20 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sag Harbor

Big Olaf Ice Cream Shop • $
Wharf Street, Sag Harbor

Customers` Favorites

Cookie Dough

“By far my favorite ice cream shop. They have a very wide range of flavor which all taste amazing, and the staff is very nice and knowledgeable. They only take cash, so don't forget to bring some, and be prepared to wait in line if you are going in the evening.“

4.5 Superb96 Reviews
Yummylicious! Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
2 Main Street, Sag Harbor

“Thank goodness for 11pm closing!

Finished eating dinner and having drinks and wanted something sweet and luckily this cute establishment was open.

Walked in, still got good service at 10:50.

They had honeydew melon (frozen!) bubble tea which was incredible.

The ice cream was also very good. Great flavors. Great oatmeal ice cream.

Been to sag harbor multiple times and never tried so was pleasantly surprised.

LOTS OF GF/Celiac options.

It made my tummy yummylicious.“

4.1 Good82 Reviews
BuddhaBerry Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
125 Main Street, Sag Harbor

Customers` Favorites

Frozen Yogurt and Popcorn White Chocolate Pretzels
Rainbow Sprinkles
Ice Cream Shop
Waffles

“Frozen yogurt was the best I have ever had....and the toppings bar was extensive. I highly recommend Buddha Berry.“

4.1 Good160 Reviews
Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen Ice Cream Shop • $$
Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton - 4.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Cheese with Tomatoes
Chocolate Chip Mint
Fresh Strawberry
Cookie Dough
Chef's Salad
Lentil Soup
Hot Fudge
Sundaes
Coconut

“While the consistency of the food has become a bit all over the place lately, this remains an excellent destination to bring the kids. This is especially true if you visit outside of the busy summer season or avoid the weekend rush. Fortunately, the fluffy pancakes are still absolutely fantastic, and Gus along with the rest of the staff remain local treasures—much like the beloved diner itself.“

4.1 Good86 Reviews
Amazing Flavors Ice Cream Shop • $
216 Front Street, Greenport - 8.13 miles

“I absolutely love this place, the atmosphere is great, interior is fun, staff is super nice!! I have multiple favorites in the store, starting with the ice-creams, the cotton candy and the Superman are the best🤗 Love their cappuccino, latte, but my absolute favorite nowadays is the Frappuccino with vanilla ice cream! Pretty sure the manager already knows when I step in the store that she needs to take out the almond milk🫣❤️“

4.5 Superb88 Reviews
The Sweet Spot Ice Cream Shop • $
106 Newtown Lane, East Hampton - 5.75 miles

“🙌🏾 Spectacular, Amazing, and Sweet! Love this place… reminds me of my grandma’s house or my favorite childhood candy store.

Clean, well organized, and my order is always ready. They get an A+ from me &… extra credit points for the “no pets inside” sign on the door. I’m sooooo tired of dogs coming into food places on the East End! Their sign is refreshing (direct and kind). Thanks Sweet Spot, our town loves this summer location, that’s right across from Hampton Chutney (my other fav spot). 😊“

4.4 Superb41 Reviews
Sundaes on Main Ice Cream Shop • $
2414 Main Street, Bridgehampton - 4.29 miles

“Always the best!“

4.4 Superb82 Reviews
Opties and Dinghies Chinese • $$
1010 Village Ln, Orient - 9.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Veggie Spring Route
Steamed Dumplings
Scallion Pancakes
Combination
Croissant
Gelato

“Excellent dumplings and gelato (who knew such a combo existed!) - and we loved the hosts! We came for the all-you-can-eat dumpling fest and had a blast…we’ll be back!

Kid-friendliness: Kids enjoyed the all-you-can-eat dumpling fest, and the gelato“

4.7 Superb45 Reviews
A La Mode Shoppe Ice Cream Shop • $
35 Newtown Lane, East Hampton - 5.88 miles

Customers` Favorites

Dairy-Free Vanilla with Sprinkles

“This place is an allergy child’s heaven! The look on my son’s face when he could have anything he wanted was worth the trip! Will definitely go back!“

4.3 Superb53 Reviews
Smokey Buns Burgers • $
68 Park Place, East Hampton - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Halloumi Wrap
Side Grilled Halloumi
Oreo Twist & Shout
Crispy Chickenwich
Classic Burger
Cheese Fries
French Fries
Cheeseburger
Lamb Burger
Fishwich

“This is one of my favorite places to visit in East Hampton, not only for the delicious food at very reasonable prices, but always complimented by a very friendly and truly caring staff. Some of my favorites I would recommend are the fishwich salmon, the So Cal chicken salad, the mushroom patty and of course their burgers are always so tasty! Oh, and as an added bonus, they accept Blackbird and Inkind, so get rewarded even more to enjoy!“

4.5 Superb89 Reviews
Sip'n Soda Ice Cream Shop • $
40 Hampton Road, Southampton - 9.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Sandwich with Fries
Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe
Kids Chicken Tenders
Bacon Grilled Cheese
Ice Cream Breakfast
Bacon & Cheese
Banana Split
Chicken Salad
Onion Rings
Home Fries

“Amazing delicious home made ice cream“

4.1 Good68 Reviews
12

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
2033 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton - 4.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

6-Pack Chipsters
Ice Cream Cone
Birthday Cake
Cakes

“i would Recommend to open more locations in all cities and towns in all states lenox masss and berkshire mass boston mass , Newton mass, watertown , Specially Massachusetts. We need ice cream place in the Berkshire mass specially Lenox mass. We have no regular ice cream place in Lenox mass specially in the Berkshire mass wasting call Ralph it open while ice cream places to be open till midnight year round specially in Lenox mass and Berkshire mass. Open the more locations in Massachusetts“

3.9 Good33 Reviews
Country Corner Cafe Family • $
55765 NY-25, Southold - 8.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Avocado and Chicken Salad over Greens
Croissant French Toast with Berries
Buttermilk Pancakes
All American Panini
Ice Cream Sundae
Roast Beef Melt
Grilled Cheese
Corn Beef Hash
Eggs Benedict
Egg Sandwich

“Great cozy spot in Southold!

It’s a little further away from my parent’s house than some other options but we try to make it out here a couple times a year.

This time I got the corned beef hash and I loved it! They make their corned beef really crispy how I like and their potatoes are flavored really well! They also have super reasonable prices for the area.

They fill up quick so if recommend getting there on the earlier side if you are able to!“

4.4 Superb92 Reviews
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices of Greenport Ice Cream Shop • $
37 Front Street, Greenport - 8.02 miles

“When on the Northfork their is no place that compares to Ralph’s of Greenport. The menu selection by far is overwhelming, simply because of the enormous amount of flavors in water ice, creme ice, ice cream, soft serve, sundaes and smoothies. and you can’t even imagine the amount of fresh toppings that they have. The prices are reasonable especially for the amount of ice/ice cream/creme ice that they give. They have something for everyone! The entire store is very clean and immaculate. They get ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ stars from me. I highly recommend it especially when you’re on the north fork of Long Island, it’s certainly a stop you won’t want to miss!“

3.7 Good16 Reviews
Moo Moo's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop •
69 North Main Street, East Hampton - 6.08 miles

“Very good ice cream. Many flavors to choose from. But they do run out and the flavors do change. But they still have many flavors, so always many choices. Could be faster taking and fulfilling orders. Line, at times, could get long and takes a while to get to the window to order. They could use more help. Still, worth going.“

3.8 Good34 Reviews
Local Burger - Southampton Restaurant and Bar Hamburger • $
668 County Rd 39, Southampton - 9.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Works Hot Dog with Cajun Fries
Crispy Brussel Sprouts
Bacon Cheese Hot Dog
Crispy Cheddar Bites
Blue Cheese Burger
Chicken Fingers
Pretzel Sticks
Skin on Fries
Local Burger
French Fries

“Overall had a really great experience. Cool, historic building. Highlight of the meal was definitely the build-your-own burger. The beef was juicy, cooked perfectly to order, and they have a massive selection of toppings and sauces. Fries were also excellent. The price point feels a bit steep for a burger and fries, even by Hamptons standards. Service was on slower side.“

4.2 Good96 Reviews
17

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
790 County Rd 39, Southampton - 10 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sheet Ice Cream Celebration Cake
Birthday Cake Crunchies
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Ice Cream w Toppings
Chipster Individual
Ice Cream Pint

“As an Ice Cream connoisseur, I find this place just fantastic. The place is always fully stocked with quick grab cakes and other treats. Its clean and its huge. Looks like their flagship location. I really dig their soft serve, its not too sugary like others. Do yourself a favor tonight, skip diner and fill your belly with Carvel from here, it'll be the best decision you've made in a while.
-Jarred“

3.7 Good26 Reviews
18

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
22 Jobs Lane, Southampton - 9.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Toppings
Gelato

“Happy 90th Birthday Carvel! I can't imagine living in this world without Carvel ice cream. While I have reduced the size of my cup, over the last few years my own cups and then some, runneth over. I look the other way once a month in the summertime to indulge myself and enjoy every spoonful. As a kid, nothing compared to this decadent ice cream. The soft serve was King! Now, I cheat and do enjoy their frozen yogurt products from time to time, but the rich, creamy flavor is not to be duplicated, anywhere. Carvel is fortunately located on Jobs Lane in the Village of Southampton. I imagine they sell the most Fudgie the Whale birthday cakes! Stop in, stroll the Lane and sit by Agawam Lake and enjoy life. It just doesn't taste any better than Carvel.“

3.8 Good46 Reviews
Greenport Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
142 Main Street, Greenport - 8.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Ice Cream

“Greenport Creamery is a must-stop whenever you're in Greenport! The homemade ice cream is incredibly rich, creamy, and full of flavor, with so many delicious choices that it's hard to pick just one. The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the fresh waffle cones make the experience even better. Whether you're strolling through town or enjoying the waterfront, this is the perfect place to treat yourself. Highly recommend, and I'll definitely be back!“

3.6 Good33 Reviews
Dylan's Candy Bar Ice Cream • $$
52 Main Street, East Hampton - 6.08 miles

“Cute little candy shop....not very big...they also sell ice cream,which I did not try. My only complaint really was. .....the bags fir the candy weren't really accessible...I walked around for 10 mins looking....so I had to settle for the" priced fixed candy box" which was 20.00. But other then that very cute atomsphere,would definitely go back“

3.4 Good8 Reviews

You May Also Like