The Sicilian Pizza & Pasta

CLOSED

55 Middle Rd, Mattituck

The Sicilian Pizza & Pasta Reviews

Delicious food! This place is like the old Italian places that one used to find throughout Brooklyn and Queens in the 1950s and 1960s. Pizza was full of flavor, and the sauce on my grandkid's spaghetti (which, by the way, was cooked to order) was scrumptious! The proprietor was genuine, friendly and accommodating! Brought back fond memories of those wonderful, family owned, small pizza places of the past. Don't pass it by!

I love this place. The place has my family's favorite slice on the North Fork. We stop here every time we're out. The proprietor is a lovely guy; he always recognizes us and never fails to cheer us up. Once he and his daughter were shucking fresh peas when we came in and gave us each a handful. He makes his own sauce from scratch, of course, and it's excellent. If I had a place like this in my neighborhood I'd be happy as a clam.

This pizza was okay. Not a good representation of what New York pizza should be. I have had better NY style pizza at other pizza places on the island and outside of New York State. Kind of over priced at $2.55 a slice and a small Pepsi for $2. At least the cups were compostable.

More Reviews(22)

Ratings

Updated on: