Buddy Boy's Pizzeria

1022 Rte 9W, Marlboro
(845) 236-2366

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tyler Eisloeffel

Ordered a medium half bbq chicken half buffalo chicken pie (bbq and buffalo sauce base). Perfect amount of sauce, cheese, and chicken. Cooked perfectly and was nice and hot. Excellent pizza!

Nasreen Islam

It was decent. They were pretty accommodating,

Erin Miller

They don't skimp on the toppings! Great crust, perfect sauce, right amount of cheese. Was just passing through and found this gem of a pizza place! Staff were friendly too! Thank you!

Melody Vona

We just ordered pizza. VERY VERY GOOD!!!!! NICE & CRISPY. AND ALSO A G/F PIZZA. SOOOO GOOD!!!! TY!!!

Andrew Moore

Two men, Brandon and Kevin brought me a pizza so legendary that I shed actual tears. I physically shed manly tears over just the pizza.

I'm 36 years old, I've never cried over food before. Mr. Wayne, you are the Batman of the food industry, I will be driving an hour to this place at some point to bask in your glory.

Thank you for being amazing.

Jeffrey W Holmes

The best by far! Greatest Stromboli I have had by far price is Great for the size! (Please don't down size them!) Can't say enough about them. Will definitely be back to try other things 😌

Troy Turkatte

Friendly staff and good pizza

Kat M

We order from them a lot and we always enjoy the food. We usually get pizza and wings of some variety. But I have to say the pizza we got recently was the best one so far. We ordered the Chicken Alfredo pizza with no red sauce, just Alfredo and it was FIRE. So good and delicious that this might be my new favorite pizza. Thanks Buddy Boys! We appreciate yall every time.

Sophia Aponte

I could write this entire thing but to sum it up: the owner/lead guy there has a poor demeanor, like he doesn't want to be there and complains about why. Not very welcoming, especially if you get there closer to closing time which happened because we do wrestling up the street, late. Gave it another try and the requested pizza slice was thrown together and tasted worse than it did the first time. We won't be back there solely because of the demeanor behind the service...the pizza can't even make up for it.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

DM 83

Wayne is a local that takes pride in his food. Even though it is a Pizza place he has the best burgers around. The Sausage and peppers is my other favorite.

George Dudar

Great food. Great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Rockwell

fast and friendly service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, Chicken Parm Sub, Pepperoni Pizza, Meatballs, Family Stromboli, Honey BBQ Boneless Wings, Cheesesteak, Chicken Caesar Wrap

Bobby Langley

I can see why it’s got the 4.8 star ratings. Decided to hit it for a couple slices and knots on the way to an orchard instead of getting an overpriced 10” pie there…

Probably going to try a slice of the bacon chicken ranch on the way home after seeing it there.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Knots

Saturday STEAM

Really really good pizza!!! Friendly kind owner and staff. Crispy and and the cheese was so good. Delicious

sean webster

Pizza I believe was over cooked didn't taste the way I hoped I am slightly disappointed. Good service though.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

Loading...