The NY style pizza is always so good and on point, especially for take out.
Don Testa
Amazing Detroit style pizza and the candied Brussel sprouts Amazing!!
Kevin Kristy
Best pizza in Lewiston
Rachel Napoleon
I thought the place was bigger from the pictures than it actually is, but it was very cozy. Their is a great atmosphere here as well, although it can be quite loud because of the size. This was our second time here. The first time we didn't realize we needed reservations so we couldn't get in. Second time, had the reservations and it was no problem, we were seated promptly upon our arrival. The tables are a bit tight, but perfect and romantic for two. We ordered the charcuterie board, excellent, and the candies brussel sprouts, recommended by a friend, and they definitely didn't disappoint! We also ordered the deep dish pizza and man it was amazing! Our waitress was phenomenal as well. Due to the table being quaint, after each dish she packed it up for us and put it in a to-go bag. We also wanted to try two of the pizzas and asked when ordering if she could only bring out half of each and automatically pack the second half. And she did! Marissa, I believe that was her name, thank you so much! You were great! All in all, I will definitely order from here again, but more than likely takeout so we can spread out.
Jes H
Amazing pizza!!
Jason Sinsabaugh
Cool little spot in Lewiston. Worth the stop. Detroit and NY style Pizzas.
Paul Ziuko
Pricey but good
Troy Frymire
This is tuff because there sweet and spicy detroit pizza is one of the best in buffalo, but the service is consistently is the absolute worst. They are totally inept! Our waitress throughout the whole meal got our drinks wrong. We invited another family to join us and the waitress brought there food out and told us they made ours wrong. 25 minutes later she brought our pizza out and our friends were well finished, and the pizza was wrong again. When it came time to pay they split the bill the wrong way putting items that we didn't order on our bill. When we went to pay they told us the best they could do was take off 10% off the wrong pizza.
Scott
Immaculate experience everytime since the first time. It's hard to describe how the consistency in experience really accelerates this spot past the other in Lewiston and the Buffalo area. We always enjoy our visit here. The food is to die for - especially the pizza.
Food was phenomenal! Can't say enough about a place that offers both NY and Detroit style pizzas. Music was a bit loud and service needed a bit of work. Asked for salad before the meal and it was brought out after the pizzas. Regardless, delicious!
Daniel Branch
Great place , pay attention to wine costs , 26 bucks a glass , ouch
Eric Munoz
Very nice vibes inside. (Compared to places in Niagara Falls) The Pepperoni Pizza was so freaking amazing and my wife loved the candied Brussel sprouts !
Stacie Schirca
I can't say enough great things about Hustler’s Tavern. We recently placed a large order for a kids' birthday party, and they absolutely nailed it. The food arrived hot, fresh, and right on time—everyone at the party couldn't stop raving about how delicious everything was! We had a variety of pizzas, panko tenders and brussel sprouts. Everything was impeccable. This will definitely be our go-to spot for future events.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alejandro Munoz
Best Brussel sprouts ever! Pizza was delicious as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Heirloom Tomato Caprese, Brussels Sprouts, Custom Detroit Pizza
The NY style pizza is always so good and on point, especially for take out.
Amazing Detroit style pizza and the candied Brussel sprouts Amazing!!
Best pizza in Lewiston
I thought the place was bigger from the pictures than it actually is, but it was very cozy. Their is a great atmosphere here as well, although it can be quite loud because of the size.
This was our second time here. The first time we didn't realize we needed reservations so we couldn't get in. Second time, had the reservations and it was no problem, we were seated promptly upon our arrival. The tables are a bit tight, but perfect and romantic for two.
We ordered the charcuterie board, excellent, and the candies brussel sprouts, recommended by a friend, and they definitely didn't disappoint!
We also ordered the deep dish pizza and man it was amazing!
Our waitress was phenomenal as well. Due to the table being quaint, after each dish she packed it up for us and put it in a to-go bag. We also wanted to try two of the pizzas and asked when ordering if she could only bring out half of each and automatically pack the second half. And she did! Marissa, I believe that was her name, thank you so much! You were great!
All in all, I will definitely order from here again, but more than likely takeout so we can spread out.
Amazing pizza!!
Cool little spot in Lewiston. Worth the stop. Detroit and NY style Pizzas.
Pricey but good
This is tuff because there sweet and spicy detroit pizza is one of the best in buffalo, but the service is consistently is the absolute worst. They are totally inept! Our waitress throughout the whole meal got our drinks wrong. We invited another family to join us and the waitress brought there food out and told us they made ours wrong. 25 minutes later she brought our pizza out and our friends were well finished, and the pizza was wrong again. When it came time to pay they split the bill the wrong way putting items that we didn't order on our bill. When we went to pay they told us the best they could do was take off 10% off the wrong pizza.
Immaculate experience everytime since the first time. It's hard to describe how the consistency in experience really accelerates this spot past the other in Lewiston and the Buffalo area. We always enjoy our visit here. The food is to die for - especially the pizza.
Loved it all 4 times we went
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was phenomenal! Can't say enough about a place that offers both NY and Detroit style pizzas. Music was a bit loud and service needed a bit of work. Asked for salad before the meal and it was brought out after the pizzas. Regardless, delicious!
Great place , pay attention to wine costs , 26 bucks a glass , ouch
Very nice vibes inside. (Compared to places in Niagara Falls) The Pepperoni Pizza was so freaking amazing and my wife loved the candied Brussel sprouts !
I can't say enough great things about Hustler’s Tavern. We recently placed a large order for a kids' birthday party, and they absolutely nailed it. The food arrived hot, fresh, and right on time—everyone at the party couldn't stop raving about how delicious everything was! We had a variety of pizzas, panko tenders and brussel sprouts. Everything was impeccable. This will definitely be our go-to spot for future events.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Brussel sprouts ever! Pizza was delicious as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Heirloom Tomato Caprese, Brussels Sprouts, Custom Detroit Pizza
Loading...