Restaurants near Shelter Island

“Totally worth the trip! Best pizza ever. So great to see Frankie and his team”

“Food is great, quick & friendly service”

“Stopped in for lunch yesterday. It was a beautiful, cool shady spot on a quaint island porch. The lunch was all home-made and fresh even down to the English muffins. The dessert case had a plethora of delicious freshly baked treats. We sampled a bunch and one was better than the next! Definitely a must visit!”

“I went there on yesterday for the first time and it was a very nice little restaurant The food was excellent and the staff was very pleasant First time going but it won't be my last”

“The best coffee ☕️ 🍮☕️☕️Good”

“Excellent food and wonderful service! The staff goes above and beyond and is extremely attentive to their patrons. The food was delicious. We cannot wait to go back!!”

“My family and I came here yesterday for my Birthday while we were exploring Shelter Island for the day and we had massive amounts of good times and even greater memories. Ice cream was outstanding and the Owner was helpful and courteous. we will be back!”

“We arrived shortly before 3 and they were nice enough to let us in even though the kitchen was about to close. The absolute BEST burger I have ever had. I got the western burger and it was incredible. Service was friendly and fun. We loved everything about this quaint, local “un-Hamptony” spot. Brought me back to the good ole days of East End life. Too bad places like these are disappearing out east.”

“Beautiful views, great service & spectacular food.”

“OMG. We found this place on IG and it is one of the best restaurants I’ve eaten at on Long Island! Everything we ate and drank was beautiful and delicious, and our server was so friendly and accommodating! Every detail was absolutely perfect!”

“We were so excited to celebrate our event last night at what we understood to be the newest 5 star restaurant in Southold. We were left extremely disappointed! Service (sat evening) was awful! The food was terrible. Our waitress eventually made her way to our table to ask for a drink order. We responded that we hadn’t selected a wine yet and she promptly turned on her heels and never returned. The GM recognized that we had been waiting for some time and took our wine order, app order and entree order…by memory. The waitress sometime later returned with our wine. It was the wrong bottle. After back and forth banter we asked to see the menu to indicate it was in fact the wrong bottle of wine. The waitress goes and promptly retrieves what you would hope be the correct wine-no. She returned with yet again the wrong wine. At this point we thru caution to the wind and said, “pour it”! After waiting approximately 30 + min for our appetizers, they arrived. Bread for the table was served when our appetizers arrived and not a moment sooner. The grilled octopus was hot served on cold fingerling potatoes. Odd combination. Kale and goat cheese salad, ok. Raw tuna, delicious. Onto entrees. We waited, at a minimum of an hour to an hour and a half for our entrees. Unacceptable! The chicken was not fully cooked-pink inside. Unacceptable! The Steak au poivre, which is supposed to be made with cracked green peppercorns in brine; was nothing more that steak served with an ABUNDANCE of ground black pepper and little to no sauce. Unacceptable! The Orecchiette with truffle was good. The GM compensated by offering us dessert on the house. This experience at Southold Social was so disappointing that we spent the first 10 min of our ride home just saying, “oh my god that was awful and we we will never return”.”

“Great find! On a chilly winter night Nookies provided the perfect last minute (a rare occurrence, I believe) dinner for two with cool easy vibes and really yummy warming food.

Fun retro decor and neat off the beaten path spot in Southold area.

We also got a nice quick little tour of the motel and would love to stay here on our next visit out!

Will definitely be back!”

“Wonderful! I would say as amazing as the Star in Riverhead and Sip n soda in S.H.

Burgers are like the way the burgers at Bob’s from the animated are described.

Delicious! The server was tired and angry, but not her fault. Just an example of how things gave changed. Not her fault but that fact that someone like her can’t have a living wage off one job. She was probably just tired from the other 2 jobs she had to work to pay her bills. Because America was destroyed by corruption and Uber capitalism.”

“The place is very convenient. I like the coffee and the ambiance is nice and relaxing and also the service was good. The staffs are very nice”

“We visited Croteaux yesterday for the first time and were very impressed with the beautiful ambiance and the wonderful wine and lobster rolls. We will certainly visit again!”

“Great food owner’s and staff very Friendly”

“Service was excellent. Food was delicious”

“Everything we have ever ordered here is fabulous!! Including the kani salad, meatballs, gagootz, and penne with chicken. You get a lot of delicious food for your money and always have leftovers. The service is always fast and pick up is seamless.”

“Food and service was wonderful!”

“Great selection of beers. Such friendly owners. Beautiful brewery, fabulous location!”

“Perfect experience. My wife and I loved our selections. The owner, Tom, stopped by to say hi, which was a really nice touch and what a great guy. Cheers.”

“Tiny hole in the wall you must try!! Instant Favorite in Sag Harbor. My go to is the Spicy Sesame. The owner and staff are so friendly. The food is out of this world with fresh flavors”

“So fun. Such a great vibe.”

“Great French/Asian fusion find in the Hamptons. My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed it. The ambiance was great, and the service was quick.”

“We decided to head over to grab a cocktail ? after dinner. The Black Llama is in Stirling Square. This lounge is situated in the same square of the 1948 pizzeria, American Beach Hotel and Restaurant and the Tree bar. The evening was absolutely perfect. We went on a Friday night and it was a good mix of people at each place I mentioned. The Black Llama had a DJ playing music ?. I enjoyed it. I believe the type of music the DJ was playing is Electronic Dance Music - EDM. The drink menu is unique which is what I expected at this lounge bar. The waiter was super helpful and offered up suggestions. A relaxed atmosphere. We sat outside but I took a look at the inside and it looked great. Our cocktails were delicious. Also, for those who might not want alcohol, they do mocktails. I will go back ! It is a special spot.”

“Hot, cold, iced latte and the food are all amazing!”

“Best meal in Greenport! Chef Umberto was very attentive and sent out some great starters. The Schnitzel was amazing and my family enjoyed their meal. Brendan the manager was also checking in. Highly recommend !”

“Bobby D. was a great host! We loved him and the food and drinks were great!”

“Wonderful first time dining here!”