10 Best Ice Cream Shops near Mattituck

“My wife an I are late bloomers. We only found Magic Fountain at the beginning of Summer 2025. I can eat any Ice Cream. However, my wife can't have any dairy, specifically casein. We've tried a few other places (we're in Port Jeff Station nowadays) and both grew up in southern Nassau. Any place I would stop by...usually had nothing for her..maybe lemon ice. plus the staff would get screwed up (one time, a local place gave her regular ice cream instead of non,-dairy). Well..we stopped by in Summer 2025, I walked in and said my wife CAN'T have dairy. Every staff member looked and understood. They pointed out the non dairy ice creams they MAKE there, along with Sorbet including a Blood Orange, which she loved. My first time, I tried Kulfi..which was delicious. since then, we average twice a month..taking almost an hour ride, just for ice cream. It's that worth it. Some of the flavors I've had there; Kulfi Guiness Honey Lavender Lemon Ginger Coffee and other assorted flavors. I'm 70..having lived on the Island all my life. Remembering Jahn's of RVC, and countless other Ice Cream Shoppes..but THIS IS THE BEST!!“

“Very kind customer service ! Very clean on the inside“

“I recommend Dari-land ice cream to everyone! The owner is such an amazing person who goes out of his way for customers! He went out of his way for me and I wish I could for him! Not only is his ice cream great but I want everyone to go to his store! Thank you Dari-land ice cream owner!“

“Doing such a nice buy one get one free for Mother’s Day!“

“Amazing. Next level. 🇮🇹 🍦 🇮🇹“

“As an Ice Cream connoisseur, I find this place just fantastic. The place is always fully stocked with quick grab cakes and other treats. Its clean and its huge. Looks like their flagship location. I really dig their soft serve, its not too sugary like others. Do yourself a favor tonight, skip diner and fill your belly with Carvel from here, it'll be the best decision you've made in a while.
-Jarred“

“I love this Carvel been going to it for years.... I wish they would put one up in Massachusetts where I live!!!!“

“Went to dinner last night to celebrate my brother’s birthday dinner, 10/25. The food was excellent. The leek soup to start was excellent. The main meal was chop steak.. That was excellent, came marinated with sautéed onions and mushrooms, and you got your choice of sides. The dessert was to die for too and very big. It definitely accommodated 4 people. The service was great. It’s A return trip! They actually have great breakfast too because I’ve been there many times for breakfast. I believe they serve lunch as well, but I’ve never been there for lunch. Wake up people & come try for yourself!“

“Happy 90th Birthday Carvel! I can't imagine living in this world without Carvel ice cream. While I have reduced the size of my cup, over the last few years my own cups and then some, runneth over. I look the other way once a month in the summertime to indulge myself and enjoy every spoonful. As a kid, nothing compared to this decadent ice cream. The soft serve was King! Now, I cheat and do enjoy their frozen yogurt products from time to time, but the rich, creamy flavor is not to be duplicated, anywhere. Carvel is fortunately located on Jobs Lane in the Village of Southampton. I imagine they sell the most Fudgie the Whale birthday cakes! Stop in, stroll the Lane and sit by Agawam Lake and enjoy life. It just doesn't taste any better than Carvel.“

“I really enjoyed this spot that we stumbled upon. You order at the counter and then they bring you your meal wherever you are. We sat outside and the kids got to play, eat and have fun. Great family environment to bring children to, they have a playground which my daughter loved, table tennis, foosball and more. We didn’t play golf, we just came for the burgers but we felt we left with a wonderful family memory. Thank you!!“