A few months back I stopped in to get a few slices of pizza after working all day roughly 30 minutes before they closed. They told me that they all ready cleaned everything and that they wouldn't make any more pizza for the night. Maybe change your business hours if you aren't going to actually make and serve pizza during that time. Just close earlier. Won't be stopping here any time soon.
Mary T.
went here last night at 9pm. Doors were locked but the signs blink 'open'. Called them up while standing outside their doors, asking if they were open. They said yes. I told them their doors were locked, they said that they weren't. I told them i was physically standing outside the door and again told them they were locked. (Mind you, their phone had a scratchy connection so that combined w/ their accent - was a lil hard to understand them.) They said they were coming to unlock the door (the one they orig said wasn't locked). She came to unlock the door. I go inside, saw an old man completely passed out in the front (left side) either from extreme tiredness or drunkeness. He was completely 'out' cold. 2 young kids front right on stools playing YouTube/video games full blast volume. There was nothing pizza smell about this place AT ALL. Smelled like oil mostly. Was EXTREMELY HOT inside - either no AC or idk, but outside it was in the 60's w/ a nice breeze. You'd think that any pizza place would prop a door open to let in the breeze to cool down.. Not this place. It felt like an incubated room inside w/ a weird smell. I asked for a slice of pizza. The woman didn't seem to understand me. So i said 'slice'. She goes to the back to check something, then comes back and says 'no slice. slice is done.' (I'm wondering in the meantime why are you going to the back to check for a slice when most pizzeria's have the slice in the front typically. Again, not this place). I said thank you and left. Based on this weird experience alone, I will NOT go back. The woman is probaly the best worker there but if your sign hours on the door says open until 1am in the morning, why are your doors locked? How are you going to pick up your food or order? Very weird. Then the inside is just as unprofessional. I can understand kids playing videos even at full blast volume, but to have a guy completely out cold? It doesn't look good and damn sure not like a pizzeria. Now if it's a halal place like the one reviewer said, then for the love of God, change your name! It shouldn't be pizza guys. Nothing about this place is pizza nor smells like pizza. Idk what this place is but i totally did not feel safe and I won't be back. I only went in b/c my mom adamantly wanted a slice of pizza and she doesn't like Leo's which is across the street from Pizza Guys (I love Leo's).
Sepideh P.
Awesome halal kind of food, the only thing is they are 35 minutes away and I wish they where closer to us.
Nick Brewer
After a long, hard day of work on a Saturday, I stopped by to pick up a couple of slices. I thought I'd give it a try try pizza look like it had been sitting there all day still against my better judgment. I ordered one's slice (I wanted two). I could tell by his face that he knew it'd been sitting there all day brought the pizza to the back to what I'm assuming was to warm it up. I've tasted better frozen pizza. I don't like leaving bad Google reviews, but to the pizza company in question, if you are reading this, do your customers a service and don't serve them cardboard pizza.
LS Username
$9 for a 2 cups of lettuce salad. Skip. The Margarita pizza is a cheese pizza. The pizza was decent, but don't bother with a salad or sides. The fries have no seasoning and the onion rings leave something to be desired. The salads are aggressively overpriced. I couldn't fill a soup bowl..... and the ingredients are lettuce and dressing. The markup is insane. That $0.90 worth of ingredients. Cool.
Lindsay Delano
We tried Pizza Guys through Slice ordering and got a cheese and pepperoni pizza, stuffed shells, medium wings and garlic knots. Everything was delicious. The stuffed shells were out of this world. So so much cheese on top which I loved. My fiance loved the medium wings which were crispy and saucy too. The garlic knots were great in addition to the pizza. The pizza does not have the typical cup pepperoni but it's a good change of pace with a thinner crust. We will be back! Ordering on slice was awesome too. Lower prices than doordash and other food delivery apps usually have. Great value.
E l a I n e T o d d
Wanted to like the pizza since location is so convenient & so many pizza choices. BUT, crust is not good. I like a thin crust, but this was like cardboard..no taste whatsoever, like a frozen pizza. So disappointing. Want to give a second chance, maybe try a sub or wings. But will not do another pizza unless dough recipe improves.
Hell Boy
I order from this place regularly, NOT ANYMORE.Terrible service and the staff has become irresponsible and rude.Numerous times my orders have been canceled, late or just not show up.YOU GIVE BUFFALO PIZZA A BAD NAME.1 year long customer lost.
AKM Hemayetul Islam
Best food in the area. Excellent support staffs. They do the best quality halal food in the city.
Raymond Pagan
Food was good. Hot. People was nice. Call and get to go. Dine in a little small.
I wouldn't recommend coming here at all. We came here thinking it would be a great new place considering the placement and the fact that it's pizza! But to my surprise it was not great at all. We come in and order garlic knots, fries, and a calzone. When we get the knots and calzone the dough was raw but that wasn't even the worst part. We found a black hair in our fries (no one in my family has that dark of hair) and to me that's just completely disgusting. And although I support family businesses, it just seemed like a hot mess when it came to the children. From what we know, there are about three or four children there. Two of them were just sitting on these stools watching YouTube in the corner which was fine other than their videos being on full blast but that didn't really bother me. But then they have this smaller child that has to be around 3-4 years old that they let just run around. In the front lobby/dining area, they literally barricaded their child in the front with a pizza warmer in the way. At first he wasn't a bother, he just sat on the floor and just ran around, but then this kid comes up to us and puts his fingers in our sauce and other food. It was just completely crazy the whole experience. And just the way they acted about everything was very unprofessional and the whole place just seemed like a hazard.
Andrew W.
Love this place, everyone's always nice and orders are done perfectly. Their subs and pizza are so good and definitely give the local pizza places a run for their money. My favorite is the cheeseburger sub...Delish
briancl11
I don’t normally post reviews, but this pizza really left an impression on me…a bad one. This was honestly one of the worst pizzas that I’ve ever had. Cheap, crackery crust. It really feels like a cheap frozen pizza. I’d rather save my money and get a Little Caesars hot and ready. Save your money and go to one of Buffalo’s many great pizza places.
Edwin Padilla
Ordered for the first time. Pizza is cheap like 7/11 or Little Cease but cost the same as high end restaurants. They didn't follow my order instructions either.
dominic vaccaro
Not good. This is based on the pizza. It was a greasey mess. Thin crust that given the amount of grease doesn't hold up well. Also almost no sauce..... given this was the first time I have eaten there so it could have been an off day. I have heard the wings are good, but is it is Pizza your after keep going down the road there are 2 much better places... ALSO I HAVE NO RESPECT FOR A RESTAURANT THAT HAS FAMILY AND FRIENDS WRITE FAKE REVIEWS TO HELP OUT YOUR RATING AND DEFRAUD THE PUBLIC. if you want better ratings make better food.
A few months back I stopped in to get a few slices of pizza after working all day roughly 30 minutes before they closed. They told me that they all ready cleaned everything and that they wouldn't make any more pizza for the night. Maybe change your business hours if you aren't going to actually make and serve pizza during that time. Just close earlier. Won't be stopping here any time soon.
went here last night at 9pm. Doors were locked but the signs blink 'open'. Called them up while standing outside their doors, asking if they were open. They said yes. I told them their doors were locked, they said that they weren't. I told them i was physically standing outside the door and again told them they were locked. (Mind you, their phone had a scratchy connection so that combined w/ their accent - was a lil hard to understand them.) They said they were coming to unlock the door (the one they orig said wasn't locked). She came to unlock the door. I go inside, saw an old man completely passed out in the front (left side) either from extreme tiredness or drunkeness. He was completely 'out' cold. 2 young kids front right on stools playing YouTube/video games full blast volume. There was nothing pizza smell about this place AT ALL. Smelled like oil mostly. Was EXTREMELY HOT inside - either no AC or idk, but outside it was in the 60's w/ a nice breeze. You'd think that any pizza place would prop a door open to let in the breeze to cool down.. Not this place. It felt like an incubated room inside w/ a weird smell. I asked for a slice of pizza. The woman didn't seem to understand me. So i said 'slice'. She goes to the back to check something, then comes back and says 'no slice. slice is done.' (I'm wondering in the meantime why are you going to the back to check for a slice when most pizzeria's have the slice in the front typically. Again, not this place). I said thank you and left. Based on this weird experience alone, I will NOT go back. The woman is probaly the best worker there but if your sign hours on the door says open until 1am in the morning, why are your doors locked? How are you going to pick up your food or order? Very weird. Then the inside is just as unprofessional. I can understand kids playing videos even at full blast volume, but to have a guy completely out cold? It doesn't look good and damn sure not like a pizzeria. Now if it's a halal place like the one reviewer said, then for the love of God, change your name! It shouldn't be pizza guys. Nothing about this place is pizza nor smells like pizza. Idk what this place is but i totally did not feel safe and I won't be back. I only went in b/c my mom adamantly wanted a slice of pizza and she doesn't like Leo's which is across the street from Pizza Guys (I love Leo's).
Awesome halal kind of food, the only thing is they are 35 minutes away and I wish they where closer to us.
After a long, hard day of work on a Saturday, I stopped by to pick up a couple of slices. I thought I'd give it a try try pizza look like it had been sitting there all day still against my better judgment. I ordered one's slice (I wanted two). I could tell by his face that he knew it'd been sitting there all day brought the pizza to the back to what I'm assuming was to warm it up. I've tasted better frozen pizza. I don't like leaving bad Google reviews, but to the pizza company in question, if you are reading this, do your customers a service and don't serve them cardboard pizza.
$9 for a 2 cups of lettuce salad. Skip. The Margarita pizza is a cheese pizza. The pizza was decent, but don't bother with a salad or sides. The fries have no seasoning and the onion rings leave something to be desired. The salads are aggressively overpriced. I couldn't fill a soup bowl..... and the ingredients are lettuce and dressing. The markup is insane. That $0.90 worth of ingredients. Cool.
We tried Pizza Guys through Slice ordering and got a cheese and pepperoni pizza, stuffed shells, medium wings and garlic knots. Everything was delicious. The stuffed shells were out of this world. So so much cheese on top which I loved. My fiance loved the medium wings which were crispy and saucy too. The garlic knots were great in addition to the pizza. The pizza does not have the typical cup pepperoni but it's a good change of pace with a thinner crust. We will be back! Ordering on slice was awesome too. Lower prices than doordash and other food delivery apps usually have. Great value.
Wanted to like the pizza since location is so convenient & so many pizza choices. BUT, crust is not good. I like a thin crust, but this was like cardboard..no taste whatsoever, like a frozen pizza. So disappointing. Want to give a second chance, maybe try a sub or wings. But will not do another pizza unless dough recipe improves.
I order from this place regularly, NOT ANYMORE.Terrible service and the staff has become irresponsible and rude.Numerous times my orders have been canceled, late or just not show up.YOU GIVE BUFFALO PIZZA A BAD NAME.1 year long customer lost.
Best food in the area. Excellent support staffs. They do the best quality halal food in the city.
Food was good. Hot. People was nice. Call and get to go. Dine in a little small.
Restaurantji Recommends
I wouldn't recommend coming here at all. We came here thinking it would be a great new place considering the placement and the fact that it's pizza! But to my surprise it was not great at all. We come in and order garlic knots, fries, and a calzone. When we get the knots and calzone the dough was raw but that wasn't even the worst part. We found a black hair in our fries (no one in my family has that dark of hair) and to me that's just completely disgusting. And although I support family businesses, it just seemed like a hot mess when it came to the children. From what we know, there are about three or four children there. Two of them were just sitting on these stools watching YouTube in the corner which was fine other than their videos being on full blast but that didn't really bother me. But then they have this smaller child that has to be around 3-4 years old that they let just run around. In the front lobby/dining area, they literally barricaded their child in the front with a pizza warmer in the way. At first he wasn't a bother, he just sat on the floor and just ran around, but then this kid comes up to us and puts his fingers in our sauce and other food. It was just completely crazy the whole experience. And just the way they acted about everything was very unprofessional and the whole place just seemed like a hazard.
Love this place, everyone's always nice and orders are done perfectly. Their subs and pizza are so good and definitely give the local pizza places a run for their money. My favorite is the cheeseburger sub...Delish
I don’t normally post reviews, but this pizza really left an impression on me…a bad one. This was honestly one of the worst pizzas that I’ve ever had. Cheap, crackery crust. It really feels like a cheap frozen pizza. I’d rather save my money and get a Little Caesars hot and ready. Save your money and go to one of Buffalo’s many great pizza places.
Ordered for the first time. Pizza is cheap like 7/11 or Little Cease but cost the same as high end restaurants. They didn't follow my order instructions either.
Not good. This is based on the pizza. It was a greasey mess. Thin crust that given the amount of grease doesn't hold up well. Also almost no sauce..... given this was the first time I have eaten there so it could have been an off day. I have heard the wings are good, but is it is Pizza your after keep going down the road there are 2 much better places... ALSO I HAVE NO RESPECT FOR A RESTAURANT THAT HAS FAMILY AND FRIENDS WRITE FAKE REVIEWS TO HELP OUT YOUR RATING AND DEFRAUD THE PUBLIC. if you want better ratings make better food.