Restaurants in Sag Harbor

“Great place. Really enjoyed the food the atmosphere and our waiter Sean was great. Good experience.”

“Food and service was wonderful!”

“Finally stopped in after meaning to for over a year and we are so glad we did!! Cute inside space with light atmosphere. The bartender was very friendly and knowledgeable about the beer choices. We tried two flights and liked 7 of the 8 we tried. Will definitely be back to try more. They also have an outdoor seating area but it was too cold the day we went.”

“Good food 🥘 nice ambience”

“Really great tasting fish! I got the fish and chips and both were fired perfectly. Tartar sauce was good but ask for an extra one as one is not enough. Be careful on weekend lunch hour as it gets packed and also the food seems to be rushed and doesn't come out as great which would give the rating of 4.5. But overall lovely food and I always come here every summer.”

“Bobby D. was a great host! We loved him and the food and drinks were great!”

“The food was fantastic and the atmosphere was very romantic!”

“Great for vegetarians and vegans. It was really good. It’s tiny inside. This is like a great quality Mexican inspired diner. I will totally go again. It’s fast paced inside, and they are on it.
I had one of the best vegetarian meals I’ve had in a long time. They do a lot of take out orders, I might do that next time because they are very busy and I don’t want to be rushed to finish my meal.

Vegetarian options: Great for vegetarians and vegans!!”

“Delicious entrees, salads, pizza and more. Food is fresh and wait time for take out is minimal. Treat yourself to the cannoli for dessert. They are exceptional!! Highly recommend this restaurant tucked away on Noyac Road.”

“Server Leoni deserves a gold star.

My pasta dish (agnolotti with morels) was an abstract painting of flavor. Every bite achieved a beautiful balance of salt, fat, and acid, yet the truly magical part was being able to experience each gorgeous umami note separately and gently (unlike a burger, which offers a more aggressive medley of flavors).

The pasta was fresh and handmade, with a perfect al dente bite around the edges. The ricotta brought a delicate sweetness and silky texture, while the peas provided a bright accent. The sauce was both lemony and savory. Perhaps what I enjoyed most was the speck paired with the morels. Unlike bacon, which can easily overpower a dish, the speck acted as a subtle accent that only enhanced the other flavors.

The artistry of the textures and flavors was simply magnificent - pasta dish craftsmanship in a way I have never experienced before. Portion size was perfect as well. Thank you.”

“So this is a Pub that is Cash Only, and shares it’s parking lot with neighboring businesses. So parking may not be close by. As you enter you’ll notice that The Bar Area is placed against the wall to the right. There’s about 6 beers on tap with plenty of bottled beers and canned beers in-stock, but they don’t serve food here. At the time of my visit, there was Grilled Cheese for $1. The place has a small interior is ideal for small to midsize groups of people to attend. The even have outdoor seating for larger crowds. They offer an ATM, Arcade Game such as Cards, Dart Board, Old School Jukebox, One Flat Screen TV, Popcorn Maker, and a water station. There’s 2 unisex restrooms for use and smoking is done outside the building in the back, that has tables and chairs to sit on. This place has a fun but more of a laid back atmosphere about it and is definitely a local hangout bar, but it’s worth checking out.”

“This restaurant is THE BEST!! All their food is amazing. Made to order, and some very creative bagels, to say the least. And it’s easy - to park (big lot), traffic signal to get in and out of busy Montauk Highway, quick orders, friendly - happy staff! The interior is so creative, with bookshelf table, motor cycle table, etc. Etc. Good for big groups or just one. Mr and Mrs Goldberg are sweethearts. ❤️ GO - you won’t regret it!!”

“Delicious and great atmosphere”

“The food was amazing and the atmosphere was cheerful. I was looking for a relaxed restaurant with good quality food, and I found it. Burgers, steak, Salmon, pizza, fajitas….all great.
Well done Dowlings, I am a fan.”

“Had cocktails and apps at the bar last night. It was great and the staff were fantastic,”

“By far my favorite ice cream shop. They have a very wide range of flavor which all taste amazing, and the staff is very nice and knowledgeable. They only take cash, so don't forget to bring some, and be prepared to wait in line if you are going in the evening.”

“ya.good...................”

“What nice people! Such a pleasure to go in and talk with them and get recommendations. Everything they have is incredible. I love everything in this beautiful shop. I embarrass myself because I buy so much. People are happy when in this shop and smile and talk. If you eat one of their grilled cheese sandwiches you will lie in bed dreaming of them. Did I mention how nice everyone is. Linda”

“Wow, pure class is found here at S&M. Simply amazing.

A must stop if you're in Sag Harbor. Elegance finds its way here. Not a prettier setting to get delicious cold brew coffee or afternoon delight with Rose`. Delicious treats and pies. Great outdoor space.

Jewelery, dresses, trinkets and more can be found next door. High end. And now a historical 2 floor sleepover suite accommodations are a beautiful stay.

I highly recommend”

“Delicious and unique home made donuts and excellent service.”

“Ginger cookies were fantastic!!!!!”

“I have been going to Il Capuccino since it opened, with bring your own wine and red and white plastic tablecloths. Loved it then and love it now. A superior experience!!! ❤️”

“I ordered an Arugula and avocado that barely has avocado with very dried/dead leaf that I m not even sure if it is an arugula. Simply horrible. Will never come back again and won t recommended.”

“Really impressed with this place! I’m picky about Mexican food & loved it! I got the chicken tacos and my boyfriend got the steak burrito. The hot sauce is soo spicy too!”

“Frozen yogurt was the best I have ever had....and the toppings bar was extensive. I highly recommend Buddha Berry.”

“Love the Cove Deli. Food is always fresh and hot meals are delicious. Helga's cakes and pastries are fabulous. Nice people, great food.”

“My sister and I had the best brownie yesterday we purchased at Harbor Market and Kitchen! They were moist fudgey, chocolatey perfection. ❤️”

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Seriously, some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had worth every penny and now I am back home dreaming of this ice cream. Can’t wait to go back. 5 stars! No picture because I ate it up.”

“I went in to order skewers, french fries, and sesame chicken on the fourth of July. The workers were so caring and made sure that all of the items that I got was correct and fresh. The french fries were so crispy and on the inside perfectly soft. Skewers were packed with protein and the sesame chicken had a great sauce. I would come back, right next to the fireworks as well!”

“We love Goldberg's for a warm morning bagel with tofu cream cheese and/or to grab a bag to go to create nice bagel spreads at home especially when we have guests over. The service at our Sag Harbor location is always nice and the bagels tasty!”