New American Restaurants near Sag Harbor, NY

Browse menus, reviews and photos of New American Restaurants near Sag Harbor.

Showing 30 of 30 restaurants

  • Page Sag Harbor 63 Main Street, Sag Harbor American · $$$

    1 Page Sag Harbor

    4.6 Superb 336 Reviews

    63 Main Street, Sag Harbor

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Local Peeko Oysters on the Half Shell
    • Garganelli Pasta Bolognese
    • Charred Spanish Octopus
    • Jumbo Lump Crab Cake

    “Great place. Really enjoyed the food the atmosphere and our waiter Sean was great. Good experience.”

  • Bell & Anchor 3253 Noyack Road, Sag Harbor Seafood · $$$

    2 Bell & Anchor

    4.5 Superb 272 Reviews

    3253 Noyack Road, Sag Harbor

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Guava Baby Back Ribs w Baby Spinach & Pine Nuts
    • Old School Lobster Garganelli
    • Pan-Roasted Scottish Salmon
    • Flat Iron Steak Frites

    “Food and service was wonderful!”

  • Lulu Kitchen & Bar 126 Main St, Sag Harbor Mediterranean · $$$

    3 Lulu Kitchen & Bar

    3.7 Good 288 Reviews

    126 Main St, Sag Harbor

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • P E I Mussels a-La-Plancha
    • Oysters on the Half Shell
    • Roasted Cauliflower
    • 1lb Whole Lobster

    “Had cocktails and apps at the bar last night. It was great and the staff were fantastic,”

  • The Blend At Three Mile Harbor 367 County Rd 40, East Hampton New American · $$

    4 The Blend At Three Mile Harbor

    4.3 Superb 140 Reviews

    367 County Rd 40, East Hampton · 5.78 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Grilled Colossal Shrimp and Crofie Carbonara
    • Grilled Mediterranean Ahi Tuna Steak
    • Slow Roasted Veal Osso Bucco
    • Fried Kung Pao Dumplings

    “The food is always good and great portions .”

  • Bruce & Son 208 Main Street, Greenport American · $$

    5 Bruce & Son

    4.2 Good 214 Reviews

    208 Main Street, Greenport · 8.03 miles

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Free Range Eggs Any Style with Toast
    • Brown Sugar Bacon
    • Egg Sandwich
    • Hot Cakes

    “Tastefully decorated and delish. The BLT & Espresso w/ Sweet Creme was yummy. We didn’t have reservations but the Host squeezed us in for a delightful meal. The wait staff was equally accommodating…can’t wait to return….🌻”

  • First and South Restaurant & Bar 100 South Street, Greenport American · $$

    6 First and South Restaurant & Bar

    4.5 Superb 255 Reviews

    100 South Street, Greenport · 8.13 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Oysters on the Half Shell
    • Fried Chicken Sandwich
    • South Street Chowder
    • Rockefeller Oysters

    “Wonderful first time dining here!”

  • Springs Tavern and Grill 15 Fort Pond Boulevard, East Hampton Bar & Grill · $$

    7 Springs Tavern and Grill

    4.3 Superb 170 Reviews

    15 Fort Pond Boulevard, East Hampton · 6.8 miles

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Beet & Burrata Caprese
    • Tortellini Alla Bolognese
    • Grilled Chicken Sandwich
    • Crispy Chicken Sandwich

    “Great place to watch a game have a beer and eats on Sunday.”

  • Highway 290 Montauk Highway, East Hampton New American · $$$

    8 Highway

    4.1 Good 150 Reviews

    290 Montauk Highway, East Hampton · 4.34 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Sushi Night with Shuko
    • Linguine with Clams
    • Rotisserie Chicken
    • Halibut Special

    “Apart from the incredible food, large portions, (atypical from other eateries out east) Fred brings the bar/cocktails to a new level. His personality makes you want to have dinner at the bar Oh yes, and my customized dirty martini is beyond compare … anywhere 🍸”

  • PAWPAW Main Street, Greenport Bar & Grill · $$$$

    9 PAWPAW

    4.9 Superb 70 Reviews

    Main Street, Greenport · 8.94 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Pork Shoulder Roasted in Spruce
    • Cereal Bread and Hay Butter
    • Duck Breast
    • Blueberry

    “Great meal last night wit PAWPAW at the Lin Beach House. The intimate setting and stellar service can’t be beat. The food never ceases to surprise me. I always try something new, that I never thought I would eat, and end up loving. Last night the Eel hush puppies blew me away! Can’t wait to come back again!”

  • Lion's Nook 10 Main Street, East Hampton New American · $$$$

    10 Lion's Nook

    4.3 Superb 17 Reviews

    10 Main Street, East Hampton · 6.1 miles

    “Great new addition to East Hampton’s dining scene - beautiful outdoor patio, professional staff, and good food. The Greek salad was nicely presented. The linguine were loaded with seafood. The tuna sandwich was a tad too cold / undercooked and a bit too smoky for my taste. Portions are generous and all food we saw looked delicious. We will be back!”

  • Nookies 1400 Silvermere Road, Greenport Pet Friendly · $$

    11 Nookies

    4.8 Superb 74 Reviews

    1400 Silvermere Road, Greenport · 7.96 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Sherry-Glazed Pork Cheeks
    • Maple Bacon French Toast
    • Roasted Fish with Beans
    • Focaccia with Ricotta

    “My brother and I went to Orient Point to see the sunrise. Afterwards, we decided we’d get something to eat but wanted to try something new and not too far back into the island (Long Island). I found this diner on Google Maps with high reviews and decided we should check it out as it was about 15-20minutes away. The diner itself is located at a motel/bungalow location named Silver Sands Motel. There was plenty of parking outside and it was giving a warm, vintage vibe to it. We arrived about 15minutes after the diner had opened so there was no wait and we sat at the bar rather than a regular table. The staff were very friendly and accommodating. The diner itself was very clean and well maintained. The menu had many great options but my brother and I decided to do the farm eggs meal which included 2 eggs made your way, hash browns and a choice of bread. We also decided to get a side of bacon each (separate charge from the meal). I didn’t get a picture of the bacon as I took the picture of the food before the bacon got to us but it was a LOT of very delicious bacon for EACH of us and totally worth the extra charge. The bill came out to around $50 which was around $25 for the both of us. 10000x better than going to an IHOP. Anytime I’m in the area again, I’ll definitely be going to Nookies for some breakfast. And honestly, I might even check out the motel because it looks absolutely gorgeous.”

  • Fresno 11 Fresno Pl, East Hampton New American · $$$$

    12 Fresno

    4.1 Good 22 Reviews

    11 Fresno Pl, East Hampton · 5.53 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “The food was great, service quick, professional and friendly . Very nice ambiance, classy place.”

  • Ellen's on Front 38 Front Street, Greenport American · $$

    13 Ellen's on Front

    4.6 Superb 220 Reviews

    38 Front Street, Greenport · 8.03 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Sweet Tea Brined Fried Chicken
    • House Smoked Whipped Ricotta
    • Long Island Chowder
    • Marinated Olives

    “Very nice atmosphere staff n owners chef are the nicest people My daughter is an employee and we were invited to dinner there n no other job that my kids have done that for the family! Beautiful place n beautiful people! The food is amazing”

  • Almond 1 Ocean Road, Bridgehampton American · $$$

    14 Almond

    4.3 Superb 349 Reviews

    1 Ocean Road, Bridgehampton · 4.22 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Sautéed Amagansett Greens
    • Steak Frites and 2 Sides
    • Sticky Toffee Date Cake
    • Turkey Burger Deluxe

    “Great French/Asian fusion find in the Hamptons. My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed it. The ambiance was great, and the service was quick.”

  • 1770 House Restaurant & Inn 143 Main St, East Hampton New American · $$$$

    15 1770 House Restaurant & Inn

    4.5 Superb 315 Reviews

    143 Main St, East Hampton · 5.99 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “Incredible ambiance, fantastic service with an impressive menu to match. Downstairs in the tavern, Kevin keeps everyone happy.”

  • Founders Tavern 55500 NY-25, Southold Bar & Grill · $$

    16 Founders Tavern

    4.6 Superb 166 Reviews

    55500 NY-25, Southold · 8.27 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Fried Calamari with House Marinara for Dipping
    • Marinated Filet Mignon Tips
    • Side of Sweet Potato Fries
    • Decent Beer Selection

    “First time visiting and we look forward to the next! Our server, Andrea was attentive and friendly. My steak was cooked perfectly and exactly what I was looking for. Thank you for a wonderful meal!”

  • T Bar Southampton 268 Elm Street, Southampton American · $$

    17 T Bar Southampton

    4.3 Superb 93 Reviews

    268 Elm Street, Southampton · 8.69 miles

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Tuna Tartare Crispy Sushi Fried Oysters
    • Chopped Salad
    • Caesar Salad
    • Rice Balls

    “Excellent food,desserts and impeccable service! Special thanks to my friends Spyros, Valentina and George!”

  • southold social 56125 Main Road, Southold American · $$$

    18 southold social

    4.5 Superb 88 Reviews

    56125 Main Road, Southold · 8.22 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • French Basque Cheesecake
    • Payard Chocolate Dome
    • Watermelon Feta Salad
    • Chocolate Bar Dessert

    “Great Place Friendly service warm welcome”

  • Claude's Restaurant at the Southampton Inn 91 Hill Street, Southampton American · $$

    19 Claude's Restaurant at the Southampton Inn

    4.2 Good 162 Reviews

    91 Hill Street, Southampton · 9.46 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “Fabulous!! Went to a charity event for Dancing thru the Decades.....the staff, the music, the atmosphere were great....and the food was fantastic!!! Kudos to the Chef!!! Best Chautea Briand mashed potatoes, broccoli rabe ever!! Definitely recommend!!!”

  • Vine Street Café 41 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island American · $$$$

    20 Vine Street Café

    4.3 Superb 417 Reviews

    41 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island · 4.84 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Hot Bread Fresh Out of the Oven
    • Spicy Tuna Tartare Tacos
    • Crispy Calamari Salad
    • Lobster Bouillabaisse

    “Excellent food and wonderful service! The staff goes above and beyond and is extremely attentive to their patrons. The food was delicious. We cannot wait to go back!!”

  • North Fork Table & Inn 57225 Main Road, Southold American · $$$$

    21 North Fork Table & Inn

    4.1 Good 361 Reviews

    57225 Main Road, Southold · 8.21 miles

    “Our wedding experience at North Fork Table & Inn was absolutely incredible from start to finish! It was such a pleasure working with Yulia (private event coordinator) and Mark (general manager), who went above and beyond to make us feel welcomed, comfortable, and completely taken care of. Mark's expertise, attention to detail, and genuine hospitality made the entire experience truly special. The food was phenomenal, the staff was attentive and wonderful, and the atmosphere was absolutely beautiful. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about everything! We are so grateful for the care and thoughtfulness that went into making our event unforgettable. We cannot recommend North Fork Table & Inn enough! It is truly an amazing experience!”

  • The Frisky Oyster 27 Front Street, Greenport Seafood · $$$

    22 The Frisky Oyster

    4.1 Good 237 Reviews

    27 Front Street, Greenport · 8.02 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Oysters Friskafella with Garlic-Scented Spinach Chipotle and Parmigiano Aioli
    • Braised Beef Short Ribs with Celery Root Puree Chantrelles and Candied Pecans
    • Seared Sea Scallops with Roasted Pumpkin Risotto and Pumpkin Seed Tuiles
    • Grilled Lobster Quesadilla

    “Amazing food, casual dining superb staff.”

  • Noah's 136 Front Street, Greenport American · $$$

    23 Noah's

    4.2 Good 492 Reviews

    136 Front Street, Greenport · 8.06 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Crescent Farm Duck Confit Hash
    • Warm Flourless Chocolate Cake
    • Nofo Calamari Frito Misto
    • Lump Blue Star Crab Cakes

    “We had a great lunch at Noah's, but the clam chowder was the one that stuck out the most...”

  • Green Hill Kitchen & Que 48 Front St, Greenport Barbecue · $$

    24 Green Hill Kitchen & Que

    4.1 Good 88 Reviews

    48 Front St, Greenport · 8.04 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Ribs and Mac and Cheese
    • Smoked Brisket Sandwich
    • Carolina Pulled Pork
    • Pulled Pork Sliders

    “We were in Greenport for Mother’s Day, and stumbled in here. The smell from outside was amazing. We ordered the half Brisket, Ribs and sausage with large fries, I was worried the food would be drenched in BBQ sauce, this was not the case. We were grateful the food was seasoned and sauced perfectly. The fries for us were crispy, some would say over done but perfect for us. We liked the atmosphere, service initially was a little slow but it was Mom’s Day. Oh two last things, if you order the sausage it is very hot, good but spicy hot so be prepared. Portions were decent, two of us ate from what we ordered and had a box to come home with.”

  • 75 Main 75 Main Street, Southampton American · $$

    25 75 Main

    3.9 Good 694 Reviews

    75 Main Street, Southampton · 9.23 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Stanley Tucci's Fresh Made Spaghetti Alla Nerano
    • Rare Skillet Seared Yellowfin Tuna Tataki
    • The Famous Brown Derby Cobb Salad
    • Old Fashioned Chicken Parmesan

    “Great atmosphere and menu”

  • Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House 1 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton American · $$$$

    26 Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House

    3.5 Good 126 Reviews

    1 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton · 4.15 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Broccoli Rabe Lemon and Chili
    • Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie
    • Mozzarella Tomato and Basil
    • Black Truffle Pizza

    “Excellent dining experience!”

  • North Sea Tavern 1271 North Sea Road, Southampton Bar · $$

    27 North Sea Tavern

    3.9 Good 170 Reviews

    1271 North Sea Road, Southampton · 8.28 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • North Sea Tavern Burger with Side Salad
    • Oysters on the Half Shell
    • Fried Pickles
    • Taco Tuesdays

    “Great and fun place! Friendly people and good food”

  • Southampton Social Club 256 Elm Street, Southampton New American · $$$$

    28 Southampton Social Club

    3.5 Good 175 Reviews

    256 Elm Street, Southampton · 8.7 miles

    • Delivery

    “Always a great time! Ian and Chris are amazing and the whole staff is great!”

  • East Hampton Grill 99 N Main St, East Hampton American · $$$

    29 East Hampton Grill

    3.5 Good 103 Reviews

    99 N Main St, East Hampton · 6.09 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Pan-Roasted Scottish Salmon with Spring Succotash
    • Tuna Tartare with Avocado
    • Rotisserie Chicken
    • Shrimp Cocktail

    “Consistently the East Hampton Grill offers outstanding food, service and ambiance.”

  • Claudio's Tavern & Grill 111 Main Street, Greenport Bar · $$$

    30 Claudio's Tavern & Grill

    3.4 Good 255 Reviews

    111 Main Street, Greenport · 7.95 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “very nice experience! we were a group of 8 who had a reservation for 4 pm but were early in Greenport so we decided to see if they could accomodate us earlier. And they did! thing that stood out was the great service! Our server Nicole was very upbeat, friendly and efficient. So were the others, the hostess, etc. who made it seem they were happy to work there. Food was OK and we were a bit disappointed because the band that was supposed to play canceled so there was no live music. But the service made it a very gratifying experience. looking forward to next time.”

New American Restaurants Nearby