Our go to place when I'm north east PA / South East New York. Been coming here since I was a kid. Quality and taste haven't changed. Amazing pizzas. Ask for the paces special. You won't regret it. Be sure to get there right when they open to avoid the wait.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Paces Special Pizza
Daniel Ruttenbur
If I could give Paces Pizzeria 10 stars, I would. My parents dated here, I grew up eating here, my children have eaten here, and now my grandchildren have, too. For generations, this place has been a constant—always consistent, always excellent. The food is delicious, the service is great, and the atmosphere feels like home. Thank you for all the memories, and I truly hope you never close
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scot Czubaj
Best pizza in the area. Being from Buffalo, while on vacation at the cottage in Lakewood we make it a point to always come here for a great pizza. Update June 2025 - still my favorite apeets parlor in the Jamestown area, I can actually say my favorite in Western new york including Buffalo. All the workers there are perfectly in sync and always attentive to needs, questions and serving quickly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Paces Special Pizza, Caprese Salad, Large Pepperoni Pizza, Pepsi Products
Chad
Great place!
Tamika Elston
Pizza was excellent. Nice crust. This was my first time and I will be back. Definitely 10/10 highly recommend.
Niklas Lane
I called to place an order and asked what options of the pizza they had. (White pizza) The woman proceeded to not even give me a chance to speak and proceeds to tell me she doesnt have the time to sit on the phone while i figure out what i wanted to order also stating how she had pizzas burning behind her. She never once gave me a chance to speak let alone make my order. She answered the phone in an awful manner right from the beginning. She then hung up and i called back to attempt to place my order again even after being treated nasty and she proceeded to tell me it was my fault i couldnt place my order then places me on hold to hang up AGAIN. Idk who this woman is answering the phones but she is atrocious and i cannot believe she is involved in running a local owned business who once before ask for the communities support themselves. I am just at a loss for words on how poorly this woman treated me. Do not recommend unless you want treated like trash.
Mary Messina
Pizza was very good. Service a little slow, our pizza took awhile to come out. We ordered salads that were $4.75 each. I expected a nice big salad but it came out with lettuce, some cheese, and 2 pieces of pepperoni. The cost was outrageous for what we got. Recommended adding some tomatoes, cucumber, onions maybe. If you make people pay $4.75 for a tiny salad at least put the regular salad toppings on it.
Robert Rothschild
Great food in far corner of NY!
BOSS R
The best in everything! And the employees showed great help) I express my gratitude! And very tasty pizza! I have never eaten this anywhere in all the states!!!
Rude waitress gave my wife attitude when she called to place the order. Wouldn't pick up after either the call was dropped or the waitress hung up. We paid 27 dollars for the 17 inch pace's special and as the pictures will show, we got 15 inches of the 17 inch pizza that was luke-warm by the time I picked it up. I was on time too.
Just noticed the bottom of the pizza box says 16". Come on.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Alisha Perry
It took them an hour to make one large cheese pizza...it was predicted to take 20 minutes.
Joseph Malovich
Among all the places in the area that sell "pizza" with premade dough and too much undercooked cheese, this place gets it right. The pizza was built with the correct proportions and done-ness. I just had a medium plain pizza. Plus when you walk in the door it actually smells like a pizza place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
McKenna Aleksivich
Love this pizza! I don't live in the area so I only get it once every once in a while but it's on the list for every visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Charles Pringle
Called in a phone order for pick up. Very pleasant on the phone, order was done on time and (of course) the salad, meatballs and pizza was delicious! Thank you for a great dinner!
Always stop when we are in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our go to place when I'm north east PA / South East New York. Been coming here since I was a kid. Quality and taste haven't changed. Amazing pizzas. Ask for the paces special. You won't regret it. Be sure to get there right when they open to avoid the wait.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Paces Special Pizza
If I could give Paces Pizzeria 10 stars, I would. My parents dated here, I grew up eating here, my children have eaten here, and now my grandchildren have, too. For generations, this place has been a constant—always consistent, always excellent. The food is delicious, the service is great, and the atmosphere feels like home. Thank you for all the memories, and I truly hope you never close
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in the area. Being from Buffalo, while on vacation at the cottage in Lakewood we make it a point to always come here for a great pizza.
Update June 2025 - still my favorite apeets parlor in the Jamestown area, I can actually say my favorite in Western new york including Buffalo. All the workers there are perfectly in sync and always attentive to needs, questions and serving quickly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Paces Special Pizza, Caprese Salad, Large Pepperoni Pizza, Pepsi Products
Great place!
Pizza was excellent. Nice crust. This was my first time and I will be back. Definitely 10/10 highly recommend.
I called to place an order and asked what options of the pizza they had. (White pizza) The woman proceeded to not even give me a chance to speak and proceeds to tell me she doesnt have the time to sit on the phone while i figure out what i wanted to order also stating how she had pizzas burning behind her. She never once gave me a chance to speak let alone make my order. She answered the phone in an awful manner right from the beginning. She then hung up and i called back to attempt to place my order again even after being treated nasty and she proceeded to tell me it was my fault i couldnt place my order then places me on hold to hang up AGAIN. Idk who this woman is answering the phones but she is atrocious and i cannot believe she is involved in running a local owned business who once before ask for the communities support themselves. I am just at a loss for words on how poorly this woman treated me. Do not recommend unless you want treated like trash.
Pizza was very good. Service a little slow, our pizza took awhile to come out. We ordered salads that were $4.75 each. I expected a nice big salad but it came out with lettuce, some cheese, and 2 pieces of pepperoni. The cost was outrageous for what we got. Recommended adding some tomatoes, cucumber, onions maybe. If you make people pay $4.75 for a tiny salad at least put the regular salad toppings on it.
Great food in far corner of NY!
The best in everything! And the employees showed great help) I express my gratitude! And very tasty pizza! I have never eaten this anywhere in all the states!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Rude waitress gave my wife attitude when she called to place the order. Wouldn't pick up after either the call was dropped or the waitress hung up. We paid 27 dollars for the 17 inch pace's special and as the pictures will show, we got 15 inches of the 17 inch pizza that was luke-warm by the time I picked it up. I was on time too.
Just noticed the bottom of the pizza box says 16". Come on.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
It took them an hour to make one large cheese pizza...it was predicted to take 20 minutes.
Among all the places in the area that sell "pizza" with premade dough and too much undercooked cheese, this place gets it right. The pizza was built with the correct proportions and done-ness. I just had a medium plain pizza. Plus when you walk in the door it actually smells like a pizza place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this pizza! I don't live in the area so I only get it once every once in a while but it's on the list for every visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Called in a phone order for pick up. Very pleasant on the phone, order was done on time and (of course) the salad, meatballs and pizza was delicious! Thank you for a great dinner!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...