31 Best Italian Restaurants near Sag Harbor

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Italian Restaurants near Sag Harbor.

Showing 31 of 31 restaurants

  • Tutto il Giorno Sag 16 Main Street, Sag Harbor Italian · $$$$

    1 Tutto il Giorno Sag

    3.9 Good 295 Reviews

    16 Main Street, Sag Harbor

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Fried Calamari and Fried Vegetables
    • Ravioli with Wild Mushrooms
    • Panna Cotta w Berries
    • Spaghetti Bolognese

    “Good food 🥘 nice ambience”

  • Cappelletti Restaurant & Take Out 3284 Noyack Road, Sag Harbor Italian · $$

    2 Cappelletti Restaurant & Take Out

    4.4 Superb 150 Reviews

    3284 Noyack Road, Sag Harbor

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Fried Calamari
    • Marinara Sauce
    • Eggplant Parm
    • Garlic Rolls

    “We love going to Capelettis — it’s a charming local restaurant that always makes you feel welcome. The owner and chef, Luigi, always greets you with a smile when you walk through the door, which makes the experience feel very personal and special. He is an amazing chef — the pasta fagioli soup is the best, and everything is always delicious. The staff couldn’t be nicer, and the whole place has a very homey, local feel. One of our favorite spots — we highly recommend it.”

  • DOPO La Spiaggia 6 Bay Street, Sag Harbor Italian · $$$$

    3 DOPO La Spiaggia

    4.0 Good 230 Reviews

    6 Bay Street, Sag Harbor

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Rigatoni with Sausage and Peas
    • Tiramisu
    • Burrata
    • Milanese

    “Delicious and great atmosphere”

  • Il Capuccino 30 Madison St, #PO1438, 30 Madison St, Sag Harbor Italian · $$

    4 Il Capuccino

    4.1 Good 214 Reviews

    30 Madison St, #PO1438, 30 Madison St, Sag Harbor

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Veal Parmigiana with Garlic and Oil Linguini
    • Chocolate Lava Cake with Vanilla Ice Cream
    • Basket of Hot Garlic Rolls
    • Mozzarella Tomato & Pesto

    “I have been going to Il Capuccino since it opened, with bring your own wine and red and white plastic tablecloths. Loved it then and love it now. A superior experience!!! ❤️”

  • Sag Pizza 103 Main Street, Sag Harbor Pizza · $$

    5 Sag Pizza

    3.7 Good 306 Reviews

    103 Main Street, Sag Harbor

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • San Marzano Pizza and 2 Garlic Knots
    • Sag Harbor Slice of Pizza
    • Tomato & Cheese Pizza
    • Summer Squash Pizza

    “I ordered an Arugula and avocado that barely has avocado with very dried/dead leaf that I m not even sure if it is an arugula. Simply horrible. Will never come back again and won t recommended.”

  • Léon 1909 29 West Neck Road, Shelter Island Heights Italian · $$$$

    6 Léon 1909

    4.3 Superb 144 Reviews

    29 West Neck Road, Shelter Island Heights · 6.24 miles

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Slow Roasted Chicken
    • Clams and Sausage
    • Bone in Ribeye
    • Roasted Fluke

    “We visited on Saturday evening during the Thanksgiving holiday weekend. From the moment we entered through the front door, we were welcomed by big smiles, big smells of delicious food, and what felt like a warm hug from a good friend. Classic and palette awakening cocktails. Try the brandade fritters and the best Caesar salad I have ever enjoyed. Sea bass was fresh out of the waters that surround the east end. The burger and the roasted chicken. For sides we ordered the onion gratin, romanesco and French fries. Surprise banana split for dessert. Delicious! See you again soon. Happy Holidays!”

  • Maroni Southold 54195 Main Road, Southold Italian · $$

    7 Maroni Southold

    4.7 Superb 87 Reviews

    54195 Main Road, Southold · 8.41 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Toasted Marshmallows over Chocolate Mousse
    • Ribs with Gummi Bear Glaze
    • Chicken Parmigiana
    • Penne Ala Vodka

    “Went to Maroni for the first time today....we split the chicken parm, the chicken milanese, and the penne ala vodka. All of it was amazing!! I can't even choose which I liked best, as all three were so great. Had the meatballs as well, and they were also perfect. One of the best meals I've had in a while, and I have nothing but good things to say.”

  • La Parmigiana 44-48 NY-27A, Southampton Italian · $$

    8 La Parmigiana

    4.4 Superb 200 Reviews

    44-48 NY-27A, Southampton · 9.12 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chicken Parmigiana
    • Pepperoni Slice
    • Fried Calamari
    • Coconut Shrimp

    “Great meal and kid-friendly. Paula is lovely!”

  • Luigi's Italian Specialties 199 Pantigo Road, East Hampton Italian · $

    9 Luigi's Italian Specialties

    4.5 Superb 97 Reviews

    199 Pantigo Road, East Hampton · 6.73 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “Absolutely delicious focaccia sandwiches don’t forget the homemade dressing when you order 😋”

  • Sant Ambroeus East Hampton 66 Newtown Lane, East Hampton Italian · $$$

    10 Sant Ambroeus East Hampton

    4.1 Good 78 Reviews

    66 Newtown Lane, East Hampton · 5.95 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Pinot Grigio NEC Otium I Vini Di Jacopo
    • Tagliatelle Alla Bolognese
    • Sant Ambroeus Burger
    • Lobster Paccheri

    “Great food and atmosphere. Dog friendly.”

  • Sant Ambroeus Southampton 30 Main Street, Southampton Italian · $$$

    11 Sant Ambroeus Southampton

    4.1 Good 326 Reviews

    30 Main Street, Southampton · 9.28 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Sant Ambroeus French Toast
    • Fettuccine Alla Bolognese
    • Sant Ambroeus Ravioli V
    • Linguine Alle Vongole

    “Stumbled by this bistro in Southampton and decided to go in for lunch. To our pleasant surprise we had a wonderful meal with excellent wine pairings suggested by our server, we loved our lunch so much we decided on having dinner at their NYC location the next evening, needless to say it was magnificent! Looking forward to trying the other locations….”

  • Nick & Toni's 136 N Main St, East Hampton Italian · $$$$

    12 Nick & Toni's

    4.1 Good 280 Reviews

    136 N Main St, East Hampton · 6.11 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Wood Grilled Prime New York Strip Steak Tagliata
    • Castelfranco & Baby Beet Salad
    • Nick & Toni's Zucchini Fritti
    • Almond Biscotti with Vin Santo

    “Friendly warm Atmosphere. Delicious fresh salads. Dinner had that home cooked taste.Loved it. Highly recommend this place I would definitely go back.”

  • FRANKIE'S Fabulous Italiano 44 Three Mile Harbor Road, East Hampton Wine Bar · $$

    13 FRANKIE'S Fabulous Italiano

    4.6 Superb 88 Reviews

    44 Three Mile Harbor Road, East Hampton · 5.98 miles

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Diavola - Devil's Pizza
    • Fried Zucchini Chips
    • Sal's Antipasto
    • Pepperoni Pizza

    “The pizza was very good - fresh ingredients.”

  • Serafina East Hampton 104 North Main Street, East Hampton Italian · $$

    14 Serafina East Hampton

    3.9 Good 223 Reviews

    104 North Main Street, East Hampton · 6.11 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Linguine Alle Vongole
    • Spaghetti Carbonara
    • Carpaccio
    • Lava Cake

    “Good food. Great service.”

  • Limoncello Ristorante 21 Hill Street, Southampton Italian · $$

    15 Limoncello Ristorante

    4.3 Superb 56 Reviews

    21 Hill Street, Southampton · 9.49 miles

    • Delivery

    “This restaurant has a beautiful decor, super friendly staff, the best food in town and very reasonable prices. They don’t charge for bread and all entrees come with side dishes, the way it should be. It’s worth supporting this wonderful restaurant.”

  • Dopo il ponte bridgehampton 2402 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton Italian · $$$$

    16 Dopo il ponte bridgehampton

    4.0 Good 194 Reviews

    2402 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton · 4.3 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Tagliatelle Alla Bolognese
    • Melanzane Alla Parmigiana
    • Linguine Alle Vongole
    • Pizza San Daniele

    “We had a wonderful meal. Nice salads, excellent fire wood oven pizzas and a beautiful space. Highly recommend.”

  • La Capannina 364 Montauk Highway, Wainscott Pizza · $

    17 La Capannina

    4.6 Superb 179 Reviews

    364 Montauk Highway, Wainscott · 4.17 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Cheese Pizza Slice
    • My Favorite Pizza
    • Pizza Margarita
    • Pepperoni Pizza

    “great staff and great food. The Chicken Franchaise is delicious”

  • The Blend At Three Mile Harbor 367 County Rd 40, East Hampton New American · $$

    18 The Blend At Three Mile Harbor

    4.3 Superb 140 Reviews

    367 County Rd 40, East Hampton · 5.78 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Grilled Colossal Shrimp and Crofie Carbonara
    • Grilled Mediterranean Ahi Tuna Steak
    • Slow Roasted Veal Osso Bucco
    • Fried Kung Pao Dumplings

    “The food is always good and great portions .”

  • Alpina 45 Front Street, Greenport Wine Bar · $$

    19 Alpina

    4.5 Superb 151 Reviews

    45 Front Street, Greenport · 8.02 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • House Made Swiss Sausage
    • Cacio E Pepper Agnolotti
    • Classic Wiener Schnitzel
    • Chartreuse Soufflé

    “Shared the duck and veal entrees which were both phenomenal. The duck was nice and crispy on the outside and perfectly medium in the middle. Fatty, fresh, delicious. The veal was chopped and mixed in with mushrooms in a delicious creamy sauce. That dish came with what is basically a German pasta on the side. We put the pasta in with the sauce so it would soak up all the flavor. Didn’t leave anything left on either plate. Will visit again next year when I’m on vacation”

  • American Pie Pizzeria - Bridgehampton 2044 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton Pizza Delivery · $

    20 American Pie Pizzeria - Bridgehampton

    4.4 Superb 210 Reviews

    2044 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton · 4.67 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Meatball Parmigiana Hero
    • Classic NY Cheese Pizza
    • Meatball Lasagna Pizza
    • Pepperoni Pizza Slice

    “Excellent. Staff was friendly and courteous. Let not forget how delicious everything was.”

  • Dopo Argento 15 Main Street, Southampton Italian · $$$

    21 Dopo Argento

    4.0 Good 198 Reviews

    15 Main Street, Southampton · 9.32 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Spaghetti Carbonara
    • Brussels Sprouts
    • Huevos Rancheros
    • Grilled Fish

    “I have had dinner here several times. Love the veal parm and my partner loves whole fish. However, most recently the waiter Palmer ruined our meal. He ignored us, then when he came over and I asked for a recommendation because my partner is gluten intolerant. He shrugged and acted like he could not be bothered to speak to the kitchen with a question. Throughout our meal he acted dismissive. He did not come back to us after he took our order and our entree plates were not cleared for 20 min. We deserved better.”

  • Sam's Restaurant 36 Newtown Lane, East Hampton Pizza · $$

    22 Sam's Restaurant

    4.4 Superb 146 Reviews

    36 Newtown Lane, East Hampton · 6 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Frutti Di Mare over Fresh Angel Hair Pasta
    • 9 Pepperoni Mushroom Pizza
    • Spaghetti Bolognese
    • Sam's Special Pizza

    “Had the chance to visit Sam’s last week and happy to report it’s still the same classic, family friendly spot it always has been. The minute you walk in the doors, all the great memories come flooding back. Our food (four cheese pie with chicken and the linguine with locally caught seafood) was delish! Our server was lovely. I also got a vodka martini that was perfect. Looking forward to coming back later this summer!”

  • Vine Street Café 41 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island American · $$$$

    23 Vine Street Café

    4.3 Superb 417 Reviews

    41 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island · 4.84 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Hot Bread Fresh Out of the Oven
    • Spicy Tuna Tartare Tacos
    • Crispy Calamari Salad
    • Lobster Bouillabaisse

    “Excellent food and wonderful service! The staff goes above and beyond and is extremely attentive to their patrons. The food was delicious. We cannot wait to go back!!”

  • Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant 1271 Noyack Road, Southampton Pizza · $$

    24 Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant

    4.4 Superb 116 Reviews

    1271 Noyack Road, Southampton · 5.92 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Seared Local Calamari
    • Meatball Sliders
    • Eggplant Sliders
    • Arugula

    “Pellegrino‘s is some of the finest Italian food on the East End. It also is a cool place to hang out with a casual vibe with no pretense.. as a local realtor when people ask me, what’s a great restaurant in the north sea area Pellegrino is always the first to come to mind. Great food fantastic service a small, but vibrant bar area or what you’ll find here. They make a great pizza. I cannot recommend this place more highly. Stop in for a bite you will not be disappointed.”

  • Springs Tavern and Grill 15 Fort Pond Boulevard, East Hampton Bar & Grill · $$

    25 Springs Tavern and Grill

    4.3 Superb 170 Reviews

    15 Fort Pond Boulevard, East Hampton · 6.8 miles

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Beet & Burrata Caprese
    • Tortellini Alla Bolognese
    • Grilled Chicken Sandwich
    • Crispy Chicken Sandwich

    “Great place to watch a game have a beer and eats on Sunday.”

  • Michelangelo Southold 53345 Main Road, Southold Italian · $$

    26 Michelangelo Southold

    3.9 Good 212 Reviews

    53345 Main Road, Southold · 8.49 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Cheese Slice Pizza
    • Eggplant Parmesan
    • Chicken Parmigiana
    • Chicken Piccata

    “The food is excellent and the pizza is even better. There once a week. You will be pleased.”

  • Cittanuova 29 Newtown Ln, East Hampton Italian · $$$

    27 Cittanuova

    3.7 Good 85 Reviews

    29 Newtown Ln, East Hampton · 6.02 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Calamari E Zucchini Fritti
    • Chicken Milanese
    • Minestrone Soup
    • Fried Calamari

    “Great atmosphere and food!”

  • Villa Italian Specialties 7 Railroad Avenue, East Hampton Italian · $

    28 Villa Italian Specialties

    3.6 Good 128 Reviews

    7 Railroad Avenue, East Hampton · 5.72 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Meatball Parmigiana Hot Hero
    • Grilled Chicken Focaccia
    • Chicken blt Panini
    • Villa Combo Salad

    “Grilled Chicken Focaccia Grilled chicken, fresh Mozzarella, roasted peppers, pesto, sliced tomato served on toasted focaccia bread. 💯💯💯💯”

  • 75 Main 75 Main Street, Southampton American · $$

    29 75 Main

    3.9 Good 694 Reviews

    75 Main Street, Southampton · 9.23 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Stanley Tucci's Fresh Made Spaghetti Alla Nerano
    • Rare Skillet Seared Yellowfin Tuna Tataki
    • The Famous Brown Derby Cobb Salad
    • Old Fashioned Chicken Parmesan

    “Great atmosphere and menu”

  • Melrose East Restaurant and Pizza 801 County Rd 39 Suite 2, Southampton Pizza · $

    30 Melrose East Restaurant and Pizza

    3.7 Good 127 Reviews

    801 County Rd 39 Suite 2, Southampton · 10 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Garlic Knots
    • Cheese Pizza

    “I stopped by Melrose last night at 10 PM, hoping to grab something last minute. It had already been a little bit of an adventure, my dogs had run away as I was leaving the house, so by the time I finally made it there, the place was already closed. The owner was walking out when he saw me and recognized me. I apologized for missing closing, but instead of simply saying, “Sorry, we’re closed,” he was incredibly kind and actually invited me back inside and made something for me. Now, maybe that sounds like a small thing, but to me, it wasn’t. I work in restaurants, and I know exactly what it feels like at the end of a long shift, when you’re exhausted, you’ve been dealing with customers all day, and all you want to do is go home. And yet, this guy chose kindness and hospitality anyway. That is what hospitality is supposed to be. It’s not just about the food or the service. It’s about the human moment. It’s about making someone feel taken care of when you absolutely don’t have to. That experience meant a lot to me. Wow. Just wow. That’s the kind of restaurant owner, hospitality, and genuine kindness I aspire to create myself. Thank you, Melrose. ❤”

  • Pepperoni's 281 Springs Fireplace Road, East Hampton Pizza · $

    31 Pepperoni's

    3.5 Good 124 Reviews

    281 Springs Fireplace Road, East Hampton · 6.33 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Cheese Calzone with Sauce
    • 1 Piece Garlic Knots
    • Pepperoni Pizza
    • Meat Lover Pie

    “The best pizza ever! Thank you Nabil!!”

Italian Restaurants Nearby

You May Also Like

  • Una Pizza Napoletana Pizzeria Named Best in the World for 2024

    Una Pizza Napoletana Pizzeria Named Best in the World for 2024

    Una Pizza Napoletana, a popular spot in New York, has just been named the best pizza in the world by the 2024 Italian 50 Top Pizza ranking. This is a major victory for owner Anthony Mangieri, who has already earned the title of best pizza in the U.S. for three years in a row.

  • Italian Pizza Chain Rosso Pomodoro Makes Its American Debut in Denver

    Italian Pizza Chain Rosso Pomodoro Makes Its American Debut in Denver

    Naples-born Rosso Pomodoro has landed in Denver. The Italian pizza franchise just opened its first U.S. location in the city's Central Park neighborhood at 29th Ave Town Center. "It has long been a dream to introduce our brand of authentic Neapolitan-style pizza to every corner of America,” CEO Nicola Saraceno shared his excitement.

  • 100-Year-Old Pizzeria Seeks New Owner, Bans Pineapple

    100-Year-Old Pizzeria Seeks New Owner, Bans Pineapple

    Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana, a 100-year-old Coney Island eatery, is looking for a buyer or partner to keep its legacy alive, but it has one important condition. Totonno's has made it through fires, floods, and even COVID, but there's one thing they'll never tolerate: pineapple on their pizza.