20 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sag Harbor

“We had an outstanding experience with the Seafood Shop from start to finish. The staff was professional, efficient and a pleasure to have helping us throughout the party. The food was fresh and delicious. The bartender was knowledgeable and experienced.“

“Frozen yogurt was the best I have ever had....and the toppings bar was extensive. I highly recommend Buddha Berry.“

“I recently had the pleasure of visiting Yummylicious, and I must say, it was an absolutely delightful experience that left me with a smile on my face. If you're a fan of heavenly, creamy, and delectable ice cream, this is the place to be. From classic favorites like vanilla and chocolate to more exotic creations like key lime pie and banana pudding, there's something for everyone. In addition, their milkshakes are out of this world! They also offer a range of creative toppings to take your dessert to the next level. The price is up to par with everything else in the area. This charming ice cream shop is definitely worth a visit while you are in SAG.“

“To call Candy Kitchen a legend and Bridgehampton treasure is not an understatement, and to still be greeted by Gus is just special.

If you order crispy bacon and eggs over medium - that's what you get and that's a rare treat these days“

“Always the best!“

“I absolutely love this place, the atmosphere is great, interior is fun, staff is super nice!! I have multiple favorites in the store, starting with the ice-creams, the cotton candy and the Superman are the best🤗 Love their cappuccino, latte, but my absolute favorite nowadays is the Frappuccino with vanilla ice cream! Pretty sure the manager already knows when I step in the store that she needs to take out the almond milk🫣❤️“

“Ice cream and milk shakes are great - coffee milkshake is exceptional and great selection of toppings. BUT more importantly the best part is the people that work here. They are incredibly kind and make sure to speak to all the kids. We appreciate you guys !“

“I recently had a little birthday party at Smokey Buns and they were incredible! Helen the GM goes above and beyond to make sure Smokey Buns not only runs smoothly but is a warm and welcoming environment for everyone. Helen is communicative, precise, and offers great insight around planning. The staff are friendly and attentive. All my friends found this location to be an excellent spot for a get together. Easily accessible, affordable, and clean. Thank you so much to Helen and the rest of the crew for being incredible. We will be back!!“

“This place is an allergy child’s heaven! The look on my son’s face when he could have anything he wanted was worth the trip! Will definitely go back!“

“Great cozy spot in Southold!

It’s a little further away from my parent’s house than some other options but we try to make it out here a couple times a year.

This time I got the corned beef hash and I loved it! They make their corned beef really crispy how I like and their potatoes are flavored really well! They also have super reasonable prices for the area.

They fill up quick so if recommend getting there on the earlier side if you are able to!“

“Delightful young ladies 😊“

“i would Recommend to open more locations in all cities and towns in all states lenox masss and berkshire mass boston mass , Newton mass, watertown , Specially Massachusetts. We need ice cream place in the Berkshire mass specially Lenox mass. We have no regular ice cream place in Lenox mass specially in the Berkshire mass wasting call Ralph it open while ice cream places to be open till midnight year round specially in Lenox mass and Berkshire mass. Open the more locations in Massachusetts“

“Amazing delicious home made ice cream“

“As an Ice Cream connoisseur, I find this place just fantastic. The place is always fully stocked with quick grab cakes and other treats. Its clean and its huge. Looks like their flagship location. I really dig their soft serve, its not too sugary like others. Do yourself a favor tonight, skip diner and fill your belly with Carvel from here, it'll be the best decision you've made in a while.
-Jarred“

“When on the Northfork their is no place that compares to Ralph’s of Greenport. The menu selection by far is overwhelming, simply because of the enormous amount of flavors in water ice, creme ice, ice cream, soft serve, sundaes and smoothies. and you can’t even imagine the amount of fresh toppings that they have. The prices are reasonable especially for the amount of ice/ice cream/creme ice that they give. They have something for everyone! The entire store is very clean and immaculate. They get ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ stars from me. I highly recommend it especially when you’re on the north fork of Long Island, it’s certainly a stop you won’t want to miss!“

“Very good ice cream. Many flavors to choose from. But they do run out and the flavors do change. But they still have many flavors, so always many choices. Could be faster taking and fulfilling orders. Line, at times, could get long and takes a while to get to the window to order. They could use more help. Still, worth going.“

“I really enjoyed this spot that we stumbled upon. You order at the counter and then they bring you your meal wherever you are. We sat outside and the kids got to play, eat and have fun. Great family environment to bring children to, they have a playground which my daughter loved, table tennis, foosball and more. We didn’t play golf, we just came for the burgers but we felt we left with a wonderful family memory. Thank you!!“

“I stopped by the Greenport Creamery the other night and had a great experience! I ordered a Cherry Vanilla cone, and it was absolutely delicious — creamy and full of flavor, with a rich cherry swirl and generous chunks of real cherries throughout. The staff was friendly and attentive. The young man helping me noticed I had my hands full and kindly offered to put my cone in a cup to make it easier for me to enjoy. Thoughtful service like that really makes a difference.
Can’t wait to go back!“

“Cute little candy shop....not very big...they also sell ice cream,which I did not try. My only complaint really was. .....the bags fir the candy weren't really accessible...I walked around for 10 mins looking....so I had to settle for the" priced fixed candy box" which was 20.00. But other then that very cute atomsphere,would definitely go back“

“Happy 90th Birthday Carvel! I can't imagine living in this world without Carvel ice cream. While I have reduced the size of my cup, over the last few years my own cups and then some, runneth over. I look the other way once a month in the summertime to indulge myself and enjoy every spoonful. As a kid, nothing compared to this decadent ice cream. The soft serve was King! Now, I cheat and do enjoy their frozen yogurt products from time to time, but the rich, creamy flavor is not to be duplicated, anywhere. Carvel is fortunately located on Jobs Lane in the Village of Southampton. I imagine they sell the most Fudgie the Whale birthday cakes! Stop in, stroll the Lane and sit by Agawam Lake and enjoy life. It just doesn't taste any better than Carvel.“