11 Best Ice Cream Shops near Hampton Bays

1 Carvel

3.9 Good 102 Reviews

73 East Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“I love this Carvel been going to it for years.... I wish they would put one up in Massachusetts where I live!!!!”

2 Magic Fountain

4.7 Superb 283 Reviews

9825 Main Road, Mattituck · 8.04 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My wife an I are late bloomers. We only found Magic Fountain at the beginning of Summer 2025. I can eat any Ice Cream. However, my wife can't have any dairy, specifically casein. We've tried a few other places (we're in Port Jeff Station nowadays) and both grew up in southern Nassau. Any place I would stop by...usually had nothing for her..maybe lemon ice. plus the staff would get screwed up (one time, a local place gave her regular ice cream instead of non,-dairy). Well..we stopped by in Summer 2025, I walked in and said my wife CAN'T have dairy. Every staff member looked and understood. They pointed out the non dairy ice creams they MAKE there, along with Sorbet including a Blood Orange, which she loved. My first time, I tried Kulfi..which was delicious. since then, we average twice a month..taking almost an hour ride, just for ice cream. It's that worth it. Some of the flavors I've had there; Kulfi Guiness Honey Lavender Lemon Ginger Coffee and other assorted flavors. I'm 70..having lived on the Island all my life. Remembering Jahn's of RVC, and countless other Ice Cream Shoppes..but THIS IS THE BEST!!”

3 Paleteria Mexicandy

4.8 Superb 162 Reviews

221 East Main Street, Riverhead · 8.11 miles

“Very kind customer service ! Very clean on the inside”

4 Dari-Land LLC

4.6 Superb 164 Reviews

51 Main Road, Riverhead · 8.23 miles

“I recommend Dari-land ice cream to everyone! The owner is such an amazing person who goes out of his way for customers! He went out of his way for me and I wish I could for him! Not only is his ice cream great but I want everyone to go to his store! Thank you Dari-land ice cream owner!”

5 Shock Ice Cream

4.4 Superb 61 Reviews

99 Main Street, Westhampton Beach · 7.76 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Their ice cream is the best in West Hampton.”

6 Ben & Jerry’s

4.3 Superb 59 Reviews

121 Main Street, Westhampton Beach · 7.72 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Nothing but FANTASTIC things to say about my experience with Antoinette and the catering aspect of Ben & Jerry's of Westhampton. We used them to cater a sundae bar party for our wedding on June 30th at Bellport Country Club and from start to finish Antoinette was a PLEASURE to deal with, so incredibly helpful, not pushy at all, and attentive to my requests. I would literally get excited every time I had to talk to her! On the day of our wedding, the sundae bar was everything I could have dreamed of and more. From the photo props, to the flavors sign, to the toppings, scoopers, and of course the ice cream---worth every penny! If you are even remotely considering getting this store to cater an event of yours DO IT! You will not regret it :) Thank you Antoinette!!!!!!!!!!!”

7 KALEIDOSCOOPS ICE CREAM

4.3 Superb 37 Reviews

103 Main Street, Westhampton Beach · 7.75 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“You must stop in here for the creamiest, most delicious ice cream you’ll ever remember having! Such a great vibe from the employees. They had the line moving along, offering samples with a smile. I had the coffee fudge truffle and my daughter had the campfire s’mores. You won’t be disappointed!”

8 Sip'n Soda

4.1 Good 68 Reviews

40 Hampton Road, Southampton · 6.89 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Amazing delicious home made ice cream”

9 Carvel

3.7 Good 26 Reviews

790 County Rd 39, Southampton · 5.13 miles

• Delivery

“As an Ice Cream connoisseur, I find this place just fantastic. The place is always fully stocked with quick grab cakes and other treats. Its clean and its huge. Looks like their flagship location. I really dig their soft serve, its not too sugary like others. Do yourself a favor tonight, skip diner and fill your belly with Carvel from here, it'll be the best decision you've made in a while. -Jarred”

10 Carvel

3.8 Good 46 Reviews

22 Jobs Lane, Southampton · 6.73 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Happy 90th Birthday Carvel! I can't imagine living in this world without Carvel ice cream. While I have reduced the size of my cup, over the last few years my own cups and then some, runneth over. I look the other way once a month in the summertime to indulge myself and enjoy every spoonful. As a kid, nothing compared to this decadent ice cream. The soft serve was King! Now, I cheat and do enjoy their frozen yogurt products from time to time, but the rich, creamy flavor is not to be duplicated, anywhere. Carvel is fortunately located on Jobs Lane in the Village of Southampton. I imagine they sell the most Fudgie the Whale birthday cakes! Stop in, stroll the Lane and sit by Agawam Lake and enjoy life. It just doesn't taste any better than Carvel.”

11 Local Burger - Southampton Restaurant and Bar

4.2 Good 96 Reviews

668 County Rd 39, Southampton · 5.35 miles

• Delivery

“Overall had a really great experience. Cool, historic building. Highlight of the meal was definitely the build-your-own burger. The beef was juicy, cooked perfectly to order, and they have a massive selection of toppings and sauces. Fries were also excellent. The price point feels a bit steep for a burger and fries, even by Hamptons standards. Service was on slower side.”