Alessia's Trattoria

551 Halstead Ave, Mamaroneck
(914) 315-4799

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kevan Oryani

Incredible food and atmosphere. Some of the best Italian food in Mamaroneck. Chicken Scarpariello was delicious!!

Jodie Scozzafava

We held our school's retirement dinner at Alessia's last night, and from the first planning phone call to the last coffee served, the event could not have been more perfect. Antonella and Anthony were an absolute pleasure to work with and were so accommodating to our requests and need for flexibility. The food was incredible and the service was impeccable. If you are looking for a place to host a party or to just go to dinner, you must try this gem of a restaurant.

Angela Palermo

I had a great experience at Alessia's. I treated my husband to a Father's Day dinner along with our two girls and we very impressed. The service was exceptional, and the food was absolutely delicious! We started with the Burrata and watermelon salad, which was refreshing and linguine with white clam sauce was simply delightful. My husband enjoyed the special of the day, tripe while our children devoured the pizza, mozzarella sticks and a Caesar salad everything was top-notch. The drinks were equally fantastic and we ended our meal on a high note with the Alessia Affogato- a must have! The big chocolate chip cookie with ice cream was the perfect treat for our girls and they loved every bite. I would definitely recommend Alessia to anyone looking for great food, drinks, outstanding service, and a wonderful ambience.

lauren capetillo

We had our son’s baptism party at Alessias - the staff was great at accommodating our time and party size. The waitstaff was very attentive and the drinks were great! Calamari was a crowd favorite. Portions are massive and easily shareable

Linda Mione

Great food and ambiance

Less D

My mom and sister hosted my bridal shower at Alessia’s Trattoria and the day could not have been more perfect! The restaurant is beautiful and modern and allowed us to really bring our vision to life. Antonella and her husband were amazing and so easy to work with. The staff was friendly and attentive to all of our guests. So many people came up to me raving about the food, especially the pastas! They even did a cute little celebration for my nonnas birthday which made the day so much more special. The entire day was beautiful and I can’t thank everyone at Alessia’s enough!

Diane Miceli

We celebrated my son‘s confirmation this weekend at Alessia’s Trattoria. They did an amazing job. The food was spectacular and the service was five star!! ⭐️

Nicholas Carbone

Amazing from start to finish! We struck out at a few other places for our sons baptism and we were referred to Alessia's by our friend who lives nearby. We went for dinner first before we finalized everything. The dinner was amazing the service specifically our waiter who also ended up being our waiter the day of our event was top notch. The overall atmosphere (vibe) of the restaurant was exactly what we were looking for. Working out the details with Antonella and her staff was very easy and they were more than flexible and accommodating to everything we were looking for. The day of the event they made everything seamless and so easy for us. We had a large group of kids and they were very helpful and flexible in pleasing all of them. It was truly a perfect place for our event of 30 people. The food was all cooked perfectly the food was delicious and the portions were perfect. We could not be more happy to have our event at Alessia's and going forward we will be having many more there. We traveled from 45 minutes away and it was worth every second.

Stephanie Puglia

We love this place! We started going to Antoninos years ago so we were hesitant to try it just being a creature of habit. And just like Antoninos,Alessias DID NOT disappoint! Our server Marco and Host Melissa are always top notch, so welcoming and friendly! The food is beyond amazing 🤩

Jane Allen

Excellent food , service, atmosphere, just everything was excellent!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Erny Bonistall

We thoroughly loved it. We had a party of 8 for a great dinner. We loved the atmosphere. We shared several yummy appetizers for the table, wine & cocktails. I believe we all had different mains which were great from seasonal specials to standards. They have a great birthday desert celebration too. Everyone seemed to also have a wide variety of deserts. Everything was awesome. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mediterranean Salad, Cannoli, Tiramisu

Eliza Lu

We love Alessias trattoria! Delicious food and great atmosphere

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jim

You can utilize their valet parking at no charge or you can park on the street. The valet attendant commented on our dress implying we were overdressed. I was wearing jeans, a button down with a jacket. My wife also dressed in a similar style. The food was just OK. Nothing wrong with it but also nothing to remember. The menu reminded me of the red Italian section of a diner. They will have that one dish you always order but they don't appear to have a signature. It was just OK.

Matt

Tried this place based on the high reviews on Google but it was not my experience. We parked in the lot and walked in the back and the hostess barked at us to come to the front to be seated which kind of set the tone. The bread was the highlight of the meal. Chicken scarp was just ok and the special pasta, which was supposed to be fettuccine arrabiata was just a lump of overcooked noodles with no real sauce, and a lump of hot peppers. Padre Pio is a block away and on another level from every perspective in my view.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Rodney Bell

Really nice place with decent service but was underwhelmed with the food the few times we have gone.

Dietary restrictions: I’ve been told they actually have a great gluten free pizza

Kid-friendliness: Relatively kid friendly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Loading...