Muscarella's Pizzeria Lancaster NY
470 Aurora St, Lancaster
(716) 683-1000
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Finger Pizza SM
Chicken Finger Sub
Chicken Wings
French Fries
Caesar Salad
Large Pizza
Sub Tuna
Daily Specials
Colossal Pizza & 30 Boneless Wings
Colossal Pizza & 30 Wings
Lg Pizza & 10 Fingers
Lg Pizza & 20 Boneless Wings
Lg Pizza & 20 Wings
Sheet Pizza & 50 Boneless Wings
Sheet Pizza & 50 Wings
Sm Pizza & 10 Boneless Wings
Sm Pizza & 10 Wings
Pizza & Calzones
Large Pizza
Small Pizza
Personal Pizza
Colossal Pizza
Calzone: Build Your Own
Sheet Pizza
Calzone: Chicken Finger
Calzone: The "Hog"
Slice
Calzone: Sicilian
Calzone: The Works
Calzone: Cheese & Pepperoni
Calzone: The Hawaiian
Calzone: The Romano
Calzone: Broccoli & Cheddar
Calzone: Steak
Wednesday Large Pizza Special
Wings & Fingers
Wings: 10pcs
Fingers Sm: 5pcs
Wings: 20pcs
Boneless Wings: 10pcs
Fingers Lg: 10pcs
Boneless Wings: 20pcs
Wings: 50pcs
Wings: 30pcs
Boneless Wings: 50pcs
Boneless Wings: 30pcs
Fingers XL: 15pcs
Specialty Pie: Per. & Sm
Chicken Finger Pizza: Sm
Chicken Finger Pizza: Per.
Steak Pizza: Per.
Steak Pizza: Sm
Sicilian Pizza: Sm
Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza: Per.
The Works Pizza: Sm
Sicilian Pizza: Per.
The "Hog" Pizza: Per.
Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza: Sm
The Romano Pizza: Per.
The Works Pizza: Per.
The "Hog" Pizza: Sm
The Romano Pizza: Sm
Specialty Pie: Lg & Sht. & Col.
Steak Pizza: Lg
Chicken Finger Pizza: Lg
Colossal Chicken Finger Pizza
Sicilian Pizza: Lg
The Works Pizza: Lg
The Romano Pizza: Lg
Colossal Romano Pizza
Chicken Finger Pizza: Sheet
Colossal Sicilian Pizza
Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza: Lg
Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza: Sheet
Colossal Broccoli & Chedder Pizza
Colossal Hog Pizza
Colossal Steak Pizza
Colossal Works Pizza
Sicilian Pizza: Sheet
Steak Pizza: Sheet
The "Hog" Pizza: Lg
The "Hog" Pizza: Sheet
The Romano Pizza: Sheet
The Works Pizza: Sheet
Submarines: Whole
Sub: Ham
Sub: Chicken Finger
Sub: Steak
Sub: Turkey
Sub: Steak Supreme
Sub: Salami
Sub: Vegetarian
Sub: Turkey Bacon Club
Sub: Royal
Sub: Bacon Cheeseburger
Sub: Cheeseburger
Sub: Italian Sausage Patty
Sub: Vincenzo Special
Sub: Tuna
Sub: Assorted
Sub: B.L.T
Sub: Capicola
Sub: Cheese
Sub: Chicken Cordon Blue
Sub: Grilled Chicken
Sub: Grilled CK Supreme
Sub: Hamburger
Sub: Musc Melt
Sub: Pizza
Sub: Sicilian Pizza Sub
Sub: Steak & Sausage
Sub: Stinger
Submarines: Half
Sub Half: Chicken Finger
Sub Half: Turkey
Sub Half: Cheeseburger
Sub Half: Pizza
Sub Half: Stinger
Sub Half: Steak
Sub Half: Turkey Bacon Club
Sub Half: B.L.T
Sub Half: Assorted
Sub Half: Ham
Sub Half: Bacon Cheeseburger
Sub Half: Capicola
Sub Half: Cheese
Sub Half: Chicken Cordon Blue
Sub Half: Grilled Chicken
Sub Half: Grilled CK Supreme
Sub Half: Hamburger
Sub Half: Italian Sausage Patty
Sub Half: Musc Melt
Sub Half: Royal
Sub Half: Salami
Sub Half: Sicilian Pizza Sub
Sub Half: Steak & Sausage
Sub Half: Steak Supreme
Sub Half: Tuna
Sub Half: Vegetarian
Sub Half: Vincenzo Special
Wraps
Wrap: Grlld Steak
Wrap: Grlld Chicken
Wrap: Chicken Finger
Wrap: Ham
Wrap: Antipasto
Wrap: Grlld Steak Supreme
Wrap: Grlld Chicken Caesar
Wrap: Grlld CK Supreme
Wrap: Assorted
Wrap: Grlld Steak Caesar
Wrap: Tuna
Wrap: Turkey
Wrap: Vegetarian
Parm Subs & Fish Fry
Parm Half: Eggplant
Parm: Eggplant
Parm: Meatball
Parm Half: Chicken Finger
Parm: Chicken Finger
Parm Half: Italian Sausage
Parm Half: Meatball
Parm Half: Steak
Parm: Italian Sausage
Parm: Steak
Salads
Salad Sm: Chefs
Salad Sm: Antipasto
Salad Lg: Grilled Chicken
Salad Lg: Chefs
Salad Lg: Antipasto
Salad Sm: Grilled Chicken
Salad Sm: Chicken Finger
Salad Lg: Julienne
Salad Lg: Gr. Chicken Caesar
Salad Lg: Chicken Finger
Salad Lg: Tuna
Salad Lg: Caesar
Salad Lg: Gr. Steak Caesar
Salad Lg: Steak
Salad Sm: Caesar
Salad Sm: Gr. Chicken Caesar
Salad Sm: Gr. Steak Caesar
Salad Sm: Julienne
Salad Sm: Steak
Salad Sm: Tuna
Sides
French Fries
Bread Sticks w/Cheese
Garlic Bread w/Cheese
Bread Sticks
Fried Cauliflower: 15pcs
Fried Mushrooms: 15pcs
Onion Rings
Fried Dough Balls
Pizza Logs: 5pcs
Garlic Bread Loaded
Mozzarella Sticks: 5pcs
Fried Zucchini: 15pcs
Tator Tots
Waffle Fries: Loaded
Loaded Fries
Waffle Fries
Jalapeno Poppers: 5pcs
Garlic Bread No Cheese
Cajun French Fries
BBQ French Fries
Sweet Potato Fries w/Honey
Blue cheese
Frankie Fries
Garlic Bread w/Cheese & Tomato
Loaded Tator Tots
Cajun Onion Rings
Beverages
Sprite: 20oz
Loganberry: 2 Liter
Cherry Coke: 2 Liter
Cherry Coke: 20oz
Diet Coke: 20oz
Orange Soda:20oz
Coke: 20oz
Root Beer: 20oz
Sprite: 2 Liter
Ginger Ale: 20oz
Coke: 2 Liter
Dasani: 20oz
Diet Coke: 2 Liter
2L Orange
Fusion Iced Tea: 20oz
Pink Lemonade: 20oz
Photos
+29 photos
+28 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I’ve been eating at Muscarellas for a while and I have never had pizza so good.The whole place looks clean and well took care of.The Italian wings are to die for.I definitely recommend to anyone.
December 2025
The service is subpar, they either wanna close earlier or not been in a good mood. Every time I come in, I see the front guy on his phone. This family business is not very friendly at all. Which you guys would stay open later for people that work the second shift
November 2024
You May Also Like
Tim Hortons - 470 Aurora St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Bakery, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Leo's Pizzeria Lancaster - 473 Aurora St
![]()
Pizza, Vegan
The Pizza Heist - 231 Aurora St
![]()
Pizza, Salad
5 Stars!