New York Pizzeria

$$ • Italian, Pizza, Chicken Wings

1 E Main St, Marathon
(607) 849-7877


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for New York Pizzeria

Stopped in for dinner.Asked if we could eat in. Was told to take a seat. Not told you had to order at counter. placed order for two pizzas, ask if we could get side salad. Was told you could only order salad with dinner! Waited for pizzas , heard several comments to customers as they came in that their pizzas wasn't made correctly.We got 1 pizza brought to our table, was told they would bring out paper plates, never saw them. Second pizza was not made at the same time full review

They made it right. Pizza and breadsticks were adequate but when I stood there for a minute or two without anyone waiting on me, I was apologized to and given a small additional desert for free for the trouble. That’s the difference between me never coming back to your restaurant again and me giving you a 5 star review… the little things matter

We stopped here on our way back to North Carolina. The pizza tasted amazing and everyone was so friendly. Would definitely go out of our way to eat here again if we come back. Thank you for a wonderful lunch.

More Reviews(63)


Monday Closed
Tuesday 11AM - 8PM
Wednesday 11AM - 8PM
Thursday 11AM - 8PM
Friday 11AM - 8PM
Saturday 11AM - 8PM
Sunday 3 - 8PM