Best key lime I've ever had, and the cheesecake is to die for, I love the vibe of the place it's really soothing, and the smell omg I need it as a candle, especially when they are making chowder, makes me want to buy everything 10/10
Kim Heil
The absolute freshest best pies, breads, honey & apples I’ve ever gotten out on the north fork!
Brian Montalto
Hallock’s cider donuts are the best I have had ever. Better than anything I’ve had anywhere, including New England. Baked to perfection with robust and dynamic flavor profiles. Highly recommended! 5 stars!
Meena
Make sure to check the expiration date. My husband stopped in for some donuts and wanted to surprise me with some caramel apples. He went on his lunch break, so did it in a hurry. The donuts were good unfortunately this place is too far to go back just to return the apples.
Laura Clark
Stopped here for cider donuts. The prices are outrageous $3 each! They were dry and tasteless. If you’re going to charge this per donut they best be spectacular. You can get pack of 6 apple cider donuts warm with delicious apple flavor for $8 $10 at other places on the east end. The apple fritters dry and no apples. Also $4 each! Cauliflower was wilted by the time I got home it must have been picked days ago. Please allow people to make their reviews without you telling them they are wrong. I read some of the reviews and you come back like an attack for someone having a negative opinion. Many places to choose on the east end this one is off my list.
alexthefish
Baked. Goods. I had a orange and ricotta lobster tail today. Fresh and delicious. And their plain cider was also really good. I haven't had good cider in a long time.
Kosta Rica
Amazing key lime pies and jams. Other than that - look elsewhere for much more options in local produce.
Danny Levy
Prices were very high for some items. Medium sized banana bread was $20, donuts $3, apple fritter $4. Aside from that, I didn’t find the apple fritter flavorful, it didn’t have enough apple in it. The donut also wasn’t anything unique, more so akin to a grocery store cider donut. Employees were nice.
Jean Balmir
Nice variety of home made baked goods and jams
J Kennedy
This has always been a go to place for us but that has come to an end. We stopped in super quick yesterday to pick up some flowers. As I was paying, a woman behind the counter noticed my husband having cigarette in our car. She abruptly beelined it from behind the counter, out the door and very loudly announced that it was a smoke-free property. It was loud enough that I became startled while paying and others that were in the lot all turned to look. Although my husband was sitting in our car, he obliged with “You got it” and extinguished his cigarette. She then came back into the store with a large grin, went behind the counter and began talking to another employee in a whisper, which I can only assume was about my husband, the man smoking inside of his own vehicle. While I understand more than most of the annoyances and issues of smokers, there is a way to treat people, especially those that are spending money at your business. There’s a way to approach people and address them and it seems this place needs some work on that. We shared our experience with friends and family and we’ll be getting our flowers, pies, veggies elsewhere. Treating people with kindness is actually not difficult.
Love this place!!! The best Cider with various flavors of Apple Cider. My favorites are Blackberry, Spiced, & original. The breads and cheese are delicious. Produce is exceptional. The Pies are a must (Ket Lime, Blueberry, and Apple). Do not forget the Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie in the Freezer!!! The employees (including the owner always out helping customers) are exceptional. You are a gem to Eastern Long Island!!!
Sam Stasi
Heavy duty
Jo Ann Eisner
We were so excited to visit this location , unfortunately we were very disappointed. The banana bread had a Smokey and funny taste and the chocolate chip cookies were so salty we couldn’t eat them . $28.00 down the drain :(
Mark Bodson
Very Good delicious Treats and Pies and Friendly Staff
Best key lime I've ever had, and the cheesecake is to die for, I love the vibe of the place it's really soothing, and the smell omg I need it as a candle, especially when they are making chowder, makes me want to buy everything 10/10
The absolute freshest best pies, breads, honey & apples I’ve ever gotten out on the north fork!
Hallock’s cider donuts are the best I have had ever. Better than anything I’ve had anywhere, including New England. Baked to perfection with robust and dynamic flavor profiles. Highly recommended! 5 stars!
Make sure to check the expiration date. My husband stopped in for some donuts and wanted to surprise me with some caramel apples. He went on his lunch break, so did it in a hurry. The donuts were good unfortunately this place is too far to go back just to return the apples.
Stopped here for cider donuts. The prices are outrageous $3 each! They were dry and tasteless. If you’re going to charge this per donut they best be spectacular. You can get pack of 6 apple cider donuts warm with delicious apple flavor for $8 $10 at other places on the east end. The apple fritters dry and no apples. Also $4 each! Cauliflower was wilted by the time I got home it must have been picked days ago. Please allow people to make their reviews without you telling them they are wrong. I read some of the reviews and you come back like an attack for someone having a negative opinion. Many places to choose on the east end this one is off my list.
Baked. Goods.
I had a orange and ricotta lobster tail today. Fresh and delicious.
And their plain cider was also really good. I haven't had good cider in a long time.
Amazing key lime pies and jams. Other than that - look elsewhere for much more options in local produce.
Prices were very high for some items. Medium sized banana bread was $20, donuts $3, apple fritter $4. Aside from that, I didn’t find the apple fritter flavorful, it didn’t have enough apple in it. The donut also wasn’t anything unique, more so akin to a grocery store cider donut. Employees were nice.
Nice variety of home made baked goods and jams
This has always been a go to place for us but that has come to an end. We stopped in super quick yesterday to pick up some flowers. As I was paying, a woman behind the counter noticed my husband having cigarette in our car. She abruptly beelined it from behind the counter, out the door and very loudly announced that it was a smoke-free property. It was loud enough that I became startled while paying and others that were in the lot all turned to look. Although my husband was sitting in our car, he obliged with “You got it” and extinguished his cigarette. She then came back into the store with a large grin, went behind the counter and began talking to another employee in a whisper, which I can only assume was about my husband, the man smoking inside of his own vehicle. While I understand more than most of the annoyances and issues of smokers, there is a way to treat people, especially those that are spending money at your business. There’s a way to approach people and address them and it seems this place needs some work on that. We shared our experience with friends and family and we’ll be getting our flowers, pies, veggies elsewhere. Treating people with kindness is actually not difficult.
Restaurantji Recommends
Love this place!!!
The best Cider with various flavors of Apple Cider. My favorites are Blackberry, Spiced, & original. The breads and cheese are delicious. Produce is exceptional.
The Pies are a must (Ket Lime, Blueberry, and Apple). Do not forget the Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie in the Freezer!!!
The employees (including the owner always out helping customers) are exceptional.
You are a gem to Eastern Long Island!!!
Heavy duty
We were so excited to visit this location , unfortunately we were very disappointed.
The banana bread had a Smokey and funny taste and the chocolate chip cookies were so salty we couldn’t eat them .
$28.00 down the drain :(
Very Good delicious Treats and Pies and Friendly Staff
Best grain bread
Loading...