Cafe Piccolo Pastry & Bagels

Had a birthday cake done for my daughter’s birthday and Luigi (baker) made it to Perfection. Red Velvet cake. Delicious and gorgeous looking cake. He also made me chocolate covered strawberries and never tasted such delicious chocolate before. Highly recommend and cannot wait to go back.

Order a ton of desserts varying from angel food cake to donuts to Italian pastry’s and everything was perfect. The donuts were to die for so light and airy they were perfect. The cupcakes, cookies and pastry’s were perfectly made with love. The angel food cake was perfect, the fruit and cream was so fresh. All of our guest asked where the desserts came from! I highly recommend using this bakery for all your future needs big or small.

Order a ton of desserts varying from angel food cake to donuts to Italian pastry’s and everything was perfect. The donuts were to die for so light and airy they were perfect. The cupcakes, cookies and pastry’s were perfectly made with love. The angel food cake was perfect, the fruit and cream was so fresh. All of our guest asked where the desserts came from! I highly recommend using this bakery for all your future needs big or small.

Absolutely divine! The pastry cakes literally just fall apart when you eat them. The bagles are so soft. The breakfast sandwiches are delicious, I've never had a fluffy fried egg but omg they did it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The best bakery in Mahopac, the food is amazing and fresh.I Super recommend this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Full transparency? Everything looks great! The cheesecake was fine. The rainbow cookies tasted a little stale. But… the cannolis were -dare i say- disgusting? Have you ever had a red hot? That’s what the cannolis taste like. So sad. ? i used to get pastries at this place all the time, but the new ownerships unfortunately seems to have taken a turn for the worse. Won’t be around for long.. sorry to the community.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Old school bakery great food service and folks. Authentic nyc vibe

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Awesome bakery. They even have gluten free items

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

This is the real deal people. If you want traditional Italian pastries and cakes, look no further. Everything is top notch and quality. Nothing frozen or pre made. Can’t recommend them enough. Lou is the nicest man and is family is so kind. These places are getting harder to come by each passing year. Those who know, know.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

As soon as I walked in, I knew this bakery was the real deal. Sweet aroma of delicious pastries in the air, an abundance of options and excellent customer service. I knew it was unlikely I'd find a whole strawberry cheesecake same day but Cafe Piccolo really came through for me! Even though they had plain cheesecake they were so kind to turn it into a strawberry cheesecake so last minute. Everyone in my family loved it! My family and I will definitely return here to try their other pastries ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent bakery, love the cakes, pastry and bread. So nice to have a superior local baker!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Yes, 11 months ago, under that ownershipI had only gone there, if I remember I wasn't impressed with their bake goods!!!BUT NOW, under new ownership, it's like when you walk into the bakery, it smells like an old-fashioned bakery that I worked in when I was 14, yrs old and I'm 76 yrs old now☺️The bakery products not only look delicious but also the quality,taste,presentation, service,owner, and baker literally come out to talk to you?‍♀️The best of all they make Prune Danish ?You can find Prune Danish anywhere anymore!!!They have fresh gluten-free products,and the Napoleon cake is to die for!!!Cakes are like eating a heavenly cloud of pure ingredients!!!So if you stopped going to this bakery because of the past owner, you are missing out on a special dessert or breads, and especially the people who own or work there?❤️ my Prune Danish

Dietary restrictions: Read the post!!!

Kid-friendliness: Kids will love their special kiddie cookies or birthday ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

OMG..Finally a local bakery that doesn't suck! Seriously- these guys are old school..the only thing they don't do on site is the bread. All cookies, cakes, pies etc are made there and the taste and quality is excellent. You will know when you take a first bite that this is the real deal- not grocery store. They have a european coffee machine so they do euro-class coffee drinks. I had a latte and it was great. Awesome! We will most definately be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

In need of a good old fashion Italian bakery ,this is the place to go. Louie the owner is great, fantastic bakery items. Take it from a former multiple Bakery owner and operator.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stop in This Morning ...picked up some bread and a black and white cookie.& coconut Danish.Very very good....fresh everything!I should have doubled up!!!