Have been to the Bayport location many times and always 5 stars. Stopped in at the mall and was surprised to see these guys up here. Food and staff 5 stars here as well. They don’t miss!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan wootle
It’s below average mall pizza. It’s pretty tasteless and inoffensive. Good prices for a mall but that garlic knot is a sin to serve. Bite sized Hawaiian rolls doused in a fake garlic sauce. Give me a
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
South Shore Catholic YA
The Pizzeria is amazing! Food and service was a 10/10! The two guys working were so kind as well. Great experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Thai Chili Slice, Upside Down Slice
Nicole Vallone-Epperson
The Pizzeria was amazing. I had my son’s birthday in the mall and we had pizza after the event. My guests all raved about how delicious the pizza was and how satisfied they were. The manager, Brian was so helpful and thorough making sure we had everything we needed and on time. Brian and his staff were so polite and on point with everything. All our needs were met and we were beyond happy with The Pizzeria! We will be back for sure!!
Great pizza, super kind and friendly people. We will for sure always come back to this location. The uncle Benny is our
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza Slice, Vodka Square Pie
stephen erato
We have had pizza here before a while ago and it was good. I dont know what happened but todaywe ordered a Regular pie and it had no taste at all it was like eating cardboard. Im hoping it was just a bad night.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Jason KErker
I work in the mall and eat this Pizza regularly. I have never gotten sick of it and can honestly say its the best pizza place around. The staff is so friendly and the pizza is amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
mother f.
First off I would like to start by saying I've been to the Lindenhurst location many of times, and have never been let down. This location on the other hand is a god damn nightmare!1!!! I first went here and instantly knew the employees were off the zaza cart, but let it slide cus the pepp pizza w hot honey sauce i got was gas. Second time I order from the same youngster as before, and experienced several complications during my visit. My order was forgotten about, and leaves the cashier giving my order which was a scillian pepp slice NO hot honey!!!!!!!! cmon!!!!! I'd also like to include the pepp liarrrr tried to gaslight me that it was what I ordered. I am not schizo but thanks ... Anyways pizza was okay 6/10 probs won't be back tho I'll stick to what I know.
Mathew Boals
Best pizza around. The chicken roll is to die for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Roll
Michelle Orellana
Amazing pizza place, everytime we go to the mall we stop by to grab a slice. Went in a couple days ago to grab my son a slice and they we’re closing out and they ended up give me a couple of different slices to take home which was really nice of the employee. Please go try there pizza i would really recommend. Thank you for the pizza and having friendly employees everyone is always so nice when we go in. Go try the yummyy pizzaaa !!!
When I think of NY pizza, this is the ideal that I’m looking for. Great crust with just the right amount of crisp. Delicious sauce. The perfect amount of cheese. And plenty of extra topping options for when you’re craving a little more than a basic slice. Round or square, it’s all really good here. The best and the most consistent pizza to be found on Long Island. I come here time and time again and never ever leave disappointed. Too many places, even ones rated an 8+ by El Pres Portnoy are hit or miss, and sometimes they miss by a lot. But this place is never a miss when I stop for a bite at the mall. Same goes for delivery from this location or the Bayport spot. Plus, they’re one of the only, maybe the only, pizza places to carry glass bottle Mexican Coke which makes my wife an extra happy customer every time. Thank you to The Pizzeria staff for dozens of great meals. I always eat a ton and still I am always left wishing I could fit even more.Parking: Huge parking lot. It’s a mall.Kid-friendliness: Kids will especially love the garlic knots. And all the pieces of pepperoni on each slice.
My girlfriend said the pizza was good here, but she is a liar. The buffalo slice is pathetic, the garlic knots are microscopic, and the lady behind the counter covered in tattoos is rude.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Alicia Gallagher
The only food place at the mall with good food service, the staff are beyond amazing. So nice, especially the girl with colored hair is super nice and polite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony William D.
My experience with this pizza place in the mall was good, not great. What was blinding my experience of the food, and the taste of the food I ordered was this rude, disrespectful, entitled, gives off the impression she's to good to be serving you, none eye contact, roll of the eye, was the greeting she gives everyone. Watching the people in front of me get disrespected made me think I was at one of the trendy rude restaurants where you pay for them to be disrespectful. For those who think it might be, it's not. Other than the person they have representing this place graces you with her presence, you get your food. Try it out, I have to say it was delicious and fresh. The garlic knots are out of this world. The sauce was perfect. The cheese amount was great. It definitely is real fresh pizza. Even though it's a little pricy I get why. It's truly delicious. It looks clean also. Kept well.
Stacey S
For a mask, their pizza is amazing. The garlic knots are to die
Have been to the Bayport location many times and always 5 stars. Stopped in at the mall and was surprised to see these guys up here. Food and staff 5 stars here as well. They don’t miss!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It’s below average mall pizza. It’s pretty tasteless and inoffensive. Good prices for a mall but that garlic knot is a sin to serve. Bite sized Hawaiian rolls doused in a fake garlic sauce. Give me a
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
The Pizzeria is amazing! Food and service was a 10/10! The two guys working were so kind as well. Great experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Thai Chili Slice, Upside Down Slice
The Pizzeria was amazing. I had my son’s birthday in the mall and we had pizza after the event. My guests all raved about how delicious the pizza was and how satisfied they were. The manager, Brian was so helpful and thorough making sure we had everything we needed and on time. Brian and his staff were so polite and on point with everything. All our needs were met and we were beyond happy with The Pizzeria! We will be back for sure!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sweet Chilli Chicken, Regular Pie, Thai Chili Slice, Sicilian Slice, Vodka Square Pie, Cheese Pizza
Great pizza, super kind and friendly people. We will for sure always come back to this location. The uncle Benny is our
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza Slice, Vodka Square Pie
We have had pizza here before a while ago and it was good. I dont know what happened but todaywe ordered a Regular pie and it had no taste at all it was like eating cardboard. Im hoping it was just a bad night.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
I work in the mall and eat this Pizza regularly. I have never gotten sick of it and can honestly say its the best pizza place around. The staff is so friendly and the pizza is amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First off I would like to start by saying I've been to the Lindenhurst location many of times, and have never been let down. This location on the other hand is a god damn nightmare!1!!! I first went here and instantly knew the employees were off the zaza cart, but let it slide cus the pepp pizza w hot honey sauce i got was gas. Second time I order from the same youngster as before, and experienced several complications during my visit. My order was forgotten about, and leaves the cashier giving my order which was a scillian pepp slice NO hot honey!!!!!!!! cmon!!!!! I'd also like to include the pepp liarrrr tried to gaslight me that it was what I ordered. I am not schizo but thanks ... Anyways pizza was okay 6/10 probs won't be back tho I'll stick to what I know.
Best pizza around. The chicken roll is to die for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Roll
Amazing pizza place, everytime we go to the mall we stop by to grab a slice. Went in a couple days ago to grab my son a slice and they we’re closing out and they ended up give me a couple of different slices to take home which was really nice of the employee. Please go try there pizza i would really recommend. Thank you for the pizza and having friendly employees everyone is always so nice when we go in. Go try the yummyy pizzaaa !!!
Recommended dishes: The Honey Pep, Regular Slice, Pepperoni Slice, Margherita, Sicilian Slice, Garlic Knots, Chicken Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
When I think of NY pizza, this is the ideal that I’m looking for. Great crust with just the right amount of crisp. Delicious sauce. The perfect amount of cheese. And plenty of extra topping options for when you’re craving a little more than a basic slice. Round or square, it’s all really good here. The best and the most consistent pizza to be found on Long Island. I come here time and time again and never ever leave disappointed. Too many places, even ones rated an 8+ by El Pres Portnoy are hit or miss, and sometimes they miss by a lot. But this place is never a miss when I stop for a bite at the mall. Same goes for delivery from this location or the Bayport spot. Plus, they’re one of the only, maybe the only, pizza places to carry glass bottle Mexican Coke which makes my wife an extra happy customer every time. Thank you to The Pizzeria staff for dozens of great meals. I always eat a ton and still I am always left wishing I could fit even more.Parking: Huge parking lot. It’s a mall.Kid-friendliness: Kids will especially love the garlic knots. And all the pieces of pepperoni on each slice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Knots, Chicken Roll, Regular Slice, Pepperoni Slice, Margherita, Margherita Pizza Slice, Upside Down Slice, Sicilian Slice, Vodka Square Pie
My girlfriend said the pizza was good here, but she is a liar. The buffalo slice is pathetic, the garlic knots are microscopic, and the lady behind the counter covered in tattoos is rude.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The only food place at the mall with good food service, the staff are beyond amazing. So nice, especially the girl with colored hair is super nice and polite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My experience with this pizza place in the mall was good, not great. What was blinding my experience of the food, and the taste of the food I ordered was this rude, disrespectful, entitled, gives off the impression she's to good to be serving you, none eye contact, roll of the eye, was the greeting she gives everyone. Watching the people in front of me get disrespected made me think I was at one of the trendy rude restaurants where you pay for them to be disrespectful. For those who think it might be, it's not. Other than the person they have representing this place graces you with her presence, you get your food. Try it out, I have to say it was delicious and fresh. The garlic knots are out of this world. The sauce was perfect. The cheese amount was great. It definitely is real fresh pizza. Even though it's a little pricy I get why. It's truly delicious. It looks clean also. Kept well.
For a mask, their pizza is amazing. The garlic knots are to die
Food: 5
Service: 5