After eating at a nearby restaurant, I stopped in here with my boys for desserts to go and to browse the showcase. The gentleman behind the counter was very friendly and helpful. There are so many delicious options that it made it so hard to decide. I will definitely be coming back to try more. This is a very cute bakery. Very bright and I enjoyed looking in the very clean showcases.
Greg Newman
Tater Cakes is my go to place anytime we need a cake. Always fresh and delicious. They also do a good job creating anything I ask. Great with birthday and children's cake. They also have a large selection of cupcakes, brownies and pastries! Great local bakery!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Diana W
After eating at a nearby restaurant, I stopped in here with my boys for desserts to go and to browse the showcase. The gentleman behind the counter was very friendly and helpful. There are so many delicious options that it made it so hard to decide. I will definitely be coming back to try more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anna C.
The bagels are divine. The service is impeccable. We have never been disappointed. Highly recommend!
Jay L.
wow! has this place gone down hill...we have given them many opportunities, after the pandemic, for this bakery to regain control of there quality. They have not. and resentful attitude from the lady way too many times... Save your time ,and go elsewhere.
Mallory Petrus
Ordered a peanut butter pie and a dutch apple pie for Thanksgiving! I was able to place the orders online and pay online. Received an email that the pies were ready for pick up on the day I requested. At the front desk the girl was very helpful about my questions. The pies were a big hit! Would absolutely go here again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cindy Jones
Tater cakes made the perfect birthday cake for my 8 year old grandson with only a description of what he might like, he loved it, and so did everybody else! Thank you for making a special boys day even more special!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Katherine M.
Our 12” round wedding cake was delicious! And beautiful. We described it over the phone, they executed it beautifully. They handled the short- notice order very well:)
Brandi P.
The cupcakes were delicious! I got a large selection for a grad party and they were a huge hit. The service was great, the price was great and she was super helpful and so patient with my indecisiveness. I underestimated how many cupcakes to get because people were coming back for seconds. Will definitely be using this bakery for all of my cupcakes in the future. Everything was 10/10Side note: I went to a grad party that got a cake here and the cake just wasn't as great as the cupcakes. Cupcakes are always better than cake anyway though
Kathleen Shamrock
Very nice and clean bakery and set up! I was highly impressed with the selection of items. I picked.out a half moon cookie and it was delicious!
Sent a Facebook message asking if they could make my daughter’s birthday cake (roughly 2 weeks ago). The message was read, but no one ever responded. I would have understood if they were swamped and couldn’t accommodate, but to not even respond? Weird.
Christine Savoia
Tater Cakes is hands down my favorite bakery of all time and I have lived in NYC, Pennsylvania and Honolulu to name a few! It’s family owned and operated. Everything is baked fresh daily. The muffins are phenomenal. Orange cranberry and cinnamon are the best! $5 breakfast boxes are a must. The cupcakes are delicious, the bread, the cookies. The chocolate chip cookie cake is perfection. I can’t say enough good things! The service is also amazing. The gentlemen who works there always remembers my exact order and is so friendly! Highly highly recommend!
Kenneth Goulding
We had Tater Cakes do our cupcakes for our wedding. We've been coming here for a while for their delicious cinnamon rolls and weekly rotations of different cupcakes, so we thought this place would be perfect to order from. We had 4 different types of cupcakes made totaling 120 cupcakes total. People loved them and made a great dessert for our wedding. We also had an apple pie made for mother's day a week ago which was great too! One of my favorite places in WNY for baked goods.
Saintfear
Tater Cakes is a phenomenal experience. I know everyone says that their local bakery is the best and blah blah blah. I drive 21 miles each way to come to this place. It is literally that good and worth the trip.Lets start with the rye bread. This is a very dense loaf. Heavy delicious rye. Seeded and non available. This bread toasts up something special. Fills your whole kitchen with a heavenly smell. Made a Ruben with this rye once and thought I died.The cupcakes are my wife's favourite. Super fluffy and with the perfect level of icing and toppings. They have a really good variety of flavours. We scooped up snickerdoodle cupcakes today. They were outrageous.If almond is your game, the almond bear claw is perfection incarnate. Flakey melty soft buttery almondy perfect.Saturday Only they make bagels. The bagels are literally the best damn thing I've ever had from a bakery. In the attached photo is the cheddar bagel. The crispy shell and tender inside toasted spectacularly. My brekky Sambo game stepped up a level with this.Overall. Tater cakes slaps. Go there. Ignore your diet. Let your eyes and stomach take control and thank me later.
Aaron Tomaino
I got a cake and some cake pops and they were very good and staff was nice and price was very good
After eating at a nearby restaurant, I stopped in here with my boys for desserts to go and to browse the showcase. The gentleman behind the counter was very friendly and helpful. There are so many delicious options that it made it so hard to decide. I will definitely be coming back to try more. This is a very cute bakery. Very bright and I enjoyed looking in the very clean showcases.
Tater Cakes is my go to place anytime we need a cake. Always fresh and delicious. They also do a good job creating anything I ask. Great with birthday and children's cake. They also have a large selection of cupcakes, brownies and pastries! Great local bakery!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
After eating at a nearby restaurant, I stopped in here with my boys for desserts to go and to browse the showcase. The gentleman behind the counter was very friendly and helpful. There are so many delicious options that it made it so hard to decide. I will definitely be coming back to try more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The bagels are divine. The service is impeccable. We have never been disappointed. Highly recommend!
wow! has this place gone down hill...we have given them many opportunities, after the pandemic, for this bakery to regain control of there quality. They have not. and resentful attitude from the lady way too many times... Save your time ,and go elsewhere.
Ordered a peanut butter pie and a dutch apple pie for Thanksgiving! I was able to place the orders online and pay online. Received an email that the pies were ready for pick up on the day I requested. At the front desk the girl was very helpful about my questions. The pies were a big hit! Would absolutely go here again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tater cakes made the perfect birthday cake for my 8 year old grandson with only a description of what he might like, he loved it, and so did everybody else! Thank you for making a special boys day even more special!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Our 12” round wedding cake was delicious! And beautiful. We described it over the phone, they executed it beautifully. They handled the short- notice order very well:)
The cupcakes were delicious! I got a large selection for a grad party and they were a huge hit. The service was great, the price was great and she was super helpful and so patient with my indecisiveness. I underestimated how many cupcakes to get because people were coming back for seconds. Will definitely be using this bakery for all of my cupcakes in the future. Everything was 10/10Side note: I went to a grad party that got a cake here and the cake just wasn't as great as the cupcakes. Cupcakes are always better than cake anyway though
Very nice and clean bakery and set up! I was highly impressed with the selection of items. I picked.out a half moon cookie and it was delicious!
Restaurantji Recommends
Sent a Facebook message asking if they could make my daughter’s birthday cake (roughly 2 weeks ago). The message was read, but no one ever responded. I would have understood if they were swamped and couldn’t accommodate, but to not even respond? Weird.
Tater Cakes is hands down my favorite bakery of all time and I have lived in NYC, Pennsylvania and Honolulu to name a few! It’s family owned and operated. Everything is baked fresh daily. The muffins are phenomenal. Orange cranberry and cinnamon are the best! $5 breakfast boxes are a must. The cupcakes are delicious, the bread, the cookies. The chocolate chip cookie cake is perfection. I can’t say enough good things! The service is also amazing. The gentlemen who works there always remembers my exact order and is so friendly! Highly highly recommend!
We had Tater Cakes do our cupcakes for our wedding. We've been coming here for a while for their delicious cinnamon rolls and weekly rotations of different cupcakes, so we thought this place would be perfect to order from. We had 4 different types of cupcakes made totaling 120 cupcakes total. People loved them and made a great dessert for our wedding. We also had an apple pie made for mother's day a week ago which was great too! One of my favorite places in WNY for baked goods.
Tater Cakes is a phenomenal experience. I know everyone says that their local bakery is the best and blah blah blah. I drive 21 miles each way to come to this place. It is literally that good and worth the trip.Lets start with the rye bread. This is a very dense loaf. Heavy delicious rye. Seeded and non available. This bread toasts up something special. Fills your whole kitchen with a heavenly smell. Made a Ruben with this rye once and thought I died.The cupcakes are my wife's favourite. Super fluffy and with the perfect level of icing and toppings. They have a really good variety of flavours. We scooped up snickerdoodle cupcakes today. They were outrageous.If almond is your game, the almond bear claw is perfection incarnate. Flakey melty soft buttery almondy perfect.Saturday Only they make bagels. The bagels are literally the best damn thing I've ever had from a bakery. In the attached photo is the cheddar bagel. The crispy shell and tender inside toasted spectacularly. My brekky Sambo game stepped up a level with this.Overall. Tater cakes slaps. Go there. Ignore your diet. Let your eyes and stomach take control and thank me later.
I got a cake and some cake pops and they were very good and staff was nice and price was very good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake