Edit: The shop responded defensively, calling this a fake review. I assure you I'm a real person with over a million views on Google Reviews. I had hoped they would take the criticism and improve their pizza, but that doesn't seem to be happening. Sorry.
This was one of the worst slices I've ever had. I waited a week to write this. It's my easy for me to write bad reviews. I hate doing it. But this pizza was really really bad. If the shop changes their recipe and changes their pizza, and then comments to me that they did this, I will remove this review. But they have to change it up. It was horrible. They should go down the block to the slice shop and see how they do it. I'm writing this because this place has to change. Sorry.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
peter vanloan
Best wings around
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Geovanny
Interesting pizza options, plenty of parking. Cannoli was good too! Credit cards accepted.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jacob Sheafe
Not open until 7/28/2025
L G24
Was up there on the during my vacation got in pretty late was the one place that was still open and their pizza was amazing and I am from New York City and they have very very very good pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marilyn
The pizza was very good. I had stop coming here because it had went down during covid. I highly recommended now
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ben Cole
Nice selection of pizza. Fast and good price
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Caitlin King
It was my first time here and what we had was very good. A few different kinds of slices (pepperoni, brocolli/bacon/cheese, and mushroom) and fried ravioli. Want to try the subs next time. Menu had a variety of pizzas, subs, and pastas. They also cater and have a family pizza deal.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Samantha Yost
My favorite pizza in the area. I'm a vegetarian and their veggie and margherita pizzas are really good. I am used to other places' soggy afterthought veg pies, but 440's is really flavorful with a good texture and balance of ingredients.
Food: 5
thomas savaglio
I want to give this place more stars...however they are sacrificing quality for quantity. Canned mushrooms still wet. Meat lovers was a disappointment. PROS: -Good for highschoolers -family deal -Great Garlic Knots! CONS: -Quality (soggy, flavorless) -Small restaurant
Definitely mine and my family’s go to for dinner food is good prices are great and the staff is always friendly and polite I definitely recommend 440 pizza!
So pizza and wings are fantastic. The paninis are good. The roast beef sub just take it off the menu. The beef is brown I literally got two thick slices on a sub. By the time I folded the meat up I barely got a quarter of a sub. Disappointed.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gabrielle P
Absolutely horrible. Oil filled my box of wings. Garlic Parm wings didn’t have any flavor. Just oil, lots of oil.
Food: 1
L B-H
Wonderful tender tasty pizza crust with perfect amount of cheese and sauce on the pizza. Guys behind the counter are really nice. Small spot to sit in can get clogged with kids from school across the street, but relatively manageable. I love their mushroom pizza because they use canned mushrooms (I know, not a popular choice but it's what I like). I bought a pie to bring home with me when I left Kingston this weekend... It's that good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly Dautrich
This place is quintessential Kingston! Order by the pie or by the slice.
I highly recommend the buffalo chicken pizza, the BBQ chicken pizza, the chicken bacon ranch pizza, the white pizza, as well as all your standard pizza offerings. I also recommend the garlic knots, the wings, the fried dough, and the salads (always get the blue cheese dressing, it’s great!)
Edit: The shop responded defensively, calling this a fake review. I assure you I'm a real person with over a million views on Google Reviews. I had hoped they would take the criticism and improve their pizza, but that doesn't seem to be happening. Sorry.
This was one of the worst slices I've ever had. I waited a week to write this. It's my easy for me to write bad reviews. I hate doing it. But this pizza was really really bad.
If the shop changes their recipe and changes their pizza, and then comments to me that they did this, I will remove this review. But they have to change it up. It was horrible.
They should go down the block to the slice shop and see how they do it. I'm writing this because this place has to change. Sorry.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Best wings around
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Interesting pizza options, plenty of parking. Cannoli was good too! Credit cards accepted.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Not open until 7/28/2025
Was up there on the during my vacation got in pretty late was the one place that was still open and their pizza was amazing and I am from New York City and they have very very very good pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza was very good. I had stop coming here because it had went down during covid. I highly recommended now
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice selection of pizza. Fast and good price
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was my first time here and what we had was very good. A few different kinds of slices (pepperoni, brocolli/bacon/cheese, and mushroom) and fried ravioli. Want to try the subs next time. Menu had a variety of pizzas, subs, and pastas. They also cater and have a family pizza deal.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
My favorite pizza in the area. I'm a vegetarian and their veggie and margherita pizzas are really good. I am used to other places' soggy afterthought veg pies, but 440's is really flavorful with a good texture and balance of ingredients.
Food: 5
I want to give this place more stars...however they are sacrificing quality for quantity. Canned mushrooms still wet. Meat lovers was a disappointment.
PROS:
-Good for highschoolers
-family deal
-Great Garlic Knots!
CONS:
-Quality (soggy, flavorless)
-Small restaurant
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Definitely mine and my family’s go to for dinner food is good prices are great and the staff is always friendly and polite I definitely recommend 440 pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Buffalo Chicken, Pepperoni Pizza
So pizza and wings are fantastic. The paninis are good. The roast beef sub just take it off the menu. The beef is brown I literally got two thick slices on a sub. By the time I folded the meat up I barely got a quarter of a sub. Disappointed.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely horrible. Oil filled my box of wings. Garlic Parm wings didn’t have any flavor. Just oil, lots of oil.
Food: 1
Wonderful tender tasty pizza crust with perfect amount of cheese and sauce on the pizza. Guys behind the counter are really nice. Small spot to sit in can get clogged with kids from school across the street, but relatively manageable. I love their mushroom pizza because they use canned mushrooms (I know, not a popular choice but it's what I like). I bought a pie to bring home with me when I left Kingston this weekend... It's that good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is quintessential Kingston! Order by the pie or by the slice.
I highly recommend the buffalo chicken pizza, the BBQ chicken pizza, the chicken bacon ranch pizza, the white pizza, as well as all your standard pizza offerings. I also recommend the garlic knots, the wings, the fried dough, and the salads (always get the blue cheese dressing, it’s great!)
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ, Salad, Buffalo Chicken, Wings, lg Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Fried Dough, Garlic Knots
Loading...