10 Best Ice Cream Shops near Mastic Beach

“Amazing ice cream! Jacob is the sweetest! If you don’t know what you want he will let you try whatever ice cream no matter how many!Best ice cream in town! 10/10. 10000x better than the overpriced ice cream places.Parking: Lots of parking!! Even has a drive thru!“

“Hands down the best Pizzeria around/in the game The Pizza as well as the food is always Hot, fresh , and absolutely delicious, extremely generous portions, excellent prices As someone who is exremely picky with their Italian food this place exceeds all expectations Anthony really knows what he's doing highly recommend!“

“Brilliant! Door dashed to our hotel that was 10 minutes away and got it delivered in 15! However, sizes were very small for the price we payed. Chocolate overload was my favorite flavor. It was delicious with chocolate chips, hunks of brownies, and chocolate swirl all in chocolate ice cream! However, I do not recommend the cherry Italian ice. Unless you like the taste of air fresheners. ‍ over all I would recommend this to anyone.“

“Always a delight! There are so many toppings and flavors, and fun variations like frozen coffee and smoothies! The owner Bernadette is so sweet (BAD pun intended,) and blends the root beer floats, they're the best ones around! Even when packed on a summer day, she's fast, resilient and patient. They also have plenty of vegan options that are more than generous with the chocolate, not to mention creamy and flavorful (it tricked my whole family too, they didn't know it was dairy free!) The prices are fair and there's something to please everyone. You may not be able to dine there, but it's well worth the wait for wherever you're going to enjoy it!“

“Wow! What an amazing store I can't believe how clean everything is no matter what time of day. The staff is so friendly and polite. The owner definitely pays attention to details. The ice cream always taste fresh including the cakes. Hands down the best carvel on long Island. I will only go to Shirley for my ice cream. Thanks so much for caring about your store and your customers“

“Who gives less than 5.0 it’s because never tried the funk monkey flavor! Omg! It’s one of my favorites ice cream spots in the world! I love it! I always order it delivered also and comes exactly the way that I ask! Worthy the calories ?“

“My dad is a very picky eater with a small appetite. He ordered the senior tuna roll and fries. He ate everything on his plate, which is something I have not seen him do in years. The waitress let him take his ice cream to go. Very nice. Good job, Friendlys!!!! My mom and brother seemed to like their food. I liked my veggie burger and broccoli.“

“Whoever the breakfast chef was on 3/23/24 you really take pride in your cooking. I haven’t had eggs or any of the sides prepared like this in 20 years of dining out. Im 34. The eggs were cooked to perfection. Not a single dry mark on all of the various egg preps requested. Food came out in 12 mins. Friendlys is severely underestimated in this day and age. Our server Janeen was a blessing. Clear and loving. She went out of her way to ensure my son got a surprise birthday candle the day before his birthday.“

“Carla Marla has so many different flavors of ice cream and specialty sundaes/milkshakes that you are sure to find the right sweet treat for you! I loved how the building resembled a candy store from the 1900s, with shelves and buckets filled with all sorts of candies. I got to try their mint flavor, birthday bash, and cookie dough and everything was so good. It reminded me of childhood flavors which was very nice. I definitely want to go back to try their floats and specialty sundaes!“

“Great little ice cream shop with so many flavors and variety (latte, smoothie, shake, sundae, soft serve and more). They have a few outside tables and benches to enjoy your treat. Prices are reasonable and staff are very friendly. Of course, you can always ask for a taste of their unique flavors. It is off a major road. Just watch your little kids as the driveway is right by the storefront.“