Shelter Island Slice

$ • Pizza, Beer Bar

Hours today·

About Shelter Island Slice

Shelter Island Slice is a local restaurant known for its delicious and freshly made pizza. The restaurant offers a comfortable dining experience with spacious indoor seating and a big TV for entertainment. The menu features the popular chicken bacon ranch slice and classic margherita slice, as well as their unique and beloved crust. The restaurant also serves the chicken Parm hero, garlic knots, and provides delivery options. The staff is described as friendly and awesome, and the owner, Franky, is praised for his passion for pizza. Customers have enjoyed the true New York-style slices, which are big and delicious. The atmosphere is described as great. The marinara sauce is top notch. It is a great local and family owned business. The food is amazing and everything is delicious.

Menu

Add a Menu
Shelter Island Slice Menu
Shelter Island Slice Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Shelter Island Slice
Shelter Island Slice
View All Photos

Shelter Island Slice Reviews

4.8
104 ratings
5
92%
4
5%
1
3%
Food
4.8
Atmosphere
4.6
Service
4.8

Share your opinion about Shelter Island Slice

Totally worth the trip! Best pizza ever. So great to see Frankie and his team
Finally got to go and see Frank carry on the tradition of Conca In his own way. As expected, the pizza is excellent
Excellent pizza, great service. Got pizza, salad and garlic knots special late Oct 2026. Decent deal especially for the location on SI. Counter guy was very nice and made sure we were all set. Food was excellent and 4 adults are it all, nothing left. Yum, thanks guys!

Read All Reviews(104)

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 11:30AM - 8PM
Thursday 11:30AM - 8PM
Friday 11:30AM - 8PM
Saturday 11:30AM - 8PM
Sunday 11:30AM - 8PM
Updated on: