New American Restaurants in Montauk, NY

668 The Gig Shack New American • $$
782 Montauk Highway, Montauk

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Organic Chicken Sandwich
Charred Lemon Caesar Salad - V
Shack Lobster Roll
Goats Cheese Salad
Baby Back Ribs
Fish Sandwich
Key Lime Pie
Fish Tacos
Tuna Tacos

“We had a lovely meal at Gig Shack! You’re definitely paying for the atmosphere. I was a bit frustrated to be paying $28 for a burger and waffle fries, only to have normal fries come out. I asked our waiter and he said they were out of waffle fries. I wouldn’t have minded too much if he had let us know, it just was a bit odd to have our meal slightly downgraded with no notice. Nice music, though, and what we got was good. Wish I had waffle fries, though.“

4.5 Superb319 Reviews
Bird on the Roof American • $$
47 South Elmwood Avenue, Montauk

Customers` Favorites

Burger and Fries with Cheese
Not Your Poppy's Pancakes
Coconut Bread Pudding
Soft Scramble Toast
Smoked Salmon Toast
Prosciutto Platter
Local Fish Taco 2
2 Eggs Any Style
Cosmic Romance
Avocado Toast

“Loved this restaurant! Everything we had was delicious, you can't go wrong. the service was great. Wish we lived closer! Must visit if you're in the area“

4.4 Superb391 Reviews
South Edison Seafood • $$$
17 South Edison Street, Montauk

Customers` Favorites

Lemongrass Local Fluke a La Plancha
Seared Rare Yellowfin Tuna ☐
Black & Blue Sea Scallops
Scallops with Mushrooms
Bone in Pork Chop Parm
Seared Yellowfin Tuna
Buffalo Chicken Bites
South Ed Baked Clams
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Buffalo Cauliflower

“excellent service.. excellent food../ amazing fluke sashimi!! and that burger!!! yum“

4.2 Good293 Reviews
Muse @ The End New American • $$
41 South Euclid Avenue, Montauk

Customers` Favorites

Plancha Sun Dried Tomato Crusted Salmon
Cauliflower Tempura Yuzu Curry Emulsion
Burger with Swiss and Grilled Mushrooms
Shrimp and Mussel Linguine Fra Diavolo
Beef Wagyu Bolognese
The Muse Casa Salad
Linguini and Clams
Grilled Pork Chop
Watermelon Salad
Rock Shrimp Salad

“Food and cocktails were delicious! Waiters were great and live music made for a very festive evening!“

3.6 Good487 Reviews
Tauk at Trail's End American • $$
63 South Euclid Avenue, Montauk

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Quesadilla
Mahi Mahi Tacos
Lobster Roll
Baked Clams
Salad
Sauce
Fish
Ribs

“The atmosphere is seaside casual. An open floor plan exists with a nice bar on one side. It’s airy inside with high ceilings. The food and service is always great. The specials are always a delight. Prices are moderate and fair. Portions are generous.“

3.7 Good182 Reviews