NY Burger Shack
$ • Ice Cream, BurgersAbout NY Burger Shack
Customers' Favorites
Brooklyn Burger
Build Your Own
Buffaque Sauce
Staten Island
Curly Fries
NY Burger Shack Reviews
111 ratings
Share your opinion about NY Burger Shack
Excellent, your getting what you pay for, everything can be customized, you can order in person or kiosk. The kiosk didnt ask me for a tip, felt bad, but good to know if your not a tipper. I couldnt finish my plate, dont say that often on a 20 dollar meal.
Will be back 🙂
The dinning area is smaller, so be prepared to take it to go. In no way a deal breaker for me
Will be back 🙂
The dinning area is smaller, so be prepared to take it to go. In no way a deal breaker for me
Pretty awesome food, the burgers look awesome. Only thing is that the fries need salt badly but other than that it was pretty great.
I've rarely if ever given a 5 star to food places but this one takes the cake. Simple menu but executed perfectly and the value for what you get is great. The space is well done and spotless. I've found my burger joint now and unless must waistline starts to say otherwise I'll be frequent flyer here. Well done it's a really good spot *******... Also the young lady at the counter was nice enough to change the TV from ABC to CBS at my request 😁. Finally with small businesses...read full review
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 10PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 8PM |
NY Burger Shack is a popular spot known for its juicy and flavorful burgers, made with fresh ingredients. Many customers praise the quality of the food, describing the burgers as delicious, with some calling them the best they’ve ever had. The 4oz burger, served with American cheese, white onions, ketchup, and spicy mayo, is especially popular for its size and taste. The grilled chicken burgers are also highly recommended, cooked perfectly and not dry.
Sides like crispy onion rings and fries are often enjoyed, though some find the Cajun fries a bit dry and plain. Onion rings are consistently praised for being super crispy and tasty. The garlic parm wings and mac & cheese bites are additional favorites, offering loaded flavors and perfect textures. Customers appreciate the quick service and the easy-to-use kiosk ordering system, which makes the experience smooth and efficient.
Inside, the restaurant is described as adorable and welcoming, with seating for around 15 to 16 people. The dessert options, including various milkshakes and ice cream, are tempting though not always tried. Overall, NY Burger Shack offers comfort food done right, with quality and taste that keep customers coming back for more. It is regarded as a must-visit on Long Island for burger lovers and those seeking hearty, flavorful meals.