Papa's Pizza Oven

155 Lake Ave, Lancaster
(716) 288-9444

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Dash App Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza Sheet

Dash App Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza Round

Dash App Half Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza

Steak and 5-Cheese Round Pizza

Dash App Chicken Fingers 10

Dash App Chicken Fingers 5

Chicken Wings

Cheese Pizza

Photos

+14 photos

+13 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Grubhub

Recent Reviews

First time having this pizza, I seen a pic of their pizza on FB and it reminded me of an old memory pizza favorite from Bocce pizza on Clinton St, Buffalo. I bought the large pizza double cheese and double pep. I got it with the sweet sauce and to me the sauce was too sweet i mean really too sweet. Everything else about this pizza was on point. I guess next tome I'll order regular sauce. Thanks for the choice. Not sure how others feel about the sweet sauce but i would never...

November 2024

I am one who rarely leaves a negative review, but I had to follow through with this one. I have been looking for the best pizza place in Lancaster and I thought I found it in Papa's. It was new and crowded so I thought I'd try it. I went the first time and it was great. I went a few more times and started seeing an issue. The pizza and wings were not consistent.
Then I went one time and the customer service and wait for food was ridiculous. But today, 10/20/24,...

October 2024

This place has impeccable food! Great prices and everything was fresh and hot. I drove a long distance to try this place because I heard nothing but good things and man... I am glad I don't work there or I would eat food all day long.

September 2024

More Reviews

Restaurants in Lancaster, NY

Papa's Pizza Oven

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Papa's Pizza Oven