18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Shelter Island

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Pizza Restaurants near Shelter Island.

Showing 18 of 18 restaurants

  • Shelter Island Slice 3 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island Pizza · $

    1 Shelter Island Slice

    4.8 Superb 104 Reviews

    3 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chicken Bacon Ranch with Marinara Sauce
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

    “Totally worth the trip! Best pizza ever. So great to see Frankie and his team”

  • Brick Oven La Capricciosa Pizza 135 3rd Street Suite 24, Greenport Pizza · $$

    2 Brick Oven La Capricciosa Pizza

    4.6 Superb 199 Reviews

    135 3rd Street Suite 24, Greenport · 2.59 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Broccoli Rabe & Sausage - Large Pie 18 8 Slices
    • Pasta Con Chicken & Broccoli
    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
    • Italian Chicken Noodle

    “Everything is delicious at this restaurant and you get generous portions too.”

  • La Capannina 364 Montauk Highway, Wainscott Pizza · $

    3 La Capannina

    4.6 Superb 179 Reviews

    364 Montauk Highway, Wainscott · 9.56 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Cheese Pizza Slice
    • My Favorite Pizza
    • Pizza Margarita
    • Pepperoni Pizza

    “great staff and great food. The Chicken Franchaise is delicious”

  • 1943 Pizza Bar 308 Main Street, Greenport Pizza · $

    4 1943 Pizza Bar

    4.3 Superb 253 Reviews

    308 Main Street, Greenport · 2.76 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • White Pie with Mozzarella & Garlic Added Caramelized Onions
    • Caesar Salad with Crispy Croutons & Shaved Parmesan
    • Nonna Lucille’S Wood Fired Meatballs
    • Goat Cheese Stuffed Piquillo Peppers

    “1943 Pizza Bar located at Brix & Rye in Greenport is phenomenal! Spot is cute, staff is delightful, and the pizza is fantastic! The clams casino pie we had might have been the best ever. Classic margarita, top notch, New Haven, so good! Make it a point to stop here!”

  • PIZZA UNO INC 46455 Middle Road, Southold Pizza · $

    5 PIZZA UNO INC

    4.7 Superb 32 Reviews

    46455 Middle Road, Southold · 4.78 miles

    Customers’ favorites

    • Caramelized Mushrooms & Onions Pizza
    • Fried Mozzarella Sticks
    • Philly Cheesesteak Hero
    • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    “Good pizza. Not a chain restaurant. Excellent NY-style pizza on the North Fork. You would think that with the poor water quality for which the North Fork is famous, that pizza would not be that good here, but that is incorrect. The pizza is better than the bagels are on the North Fork. Service was good too”

  • American Pie Pizzeria - Bridgehampton 2044 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton Pizza Delivery · $

    6 American Pie Pizzeria - Bridgehampton

    4.4 Superb 210 Reviews

    2044 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton · 9.42 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Meatball Parmigiana Hero
    • Classic NY Cheese Pizza
    • Meatball Lasagna Pizza
    • Pepperoni Pizza Slice

    “Excellent. Staff was friendly and courteous. Let not forget how delicious everything was.”

  • Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant 1271 Noyack Road, Southampton Pizza · $$

    7 Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant

    4.4 Superb 116 Reviews

    1271 Noyack Road, Southampton · 8.15 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Seared Local Calamari
    • Meatball Sliders
    • Eggplant Sliders
    • Arugula

    “Pellegrino‘s is some of the finest Italian food on the East End. It also is a cool place to hang out with a casual vibe with no pretense.. as a local realtor when people ask me, what’s a great restaurant in the north sea area Pellegrino is always the first to come to mind. Great food fantastic service a small, but vibrant bar area or what you’ll find here. They make a great pizza. I cannot recommend this place more highly. Stop in for a bite you will not be disappointed.”

  • Pineneck Pizza 3360 Noyack Road, Sag Harbor Pizza Takeaway · $$

    8 Pineneck Pizza

    4.5 Superb 37 Reviews

    3360 Noyack Road, Sag Harbor · 5.11 miles

    • Delivery

    “Great pizza! Love the Buffalo chicken pie!”

  • Brix & Rye 308A Main Street, Greenport Cocktail Bar · $$

    9 Brix & Rye

    4.8 Superb 121 Reviews

    308A Main Street, Greenport · 2.7 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Italian Scallion Pizza
    • Build Your Own Pizza

    “So fun. Such a great vibe.”

  • Harbor Market and Kitchen 184 Division Street, Sag Harbor Pizza · $$

    10 Harbor Market and Kitchen

    4.1 Good 117 Reviews

    184 Division Street, Sag Harbor · 5.54 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Fish Tacos

    “My sister and I had the best brownie yesterday we purchased at Harbor Market and Kitchen! They were moist fudgey, chocolatey perfection. ❤️”

  • Sophie's 730 Main Bayview Road, Southold Seafood · $$

    11 Sophie's

    4.5 Superb 157 Reviews

    730 Main Bayview Road, Southold · 5.14 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Marinated Strip Steak with Steamed Vegetables and Mahesh Potatoes
    • Baked Seafood
    • Pretzel

    “I want to rate this 3 stars out of 5. The food is amazing but customer service not that great. My family was in from out of state and wanted to get take out and I instantly thought about this place. my fiance got the food and came home and my order was missing the cheese on the burger. So, I unfortunately couldn't eat with my family and neither did my fiance because he had to eat his food while driving 20 minutes back to get my food fixed at the restaurant and then 20 minutes back. However, I would still recommend you guys to other people. I would just suggest checking your order before leaving”

  • Stone Street Cafe 54180 Main Road, Southold Cafe · $

    12 Stone Street Cafe

    4.4 Superb 102 Reviews

    54180 Main Road, Southold · 4.62 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Sandwich Display
    • Quiche

    “The first time I tried the pretzel croissant I became addicted! All of their croissants are amazing... Their coffee is awesome too! So glad it opened in Southold. Lately, they've been making the pretzel croissants into egg sandwich which I'm sure is delicious too, but I prefer to ask for it alone :) Whoever is making these croissants, thank you Chef!!!!”

  • Roma Pizzeria 31455 Main Road, Cutchogue Pizza · $

    13 Roma Pizzeria

    3.9 Good 124 Reviews

    31455 Main Road, Cutchogue · 8.18 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Buffalo Chicken Pizza
    • Pepperoni Pizza Pie
    • Marinara Sauce
    • Cheese Pizza

    “Born in New York and grew up in Huntington. This is my First time at Romas and visiting mom from Virginia, my son has never been to any authentic New York pizza joints. So when we tried Roma’s, he had the Sicilian and he told the owner “it’s the best pizza he ever ate”. Coincidentally the owner knows Tony from our local pizza place in Virginia. Real glad we got up for some real New York pizza before leaving to go home in little ol’ Virginia.”

  • Rolling In Dough Pizza 308 Main St, Greenport Caterers · $$

    14 Rolling In Dough Pizza

    5.0 Superb 2 Reviews

    308 Main St, Greenport · 2.76 miles

    • Take-Out

    “Love love love the food is always amazing the staff is great 💯💯💯💯💯💯💯🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕”

  • Sag Pizza 103 Main Street, Sag Harbor Pizza · $$

    15 Sag Pizza

    3.7 Good 293 Reviews

    103 Main Street, Sag Harbor · 5.16 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • San Marzano Pizza and 2 Garlic Knots
    • Sag Harbor Slice of Pizza
    • Tomato & Cheese Pizza
    • Summer Squash Pizza

    “I ordered an Arugula and avocado that barely has avocado with very dried/dead leaf that I m not even sure if it is an arugula. Simply horrible. Will never come back again and won t recommended.”

  • The Pizza Place 2123 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton Pizza · $

    16 The Pizza Place

    3.6 Good 109 Reviews

    2123 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton · 9.43 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Caldo de Gallina

    “1 word CLEAN .FOOD IS SUPER SUPER GOOD.”

  • Porco’s Country Deli 926 Noyack Road, Southampton Deli · $

    17 Porco’s Country Deli

    3.8 Good 129 Reviews

    926 Noyack Road, Southampton · 8.8 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Tuscan Half & Half Ultra Pasteurized
    • Submarine Sandwich
    • Grilled Chicken
    • Chicken Fajitas

    “Walkable from Southampton Shores. Good stopping point em route to Sag Harbor or North Haven/Shelter Island.”

  • Michelangelo Southold 53345 Main Road, Southold Italian · $$

    18 Michelangelo Southold

    3.9 Good 212 Reviews

    53345 Main Road, Southold · 4.77 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Cheese Slice Pizza
    • Eggplant Parmesan
    • Chicken Parmigiana
    • Chicken Piccata

    “The food is excellent and the pizza is even better. There once a week. You will be pleased.”

Pizza Restaurants Nearby

You May Also Like

  • California Pizza Kitchen Wants 1,000 Pizza Vending Machines in Three Years

    California Pizza Kitchen Wants 1,000 Pizza Vending Machines in Three Years

    A pizza from a vending machine takes 90 seconds. California Pizza Kitchen is betting on a thousand of them. The chain has partnered with retail services firm T-Roc Global to install and operate up to 1,000 automated retail machines across 30 U.S. markets over the next three years. The kiosks will go into airports, universities, hospitals, hotels and office complexes, places where a decent sit-down meal is hard to find. CPK will fill each market with a cluster of at least 20 machines before pushing further.

  • A Guide to the Best Pizzerias in Chicago

    A Guide to the Best Pizzerias in Chicago

    Pizza is a huge part of Chicago's food culture, offering a wide variety of styles beyond just the famous deep dish. Here are 10 pizzerias, where you can try this famous food in all its different types. We'll look at old pizza shops that have been around for decades and recent places trying new things with ingredients.

  • A Guide to the Best Pizzerias in New York City

    A Guide to the Best Pizzerias in New York City

    Pizza in New York is a part of the city's culture and history. Each pizzeria has its story, often reflecting the neighborhood's character and the passion of the people who run them. Here are ten of the best pizzerias in New York that you should try.

  • PizzaExpress Plans American Debut After 60 Years in Britain

    PizzaExpress Plans American Debut After 60 Years in Britain

    PizzaExpress, a popular British restaurant chain that's been dishing out what it calls "Britalian" pizza for nearly 60 years, plans to make its U.S. debut in Florida this year. The chain, which generates more than half a billion in annual revenue from its nearly 360 locations across the U.K. and Ireland, isn't just another pizza joint.

  • California Pizza Kitchen to Grow in Nevada and Utah

    California Pizza Kitchen to Grow in Nevada and Utah

    California Pizza Kitchen (CPK) has partnered with multi-unit restaurant operator Sundine LLC to expand its presence in Nevada and Utah. It's CPK's first big franchising deal in the U.S. - and it couldn't come at a better time. The casual dining chain, known for its inventive pizzas, has struggled in recent years to keep stores open.