Italian Restaurants near Mattituck

1
A Mano

A Mano Italian • $$
13550 Main Rd, Mattituck

Customers` Favorites

Flourless Chocolate Cake
Homemade Bread with Oil
Chicken Parmigiana
Fritto Misto

“First time dining at aMano and I was back 5 days later. The food was excellent and the staff couldn't have been nicer. This is a very welcoming establishment from the moment you walk in. Last night we ate at the bar and again had An outstanding meal and great service. Looking forward to trying more of the menu.“

3.8 Good47 Reviews

2
Basso

Basso Wine Bar • $$
10200 Main Rd, Mattituck

Customers` Favorites

Charcuterie

“For those in search of an enchanting escapade that promises to whisk you away to the charming ambiance of an Italian enoteca, Basso beckons. This delightful spot offers an exquisite selection of fine wines paired with a delectable array of house-made culinary delights that epitomize the essence of Italian fare.Do your palate a favor and inquire about the daily specials; they are nothing short of spectacular. The flavors are thoughtfully curated and promise to be a highlight of your dining experience. While indulging in the delightful sips and savory morsels, don't miss the chance to peruse the market items. Here, you will discover a trove of unique and irresistible treats that capture the authentic tastes of Italy.The team at Basso takes hospitality to heart, going above and beyond to ensure that every guest's needs are not just met, but exceeded. They strike the perfect balance between professionalism and warmth. Should you welcome it, they are eager to engage in vibrant conversation, adding a personal touch to your visit that is as memorable as the cuisine.Basso provides a cultural journey that promises satisfaction to both the gourmand and the convivial spirit in search of connection and a genuinely Italian experience, one delightful bite and conversation at a time.“

3.9 Good15 Reviews
Michelangelo Pizzeria Pizza • $$
10095 Main Rd, Mattituck

Customers` Favorites

Broiled Seafood Platter
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Vegetable Pizza
Fritti Di Mare

“Lovely dinner with my family last night. Waitstaff could have came around to keep drinks full and make sure our needs were met. Food was delicious but someone needs to please clean that pizza oven. Burn bottom and crust was a bummer as everything else was very nice. Photo is my take home slices. All three pies were this way. Such a shame. My family came from MA.“

3.4 Good43 Reviews
Maroni Southold Italian
54195 Main Rd, Southold - 7.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Toasted Marshmallows over Chocolate Mousse
Ribs with Gummi Bear Glaze
Chicken Parmigiana
Sushi Tuesday

“Maroni Southold was an unforgettable dinner experience. It’s such a beautiful modern atmosphere and the food deliciousness certainly matches the beauty and friendliness of the staff. I did the mini tasting and my wife had the lobster bisque, meatball, penne and zucchini. Everything was absolutely incredible. The perfect place for our 10 year anniversary “

4.9 Superb35 Reviews
Centro Trattoria & Bar Italian • $$$
3525 336 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 8.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cavatelli Carbonara
Chicken Parmigiana
Pomodoro Mussels

“Went for a birthday dinner with a group of 6. The service was A1. Very nice and helpful. The table was also a horseshoe shape that was nice for the group to interact.It was restaurant week. The food was good, above average. Nothing blew us away but it was good.I will go back.“

4.4 Superb56 Reviews
Slice of the Hamptons Pizza • $
20 County Rd 39, Southampton - 9.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Meatballs or Sausage
Bruschetta Pizza
Grilled Chicken
Peter's Grandma
Chicken Wings
Longwood Hero
Eggplant Roll
Caesar Salad

“The owner is so super friendly. The pizza was really good. I like the care taken with the preparation and service. Pro tip: look for the Dunkin Donuts to turn in to the parking lot that is right before the gas station. It is a lovely place to grab a slice and enjoy being in South Hampton.“

4.7 Superb62 Reviews
Villa Paul Italian • $$
162 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 7.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oysters Rockefeller and Oysters Casino
Roast Long Island Duckling
Chicken Parmigiana
Almond Joy Sundae
Veal Saltimbocca
Eggplant Tower
Fried Calamari
Onion Soup
Baked Clams
Escargot

“Food was excellent and service was very attentive. I think prices are reasonable. Was disappointed that we had to sit in the other room on Valentine's Day...it was bright and no fireplace. No real decor. The main dining area was much nicer.“

4.7 Superb39 Reviews
Edgewater Restaurant Italian • $$$
295 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 7.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan
Blueberry Waffle
Side of Risotto
Fried Calamari
Shrimp Risotto
Lobster Pasta
Garlic Bread
Crab Bisque
Lamb Chops
Tiramisu

“Came here for a bridal shower and couldnt believe the view and food! The spaghetti and meatballs was extraordinarily delicious and they kept the amazing bread coming! I even asked for extra to take home. They did an amazing job hosting the bridal shower. I have it on my radar to go back for dinner in the near future as well. Great experience here.“

4.3 Superb100 Reviews
Lenny's Pizza & Bistro (AKA Lenny's of Jamesport) Pizza • $
1451 Main Rd, Jamesport - 4.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sicilian Square Pie
Chicken Francaise
Mozzarella Sticks
Buffalo Chicken
Caprese Salad
Buffalo Wings
Baked Clams
Baked Ziti
Pizza

“We had a great experience at this Italian pizza restaurant! It exuded that old school Brooklyn style that's hard to find these days. Walking in, it felt like my grandmother was there to take care of us. She was incredibly sweet, attentive, and showered us with love. Now, onto the food - we ordered the SPINACH ARTICHOKE pizza, and it was an absolute delight. The combination of mozzarella, spinach, artichokes, and asiago was a heavenly mix, and it came to our table piping hot and incredibly fresh. We couldn't resist trying the bruschetta, which was a unique treat. The toasted bread was perfection, and the "make your own" bruschetta mix in a small bowl was a fun touch. Garlic bread topped with chopped tomato, basil, garlic, onion, and Romano cheese - pure deliciousness! One of the highlights was Larry's freshly baked bread for the table. Watching the butter melt off that warm, crusty bread was a sensory delight. Personally, I dipped mine in olive oil, and it was a match made in heaven. We also indulged in the spaghetti and GNOCCHI, and each bite took me back to my nonna's kitchen. The potato pasta with Parmesan cheese, paired with a choice of Vodka, Alfredo, Tomato, or Marinara sauce, was a nostalgic taste of home. This place is a definite home run in my book. The ambiance, the service, and, most importantly, the food make it a must-visit. I'll be back for sure, and I highly recommend it to anyone in search of a memorable Italian dining experience!“

4.4 Superb37 Reviews
Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant Pizza • $$
1271 Noyack Rd, Southampton - 7.75 miles

Customers` Favorites

Seared Local Calamari
Pizza

“I can’t believe I drove past this place for years. Finally stopped in for dinner with my husband and we loved it so much we came back a week later. It feels local and yet classy. The staff is great, and the food comes out quick, even with a full dining room. Nepolean style pizza is delicious, pasta and gelato from scratch are a must. We are definitely adding this to our rotation of regular spots. Great food for reasonable prices is hard to find out here and they nailed it.“

4.3 Superb29 Reviews
Grana Trattoria Antica & Enoteca Italian • $$$
1556 Main Rd, Jamesport - 3.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Wood Roasted Eggplant Pizza
Wild Mushroom Pizza
Eggplant Parmigiana
Margherita Pizza
Grilled Octopus
Not Your Mom
Fig Pizza
Jamesport
Grana
Salad

“We celebrated my birthday today! Brett was amazing! The whole restaurant sang for me. The food was delicious. I didn’t even care the food took a little time because I was having too much fun. I definitely recommend this gem! Amazing!! Will come “

4.2 Good94 Reviews
Uncle Joe’s Pizza & Parlour - The Hamptons Institution Since 1968 Pizza • $$
42 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 7.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Kid's Spaghetti with Marinara Sauce
Kid's Penne Alla Vodka
Meatball Parm Platter
Italian Cheesecake
Chicken Parmigiana
Veal Parm Platter
Seafood Marinara
Side of Broccoli
Chicken Francese
Chicken Marsala

“Absolutely delicious food surrounded by a beautiful atmosphere! I had the pleasure of eating here after the grand re-opening and I couldn’t have been more pleased. Staff was lovely! My favorite things that I ate were the Hamptons White slice (unreal, roasted garlic flavor), eggplant Parmesan (fried to perfection with the perfect tomato sauce), and of course the Doughknots. Delectable fried dough knots served with dipping sauces. My recommendation would be to have the marscapone dipping sauce. It’s incredible! Well done Uncle Joe’s ???“

4 Good73 Reviews
Cucina 25 Pizza • $$
12 W Main St #2802, Riverhead - 8.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Penne Bolognese Pasta
Classic Cheese Pizza
Chicken Parm Hero
Chicken Parmesan
Penne Florentine
Lobster Ravioli
Choice of Pasta
Grilled Chicken
Fried Calamari
12 Garlic Knots

“Highly recommended! My wife and I visited on a Monday and found they had a fantastic offer available on this day. We had a starter, main, and dessert for only $17.95 which is such a great deal. We both loved our food. It was busy but the server was attentive and cheerful despite having other customers to see. We'll be back!“

4.2 Good65 Reviews
SLICE OF 48 Pizza • $
46455 County Rd 48, Southold - 7.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Side of Meat Sauce
Garlic Knots
BBQ Chicken
Sausage

“Ordered a cheese pie for delivery and it was more affordable than the other nearby options. From placing the order to the delivery driver the staff was very friendly. Plus the pie was delicious! Added a picture of the box because it's a nice touch!“

4.1 Good13 Reviews
Sergio's Pizza Pizza • $
739 Old Country Rd, Riverhead - 7.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan
Pizza Special
Veggie Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Everything
Sicilian

“The best pizzeria ever seriously!! Super amazing staff, very helpful !! I got a catering order from them delivered all the way to ronkonkoma and couldn't be more happier . The food , the experience, the delivery , the price everything was seriously perfect. 1000x recommend .“

4.1 Good35 Reviews
Touch of Venice Italian • $$$
28350 Main Rd, Cutchogue - 2.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Shrimp in Scampi Sauce
Linguine Con Vongole
Linguine with Clams
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Stuffed Artichoke
Grilled Swordfish
Chicken Briano
Seafood Pasta
Baked Clams
Rice Balls

“Interior is warm and inviting, our server was exceptionally welcoming and friendly with myself and wife. Was never rushed and maintained welcomed intervals of time between courses. The choices were enticing but the specials are what we ordered and they were delicious. Presentation hit the mark and cocktails were great. I would gladly recommend Touch of Venice to everyone. Truly an enjoyable experience in fine dining.“

4.1 Good49 Reviews
Barrila's Pastaria Restaurant & Bar + Catering Services & Event Venue Italian • $$
300 E Main St, Riverhead - 8.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spinach and Cheese Ravioli
La Pastaria Risotto Fungi
Shrimp Francaise
Spinach Ravioli
Lasagne
Burrata
Seafood

“I had an amazing meal and evening in this restaurant last week. The food, staff and atmosphere were pitch perfect. I have no reservation recommending this place to anyone. My monkfish was wonderful! The rose was wonderful. The professional staff was wonderful. It will be my go to spot when I dine with people who appreciate wonderful.“

4 Good87 Reviews
Paul's Italian American Restaurant Italian • $$
21 Hill St, Southampton - 10.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Onion Soup
Garlic Bread
Waffle Fries
Chicken Parm
Clams

“It’s outdated, the food isn’t high quality, but it’s a Southampton institution. That being said, my husband and I went on a date night we’re we ordered one slice of pizza from 10 places from Wainscott to Hampton bays and Paul’s had the best slice. A bottle of Caesar dressing is always in the fridge. Don’t come here expecting much from the regular menu, and staff is always rotating so service is iffy. Stick with the pizza and you won’t be disappointed“

3.9 Good36 Reviews
Melrose East Restaurant and Pizza Pizza • $
801 County Rd 39 #2, Southampton - 8.84 miles

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knots

“Food was good, we ordered pizza and a burger. Portion sizes vs price was very solid. Fast time from ordering to service.Very nice staff and good restaurant atmosphere. Definitely recommend for lunch or a quick pizza stop.Parking: Parking lot was small and traffic plus parkinglot size made leaving the lot very difficult.“

3.9 Good37 Reviews
Roma Pizzeria Pizza • $
31455 Main Rd, Cutchogue - 3.36 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Pie
Marinara Sauce
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots

“I order pizza here pretty regularly but last night I placed an order. They forgot a slice- which they refunded when I called. And I should have checked. However I got the baked pasta trio and the ricotta cheese in the stuffed shells and manicotti and lasagna was sour. It must have gone bad. So that $20 dish was thrown in the garbage. The marina very bland. I admit I was surprised. I chalk it up to life but hope someone checks that cheese because I wasn’t the only one that tasted it. Didn’t feel like calling again to complain after calling during dinner to say I never got a slice. Service is always friendly and prompted. Sometimes it’s busy and some of the reviews here show that they have never worked in a restaurant, especially after 2020- it stresses me out going anywhere. I can’t imagine how it is dealing with these fragile attitudes day in and day out. The ladies up front definitely work hard.“

3.8 Good26 Reviews
Scotto's Pork Store Deli • $$
25 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 7.87 miles

“We love Scottos. They have everything my Italian Mom made for us,25yrs.wonderful Sullivan Street Bread from Brooklyn,on weekends. Great breads made daily. Fresh mozzarella,Braciole,Sausageready to go frozen dinners for our kids who cook on there own...lol. Geneoa Salami,nice sliced thin.Homemade.Sauce,Ravioli and Stuffed Shells...just the best! Pizza is awesome too..xo.Thanks Jack&Jude - Sag Harbor NY“

3.7 Good33 Reviews
Tutto Il Giorno South Italian
56 Nugent St, Southampton - 10.41 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cioppino

“Lovely place with even better food and service. The appetizers are all amazing - highly recommend the fried calamari. This place is very charming and the staff is kind and attentive. Out of everywhere I ate in Southampton, this one takes the prize.“

3.7 Good53 Reviews
Il Giardino Restaurant by John Gambino Italian • $$$
739 Main Rd, Aquebogue - 5.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bolognese Pappardelle
House Made Fresh Mozz Salad
Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato
Pasta with Scallops
North Fork Paccheri
Halibut Puttanesca
Chicken Parmigiana
Grilled Octopus
Seafood Platter
Baby Eggplant

“My wife and I had our first dinner here last month and were very pleased by the quality of the food, the friendly service and the charming ambience. It checks all the boxes for us. We went back last week and had the same first class experience. We arrived early both times and had no problem being seated promptly. We are both looking forward to our next visit this evening.“

3.7 Good61 Reviews
Michelangelo Southold Italian • $$
53345 Main Rd, Southold - 7.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Slice Pizza
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Piccata
Pepperoni Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Fried Calamari
Grandma Pizza
Garlic Knots
Lasagna
Mac

“Great Italian food restaurant worth visiting if you're heading out to eastern Long Island. Food and atmosphere are great, and never have any complaints about the dishes. Sometimes gets very busy so service can be a bit delayed, but if you're looking to relax and have a nice meal, this is the place. Specials are always great as well and there is plenty of parking. Clams oreganta and calamari arrabiata appetizers are excellent, worth trying. Will keep returning!Vegetarian options: Salads and moreKid-friendliness: AbsolutelyParking: AmpleWheelchair accessibility: RampDietary restrictions: Plenty of options“

3.5 Good52 Reviews
Loading...
map Map