21 Best Ice Cream Shops near Shirley

1

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
492 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cone
Birthday Cake

“Carvel is classic. A nice, busy Carvel on William Floyd, on your way to the beach. They have all the basics Carvel has to offer. A nice staff and a clean Carvel. Nowhere to sit though. It's a take out and eat in your car Carvel, as usual.“

4.3 Superb68 Reviews
Baskin-Robbins Ice Cream Shop • $
545 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley
3.4 Good5 Reviews
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices & Ice Cream, Shirley Ice Cream Shop • $
990 Montauk Hwy, Shirley

Customers` Favorites

Regular Acai 16 Oz
Small Acai 8 Oz
Soft Ice Cream
Red Raspberry
Sour Cherry
Italian Ice
Tiramisu
Sundaes

“We visit the Shirley store regularly (maybe too regularly 😜) and are always greeted by the lovely staff who are very quick and flawless with taking orders. I would give five stars if they didn't run out of the popular flavors so quickly.“

3.6 Good70 Reviews
Friendly's American • $
940 Montauk Hwy, Shirley

Customers` Favorites

Appetizer Sampler Chicken Onion Rings Mozarellasticks
Honey Barbeque Burger and Loaded Waffle Fries
Triple Decker Bacon Cheeseburger
Honey BBQ Chicken Supermelt
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
Candy Blast Monster Shake
Hamburger & Onion Rings
Mini Mozzarella Sticks
Friendly's Patty Melt
Honey BBQ Super Melt

“Food is always good, and the service is always very friendly! 😊👍“

4.2 Good129 Reviews
Sonic Drive-In Fast Food • $
800 Montauk Hwy, Shirley

Customers` Favorites

Cheeseburger Cheeseburger
Bacon Double Cheesesteak
Jumbo Popcorn Chicken
Quarter Pound Double
Mozzarella Sticks
Original Pretzel
All-American Dog
Combo Sandwich
Crispy Tenders
Grilled Cheese

“We stopped by for a late meal on a Sunday night. The woman who helped us went above and beyond in making sure my niece’s food was just perfect even though it was so late. By the way, she absolutely loved her pink Hello Kitty toy! We were pleasantly surprised by how professional and kind the staff was. Thank you again and we will be back for our next road trip. Highly recommended!“

3.3 Good106 Reviews
Paradise Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
410 Neighborhood Rd, Mastic Beach - 2.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
Coffee Lovers Paradise
Birthday Cake Sundae
Birthday Cake Remix
Waffle Bowl Sundae
Ice Cream Cones
Banana Split
Italian Ice
Soda Floats
Waffle Cone

“just went for the first time, and it definatly won't be the last! owner was nice and ice cream was all amazing!“

4.9 Superb75 Reviews
Ice Cream Cottage Ice Cream Shop • $
1590 Montauk Hwy, Mastic - 1.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Assorted Ice Cream
Banana Nut Crunch
Rainbow Cookie
Sundae 5 Scoops
Assorted Gelato
Birthday Cake
Blackberry

“Perfect ice cream every time. Must give it a try please.“

4.3 Superb106 Reviews
The Rainbow Rolls Ice Cream Shop • $$
333 Main St, Center Moriches - 3.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Green Tea Matcha Cup Taco
Cookies & Cream Taco
Cookie Dough Shake
Birthday Cake Taco
Mint O Fresh Taco
Vegan

“We went for the 1st time last night!! What a great place with friendly service. The ice cream was delicious and it was fun to watch them make it !! We will definitely be back :)“

4.4 Superb76 Reviews
NY Burger Shack Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
2080 NY-112, Medford - 7.22 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brooklyn Burger
Build Your Own
Staten Island
Curly Fries

“Honestly came here on weds night. I got the Bronx burger , my wife made her own burger. The burger was delicious and so flavorful. I could literally eat this everyday. I’ll deff be back . Highly recommend if you’re craving a tasty burger .“

4.3 Superb88 Reviews
Ultimate Ice Cream & Ice Ice Cream Shop • $
252 Montauk Hwy, Center Moriches - 4.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chunk
Cookie Dough
Brownie

“Bernadette is not only a wonderful person that works extremely hard at her business but she provides absolutely the best ice cream on Long Island“

4.4 Superb45 Reviews
Friendly's American • $
2220 Rte 112, Coram - 8.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hunka Chunka PB Fudge Sundae
A Disaster of French Toast
Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
Soup \u0026 Salad Combo
Mini Mozzarella Sticks
Reese's Pieces Sundae
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy Chicken Salad
Chicken Noodle Soup
Fish Sandwich Combo

“Delicious breakfast, I really enjoyed it.“

4.5 Superb166 Reviews
Yogomania-Medford Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
2717 NY-112, Medford - 6.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Medium Acai Bowl

“Simply cannot believe the negative reviews…I have been going here for years and I’m pleased with every experience. Probably upwards of 25-30 times since it’s been open.

Complaints about the prices? You control how much frozen yogurt and toppings go in your cup! It’s weighed! How about you take…less? Like, what?!

The owner is always lovely and efficient and the place is spotless. They seem to take so much pride in keeping it clean.

Will continue to patron this establishment and I absolutely recommend it.“

4.2 Good63 Reviews
13

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
1289 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island - 6.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mint Chocolate Chip Sundae Dasher
Oreo Cookie Sundae Dasher
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Ice Cream Sundae
Carvelanche

“Carvel in Middle island is the Best! I went to order a m&m cake for my son that is no longer made and they made it for me!! Came out better than I expected. They were very helpful and friendly . I highly recommend this location for you ice cream needs! I know I will be ordering from them again.

Thank you again!!“

4 Good66 Reviews
14

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
217 E Main St, Patchogue - 7.79 miles

“A clean Carvel in a busy shopping 🛒🛍️ center. May I suggest putting a couple tables with chairs. Up front by the entrance and exit doors. You certainly have the room for it. Also offer soda 🥤 as well my daughter's and I would love to sit and relax in this Carvel. 🍨 🍦.“

4.5 Superb22 Reviews
Friendly's American • $
70080 Sills Rd, Medford - 4.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

A Hamburger with Wilted Nasty Lettuce
Nite over Carmel with Carmel Syrup
Country Chicken Tenders with Fries
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Sundae
New Blueberry Muffin-Top Pancakes
Quarter Pound Cheeseburger
Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
Lemon Pepper Fish Dinner
Mini Mozzarella Sticks
Chinese Chicken Salad

“Food was great. Kind of disappointed that I wasn't offered a refill to go when I asked for a to go box for my food. Guess the waitress was super busy.“

4.2 Good235 Reviews
Anthony's Pizza Pizza • $
520 Mastic Rd, Mastic Beach - 1.73 miles

Customers` Favorites

Specialty Pizza Slice
Mozzarella Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Eggplant Parm
Chicken Parm
Sicilian
Delivery
Grandma
Soda

“ordered for the first time tonight , we got the pizza,pasta,mozzarella sticks, and salad daily special for $39.95, everything was delicious , and the delivery driver was nice , we will definitely be ordering again“

4.2 Good106 Reviews
Carla Marlas ICE CREAM PARLOR & CANDY SHOPPE Ice Cream Shop • $
8 Bellport Ln, Bellport - 4.85 miles

“I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream! And Carla Marla’s hears you! Delicious ice cream, hand scooped and some candy and many toppings there too. Cool off, slow down and enjoy some ice cream, all sizes and with whip cream, if you like!“

4.1 Good17 Reviews
Tweets Ice Cream Café Dessert • $
5768 NY-25A Bldg L, Wading River - 10.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
Mango Dragon Refresher
Pink Drink Refresher
Ice Cream Cakes
Large Acai Bowl
Cookie Monster
Ice Cream Cups
Cotton Candy
Brownie Pie
Oreo Pieces

“What a nice place. We come here very often and the employees are always pleasant and helpful, especially Jennifer. They're in a great location at the East Wind Shoppes... go have fun and stop in here. I highly recommend it“

4.2 Good81 Reviews
Baskin-Robbins Ice Cream Shop • $
350 Middle Country Rd # A, Coram - 9.11 miles
4.3 Superb3 Reviews
20

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
536 Montauk Hwy, Center Moriches - 3.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Round Ice Cream Cake

“so yummy!!! so yummy!!!!!“

3.5 Good17 Reviews
Ralph's Italian Ice & Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
6346 NY-25A, Wading River - 9.94 miles

“A Lil hidden sweet spot.. I kind of thought this location didn't get too busy. I'm wrong. Line looped around and out the door. Worth the wait. There was only 2 girls working... another one was Def needed. But I believe it was a Monday early eve so who knew it would be busy? Aaaw hell... it's summer it's hot n Ralph's is tasty and refreshing sooooo yeah jus assume it's gonna be busy.. but totally worth the wait. Try the pancake ice-cream Yummmmalicous“

3.3 Good26 Reviews

You May Also Like