Only Rare NYC

229-13 Merrick Blvd, Laurelton
(475) 277-2917

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Whipped Cream
Fruit Loops

Menu

Mains
Rare Cookies & Cream
Rare Banana Pudding
Rare Brownie Roll
Rare Cereal Roll
Pick 1 cereal for your ice cream flavor Pick 1 topping 1 syrup
Rare Smores
Rare Apple Pie
Rare Birthday Cake
Rare Marshmellow
Rice crispy treats.
Rare Strawberry Shortcake
Rare Candy Rolls
Rare Sweet Potato Pie
Choose your topping Choose your syrup
Rare Peach Cobbler
Rare Fruit Rolls

Vegan Toppings
Oreo Crumbs
Fruity Pebbles
Captain Crunch
Sprinkles
Coconut Flakes
Vegan Strawberry Syrup
Vegan Chocolate Syrup

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+21 photos
Photo credit: grubhub
+20 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Customer service is awesome. I love seeing people of the community serve their own community. Ice cream is unique and well made. Now all I have to do is bring my son and husband to try.
August 2025
I ordered the rolled ice cream for my daughter’s birthday and we ordered the banana pudding flavor, the candy flavor and the Oreo flavored rolled ice cream. They were all very delicious. I highly recommend. You have options of toppings like cereal or chocolate chip or whipped topping etc and also for the type of syrup that you want on top .There are lots of toppings to choose from. I can’t wait to try them all?

Vegetarian options: Lots of vegetarian type options from...
January 2024
Love this place. The staff is friendly and patient. The attendant took the time to go over my options and provided recommendations. I will highly recommend this place for an ice cream treat on a hot summer day.
May 2023

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Truth Restaurant and Lounge - 229-15 Merrick Blvd
Lounges, Caribbean, Asian Fusion, Seafood
Crown Fried Chicken - 229-7 Merrick Blvd
Chicken, Southern, Fast Food
POP'S HOUSE RESTAURANT - 229-19 Merrick Blvd

Only Rare NYC

229-13 Merrick Blvd, Laurelton, NY 11413
(475) 277-2917