This restaurant is (temporarily) closed. A note on the door says "Temporarily closed, sorry for the inconvenience, stay tuned".
I drive over to see why I was getting an odd Verizon error message when I called to place an order.
I hope all is OK, we like their food and staff. I will delete this post when they are open again.
Please call them to verify before going elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Malisa Meyer
The guy that answered the phone laughed at me and was in my opinion rude because of the price the establishment had on their website. I was placing an order for almost $100 and to be treated with such disrespect it made me cancel my order. I have had pizza here and it taste great but unfortunately a new family in the community will not be utilizing this pizza place because of the unbelievable amount of rudeness that was expressed while trying to order my second time. I feel the customer service was very poor!
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Joshua Vibbert
High price, cheap ingredients,skimpy on toppings and sauce,asked for more sauce on next time around was charged another topping for it.its barely a regular amount of sauce if that .asked for 2 additional toppings one on each side pizza came with both extra toppings on one side got the order wrong. Would order somewhere but it's the only joint around. hours ,days of operation,and delivery times are lackluster
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Amanda M.
Fish Fry review: I ordered my grandparents a fish sandwich meal ($10 includes 1 large sandwich-sized piece of haddock on a hoagie bun and 1 side) each and I got the fish fry dinner ($14 for 1 large dinner-sized piece of haddock with two sides and a roll). Tartar sauce packets were included. Portions were generous and probably provide leftovers for some customers. Non-fries sides are about 6oz.
Fries were good quality and seem to be beer-battered. Fish was firm and fresh haddock in a beer batter. Mac salad was well-seasoned, good quality with tuna, egg, and carrot. Potato salad was fresh, used a softer white potato, mix of sweet and savory. Coleslaw was kinda gross, too sweet and had gone over into wilted pickled cabbage land.
Service was 10 minutes with brusque but friendly staff. I was pleasantly surprised with my experience (formerly from the area but never could find good food in town) and would return again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 5
Keren Reiser
Great place to stop off the I-81 for authentic pizza. Extremely friendly staff and delicious pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Samantha Gray
Pizza was damn good! So happy this place exists and is close by!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Douglas Rozelle
The food was excellent but what I most enjoyed was the hospitality. I don't believe I've ever been to a restaurant that provided a "family-like" atmosphere and genuine conversation. I truly wish I lived here to enjoy this place more often.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Hot Sausage Roll, French Fries
Rabbits Watching
Fish Fry review: I ordered my grandparents a fish sandwich meal ($10 includes 1 large sandwich-sized piece of haddock on a hoagie bun and 1 side) each and I got the fish fry dinner ($14 for 1 large dinner-sized piece of haddock with two sides and a roll). Tartar sauce packets were included. Portions were generous and probably provide leftovers for some customers. Non-fries sides are about 6oz.Fries were good quality and seem to be beer-battered. Fish was firm and fresh haddock in a beer batter. Mac salad was well-seasoned, good quality with tuna, egg, and carrot. Potato salad was fresh, used a softer white potato, mix of sweet and savory. Coleslaw was kinda gross, too sweet and had gone over into wilted pickled cabbage land.Service was 10 minutes with brusque but friendly staff. I was pleasantly surprised with my experience (formerly from the area but never could find good food in town) and would return again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 5
Dawn Bagliere
Temporarily in the area & ordered twice. 1st order was delivery (on time) & 2nd order was pick up, again on time. Tried the garlic parm wings, veggie basket and 6" pizza with veggies & sausage. All the food was excellent, great prices & very friendly staff. I'll be ordering again next time I'm here!
Vegetarian options: You have the option of veggie pizza, deep-fried veggies and I believe there are veggie options with the other food choices.
Parking: Seemed to be plenty of parking. Lot surface is mostly hard-pack dirt.
Jeremy Ciesla
I'd say best pizza in Lafayette but it might be the only pizza in Lafayette? So I'll go ahead and say best in Central New York, in my opinion. From the dough to the sauce and toppings its all delicious, and the wings and other sides are excellent too. The folks who own it and work here are good people so if you want great pizza and to support a local business, order from A Taste of Heaven.
Wheelchair accessibility: Ground level entrance, it should be easily accessible by wheelchair
Headed to a concert in Lafayette NY stopped at this pizza place right off exit 15. The owner was very nice and helped us get directions, and as we were sitting in our car waiting for our food. He actually came out and asked us if we wanted our sub cut or not! The meatballs on our sandwich were very good, and the price was reasonable. Highly recommend!!
Sue Ann Okoniewski
Very good pizza and wings. Had fish the week before. Excellent batter coating on the fish.
Louis Sanchez
Amazing pizza and friendly staff. My wife and I stopped from a road trip and we're happy we did
Sylas Good-Dashow
We are driving up the East coast back home to Canada, and we knew we wanted some NY pizza before we leave the state. After trying two other places that were closed, perhaps it was fate we held out, because this place was fantastic! And right off the highway so it was an easy and quick stop. Very nice service too. As we were eating in the car outside, one of the owners came out and when he saw us, he waved and asked if it was good (it was very much so!) and if we needed napkins. Would recommend to anyone who is looking for good pie!
Jennifer Henry
We had the philly steak pizza and it was delicious. Nice crust too
This restaurant is (temporarily) closed. A note on the door says "Temporarily closed, sorry for the inconvenience, stay tuned".
I drive over to see why I was getting an odd Verizon error message when I called to place an order.
I hope all is OK, we like their food and staff. I will delete this post when they are open again.
Please call them to verify before going elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
The guy that answered the phone laughed at me and was in my opinion rude because of the price the establishment had on their website. I was placing an order for almost $100 and to be treated with such disrespect it made me cancel my order. I have had pizza here and it taste great but unfortunately a new family in the community will not be utilizing this pizza place because of the unbelievable amount of rudeness that was expressed while trying to order my second time. I feel the customer service was very poor!
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
High price, cheap ingredients,skimpy on toppings and sauce,asked for more sauce on next time around was charged another topping for it.its barely a regular amount of sauce if that .asked for 2 additional toppings one on each side pizza came with both extra toppings on one side got the order wrong. Would order somewhere but it's the only joint around. hours ,days of operation,and delivery times are lackluster
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Fish Fry review: I ordered my grandparents a fish sandwich meal ($10 includes 1 large sandwich-sized piece of haddock on a hoagie bun and 1 side) each and I got the fish fry dinner ($14 for 1 large dinner-sized piece of haddock with two sides and a roll). Tartar sauce packets were included. Portions were generous and probably provide leftovers for some customers. Non-fries sides are about 6oz.
Fries were good quality and seem to be beer-battered. Fish was firm and fresh haddock in a beer batter. Mac salad was well-seasoned, good quality with tuna, egg, and carrot. Potato salad was fresh, used a softer white potato, mix of sweet and savory. Coleslaw was kinda gross, too sweet and had gone over into wilted pickled cabbage land.
Service was 10 minutes with brusque but friendly staff. I was pleasantly surprised with my experience (formerly from the area but never could find good food in town) and would return again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great place to stop off the I-81 for authentic pizza. Extremely friendly staff and delicious pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was damn good! So happy this place exists and is close by!
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was excellent but what I most enjoyed was the hospitality. I don't believe I've ever been to a restaurant that provided a "family-like" atmosphere and genuine conversation. I truly wish I lived here to enjoy this place more often.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Hot Sausage Roll, French Fries
Fish Fry review: I ordered my grandparents a fish sandwich meal ($10 includes 1 large sandwich-sized piece of haddock on a hoagie bun and 1 side) each and I got the fish fry dinner ($14 for 1 large dinner-sized piece of haddock with two sides and a roll). Tartar sauce packets were included. Portions were generous and probably provide leftovers for some customers. Non-fries sides are about 6oz.Fries were good quality and seem to be beer-battered. Fish was firm and fresh haddock in a beer batter. Mac salad was well-seasoned, good quality with tuna, egg, and carrot. Potato salad was fresh, used a softer white potato, mix of sweet and savory. Coleslaw was kinda gross, too sweet and had gone over into wilted pickled cabbage land.Service was 10 minutes with brusque but friendly staff. I was pleasantly surprised with my experience (formerly from the area but never could find good food in town) and would return again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 5
Temporarily in the area & ordered twice. 1st order was delivery (on time) & 2nd order was pick up, again on time. Tried the garlic parm wings, veggie basket and 6" pizza with veggies & sausage. All the food was excellent, great prices & very friendly staff. I'll be ordering again next time I'm here!
Vegetarian options: You have the option of veggie pizza, deep-fried veggies and I believe there are veggie options with the other food choices.
Parking: Seemed to be plenty of parking. Lot surface is mostly hard-pack dirt.
I'd say best pizza in Lafayette but it might be the only pizza in Lafayette? So I'll go ahead and say best in Central New York, in my opinion. From the dough to the sauce and toppings its all delicious, and the wings and other sides are excellent too. The folks who own it and work here are good people so if you want great pizza and to support a local business, order from A Taste of Heaven.
Wheelchair accessibility: Ground level entrance, it should be easily accessible by wheelchair
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Headed to a concert in Lafayette NY stopped at this pizza place right off exit 15. The owner was very nice and helped us get directions, and as we were sitting in our car waiting for our food. He actually came out and asked us if we wanted our sub cut or not! The meatballs on our sandwich were very good, and the price was reasonable. Highly recommend!!
Very good pizza and wings. Had fish the week before. Excellent batter coating on the fish.
Amazing pizza and friendly staff. My wife and I stopped from a road trip and we're happy we did
We are driving up the East coast back home to Canada, and we knew we wanted some NY pizza before we leave the state. After trying two other places that were closed, perhaps it was fate we held out, because this place was fantastic! And right off the highway so it was an easy and quick stop. Very nice service too. As we were eating in the car outside, one of the owners came out and when he saw us, he waved and asked if it was good (it was very much so!) and if we needed napkins. Would recommend to anyone who is looking for good pie!
We had the philly steak pizza and it was delicious. Nice crust too
Loading...