19 Best Pizza Restaurants near Shelter Island

“Totally worth the trip! Best pizza ever. So great to see Frankie and his team“

“From the moment we walked in, we were greeted by what was quite possibly the most patient host I've ever seen. She was managing a huge crowd with a smile on her face, even while dealing with guests insisting they were owed a table when they weren't. She handled everything with professionalism and kindness.

Once we were seated, we were lucky enough to have Omar as our server, and he was easily the best server in the restaurant. He made sure our table was well taken care of, checked in at the right times, and everything came out promptly, exactly the kind of service we were hoping for. The next time I come back, I'll definitely be asking for Omar.

And the food? I can't lie.. it was absolute FIRE. I'd give the meal an 8/10 overall. Every dish at our table was solid, and I don't think there was a single bad plate.

Thank you to the entire team for making it such a great experience. We'll definitely be back!“

“Excellent. Staff was friendly and courteous. Let not forget how delicious everything was.“

“Everything is delicious at this restaurant and you get generous portions too.“

“great staff and great food. The Chicken Franchaise is delicious“

“Good pizza. Not a chain restaurant. Excellent NY-style pizza on the North Fork. You would think that with the poor water quality for which the North Fork is famous, that pizza would not be that good here, but that is incorrect. The pizza is better than the bagels are on the North Fork. Service was good too“

“Pellegrino‘s is some of the finest Italian food on the East End. It also is a cool place to hang out with a casual vibe with no pretense.. as a local realtor when people ask me, what’s a great restaurant in the north sea area Pellegrino is always the first to come to mind. Great food fantastic service a small, but vibrant bar area or what you’ll find here.
They make a great pizza.
I cannot recommend this place more highly.
Stop in for a bite you will not be disappointed.“

“Great pizza! Love the Buffalo chicken pie!“

“I love this place and have been coming here for years now in both the winter and warmer seasons.

I am a huge fan of margarita pizzas with delicate light red sauce and their create your own personal pizza is just that. It is one of my favorite margarita pizzas around. I've also tried their salad, olive appetizer and appetizer meatballs over the years and they are all delicious in my opinion. I've seen folks order some unique pizza combos while I've been there including an oyster topping on a white pizza, but all have appeared to enjoy.

On a winter night, I love getting a small table and ordering to stay in the warm pizzeria. I. The warmer months, it is delightful to get one of the outdoor seats in the courtyard and enjoy the warm weather.

Occasionally in the warmer months I've noticed that service can be a little slower than I'd prefer, but it has always been friendly and never an excessively long wait for the food for me.“

“So fun. Such a great vibe.“

“The first time I tried the pretzel croissant I became addicted! All of their croissants are amazing... Their coffee is awesome too! So glad it opened in Southold. Lately, they've been making the pretzel croissants into egg sandwich which I'm sure is delicious too, but I prefer to ask for it alone :) Whoever is making these croissants, thank you Chef!!!!“

“I want to rate this 3 stars out of 5. The food is amazing but customer service not that great. My family was in from out of state and wanted to get take out and I instantly thought about this place. my fiance got the food and came home and my order was missing the cheese on the burger. So, I unfortunately couldn't eat with my family and neither did my fiance because he had to eat his food while driving 20 minutes back to get my food fixed at the restaurant and then 20 minutes back. However, I would still recommend you guys to other people. I would just suggest checking your order before leaving“

“My sister and I had the best brownie yesterday we purchased at Harbor Market and Kitchen! They were moist fudgey, chocolatey perfection. ❤️“

“Love love love the food is always amazing the staff is great 💯💯💯💯💯💯💯🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕“

“Born in New York and grew up in Huntington. This is my First time at Romas and visiting mom from Virginia, my son has never been to any authentic New York pizza joints. So when we tried Roma’s, he had the Sicilian and he told the owner “it’s the best pizza he ever ate”. Coincidentally the owner knows Tony from our local pizza place in Virginia. Real glad we got up for some real New York pizza before leaving to go home in little ol’ Virginia.“

“Absolutely loved Crazy Pizza in East Hampton. The atmosphere is lively without feeling overdone, the service was warm and attentive, and the food was genuinely excellent.

Importantly, this is not the place for people expecting traditional, heavy pizza. These are lighter, roughly 500-calorie pizzas with some of the thinnest crust I’ve ever had. Personally, I love that because it feels clean and doesn’t leave you feeling weighed down. But it’s worth knowing going in that this is not deep dish or a traditional NY-style thick crust.

That said, if you like ultra-thin, crisp, flavorful pizza with great ingredients, it really delivers. It has that rare mix of being fun, polished, and still relaxed enough for a casual night out. Great spot for dinner with friends, date night, or bringing people from out of town who want something that feels very East Hampton but not stuffy.

Definitely one of the better dining experiences I’ve had out east. Will absolutely be back.“

“I ordered an Arugula and avocado that barely has avocado with very dried/dead leaf that I m not even sure if it is an arugula. Simply horrible. Will never come back again and won t recommended.“

“The food is excellent and the pizza is even better. There once a week. You will be pleased.“

“Walkable from Southampton Shores. Good stopping point em route to Sag Harbor or North Haven/Shelter Island.“