Papa's Pizza Oven
155 Lake Ave, Lancaster
(716) 288-9444
Customers' Favorites
Dash App Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza Sheet
Dash App Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza Round
Dash App Half Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza
Steak and 5-Cheese Round Pizza
Dash App Chicken Fingers 10
Dash App Chicken Fingers 5
Chicken Wings
Cheese Pizza
Menu
Photos
+15 photos
+14 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Usually I never have an issue with service or the food, today I called and placed my order while the guy was rushing me off of the phone then hung up on me, I get there to pick it up and the guy who took the order never put it in so then I waited almost an hour for a medium pizza & a single order of wings. Won’t be ordering from here for awhile.
One day it's good, one day it just isn't. It was like ordering from 2 totally different pizzerias, one of which I wouldn't order from...ever. the breadsticks last week were out of this word. Tonight, they pulled them out of the slice warmer and threw them in a box. Stale and soaked in grease. Inedible. Pizza last week was dynamite. Tonight...meh. if I were the owner, I'd be beyond angry. It's the pizza game, and inot for nothing, consistency is paramount.
First time having this pizza, I seen a pic of their pizza on FB and it reminded me of an old memory pizza favorite from Bocce pizza on Clinton St, Buffalo. I bought the large pizza double cheese and double pep. I got it with the sweet sauce and to me the sauce was too sweet i mean really too sweet. Everything else about this pizza was on point. I guess next tome I'll order regular sauce. Thanks for the choice. Not sure how others feel about the sweet sauce but i would never...
You May Also Like
Pallet Cafe - 155 Lake Ave
![]()
Cafe, Coffee & Tea
Green Buffalo Pub - 165 Lake Ave
![]()
Pubs, American, Vegetarian
Ronny's Take Out - 222 Aurora St
![]()
Pizza, Vegetarian