Tammy is a National Treasure and all who have the pleasure of sitting in her section should be required to write a poem on the spot to pay homage to her.
Since it’s my suggestion, I’m not going to write one but am eagerly awaiting your feeble responses to try and match how awesome she is. You will fail to live up to her wittiness and you will like it! Or else… honestly, I’m terrified of her all at the same time!
Marla Dalton
So good! A definite must while in Kingston.
Victor Jung
For upstate, this is definitely a slice of Brooklyn. The wait staff is friendly and attentive. Pizza is 9.2 on Barstool if Dave were to rate the slice. The lasagna is out of this world. Worth the stop over after shopping in Kingston.
Catskills39
Possibly a chain, wait staff was fun to i tertwine with. Food was good.
Anthony Hung
Old school feeling Italian restaurant. I think it's some of the best pizza around. Thin crust, super crispy and no flop. Just the right amount of toppings without being overwhelming. Pastas, soups, breads and wings are decent. I have had better, but they were still really good. Tammy was our server and she was amazing! Super friendly and easy to get along with. Great service and a pleasure to talk too and joke around with.
Franca Cooper
Best lemonade. Pizza was tasty.
lui- g
Dawn is carring and funny I apreaciate everything thank you !
Karen Madden Dreiser
Somebody wonderful things to say about slice of Italy. The food is outstanding. My favorite part of slice of Italy is the staff they are always so kind so helpful and the food's delicious!
This was one of my favorite places to come after work, I’d drive from across town. But the last two times I had two different awful servers. One never came back to check after she dropped off my food , so I never got a soda refill or another napkin I wanted. Tonight I asked for an ice water and a coke. Guess I was lucky I got the coke at least!! And I had barely started my food and she asked if I’d want a box to take some home. I only got a sub. Caitlyn is the only server I recommend. If I could get her I’d go even more often. She’s a 5 star person!! If I really want something it’s going to be to go.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Sai
I recently dined at A Slice of Italy in New York, and I can honestly say it was the best pepperoni pizza I’ve ever had! The crust was perfectly crisp yet chewy, and the pepperoni was flavorful with just the right amount of spice. Each bite was a perfect combination of rich tomato sauce, melted cheese, and that iconic pepperoni taste.
But it wasn’t just the pizza that made the experience memorable—the service was outstanding. A sweet lady took care of everything with such warmth and attentiveness, ensuring we had everything we needed. Her friendly demeanor and genuine care for customers made the meal even more enjoyable.
If you’re looking for incredible pizza and top-notch service, A Slice of Italy is a must-visit. I’ll definitely be back to try more!
Good food. Great staff and owners!! Steve
Tammy is a National Treasure and all who have the pleasure of sitting in her section should be required to write a poem on the spot to pay homage to her.
Since it’s my suggestion, I’m not going to write one but am eagerly awaiting your feeble responses to try and match how awesome she is. You will fail to live up to her wittiness and you will like it! Or else… honestly, I’m terrified of her all at the same time!
So good! A definite must while in Kingston.
For upstate, this is definitely a slice of Brooklyn. The wait staff is friendly and attentive. Pizza is 9.2 on Barstool if Dave were to rate the slice. The lasagna is out of this world. Worth the stop over after shopping in Kingston.
Possibly a chain, wait staff was fun to i tertwine with. Food was good.
Old school feeling Italian restaurant. I think it's some of the best pizza around. Thin crust, super crispy and no flop. Just the right amount of toppings without being overwhelming. Pastas, soups, breads and wings are decent. I have had better, but they were still really good. Tammy was our server and she was amazing! Super friendly and easy to get along with. Great service and a pleasure to talk too and joke around with.
Best lemonade.
Pizza was tasty.
Dawn is carring and funny I apreaciate everything thank you !
Somebody wonderful things to say about slice of Italy. The food is outstanding. My favorite part of slice of Italy is the staff they are always so kind so helpful and the food's delicious!
The best pizza EVER!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
we went to first time we had good experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always good food and friendly people
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza, Garlic Knots, Pizza Pepperoni
This was one of my favorite places to come after work, I’d drive from across town. But the last two times I had two different awful servers. One never came back to check after she dropped off my food , so I never got a soda refill or another napkin I wanted. Tonight I asked for an ice water and a coke. Guess I was lucky I got the coke at least!! And I had barely started my food and she asked if I’d want a box to take some home. I only got a sub. Caitlyn is the only server I recommend. If I could get her I’d go even more often. She’s a 5 star person!!
If I really want something it’s going to be to go.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
I recently dined at A Slice of Italy in New York, and I can honestly say it was the best pepperoni pizza I’ve ever had! The crust was perfectly crisp yet chewy, and the pepperoni was flavorful with just the right amount of spice. Each bite was a perfect combination of rich tomato sauce, melted cheese, and that iconic pepperoni taste.
But it wasn’t just the pizza that made the experience memorable—the service was outstanding. A sweet lady took care of everything with such warmth and attentiveness, ensuring we had everything we needed. Her friendly demeanor and genuine care for customers made the meal even more enjoyable.
If you’re looking for incredible pizza and top-notch service, A Slice of Italy is a must-visit. I’ll definitely be back to try more!
Kid-friendliness: Yes
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Personal Pepperoni Pizza
A great place, enough said!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...