“Ordered a cheese pie for delivery and it was more affordable than the other nearby options. From placing the order to the delivery driver the staff was very friendly. Plus the pie was delicious! Added a picture of the box because it's a nice touch!“
“My family and I took a walk up main road and Southold, an activity we had been planning for 2+ years We happened upon this little gem. Perfect place to get a snack or a meal with tables and chairs outside to sit and watch people walk by The sorbet was amazing. My daughter will be a super fan for life. Can't wait to try their meals next time.“
“I stop here frequently either before or after my visit to vineyards. Sometimes we pick up a pie or two and head on out, sometimes a few slices in the way back. For Long Island it's good pizza. It's not NYC pizza but it's good. The specialty slices are stacked with goodness. Definitely worth stopping by.“
“Wow ! What an amazing local place . I'd your not local hop on a ferry . Food is delicious and freshly made. Chicken Parm hero best I've had out. Staff super nice and courteous. Doesn't have to be fancy to be so good . Best of all, so friendly priced.“
“Visited Greenport for me and my girlfriend's anniversary, stopped here for some drinks and pizza not expecting too much and were honestly blown away. The owner helped us out in picking cocktails based on our likes and dislikes and they all turned out amazing. The pizza was delicious with many different topping options and you could tell they were made fresh. This place is an awesome little spot in Greenport and I cannot recommend enough. *Ps: mashed potatoes, bacon and caramelized onions on a white pie...just trust me“
“Hands-down, some of the best pizza around! It is always fresh, delicious, and most applicable seeing how expensive everything is which sadly makes it hard to support locals As much as one would want. But They truly are affordable here!. Not to mention accommodating as much as possible. I really like these guys, And the young students they employee. It’s hard to have service, Quantity and quality, but they seem to have all three! ?✌️“
“This place has the best pizza in mattituck right now...if you dont mind paying for it.....i got a pie wit sausage and pepper....4$ for 12 slices of sausage and 4$ for 12 slices of green pepper on a 24$ pizza.... almost 40$ for a pie with few toppings...i know it should be more because it a little better. But i am going to Gran or Lenny's from now on.“
“Wow! You are greeted by friendly staff, and the brick oven pizza is out of this world! The dining area is small, but weather permitting, there is outdoor seating available. If you have to wait, it is definitely worth it! Nonna's oven fired meatballs are to die for! Make sure you ask for extra bread to sop up the tasty sauce. There is a wide variety of specialty pizzas to choose from. You can even create your own. Don't forget to check out their Rolling In Dough pizza truck for your next event! It is worth every penny! Enjoy!“
Pizza • $
“We had a great experience at this Italian pizza restaurant! It exuded that old school Brooklyn style that's hard to find these days. Walking in, it felt like my grandmother was there to take care of us. She was incredibly sweet, attentive, and showered us with love. Now, onto the food - we ordered the SPINACH ARTICHOKE pizza, and it was an absolute delight. The combination of mozzarella, spinach, artichokes, and asiago was a heavenly mix, and it came to our table piping hot and incredibly fresh. We couldn't resist trying the bruschetta, which was a unique treat. The toasted bread was perfection, and the "make your own" bruschetta mix in a small bowl was a fun touch. Garlic bread topped with chopped tomato, basil, garlic, onion, and Romano cheese - pure deliciousness! One of the highlights was Larry's freshly baked bread for the table. Watching the butter melt off that warm, crusty bread was a sensory delight. Personally, I dipped mine in olive oil, and it was a match made in heaven. We also indulged in the spaghetti and GNOCCHI, and each bite took me back to my nonna's kitchen. The potato pasta with Parmesan cheese, paired with a choice of Vodka, Alfredo, Tomato, or Marinara sauce, was a nostalgic taste of home. This place is a definite home run in my book. The ambiance, the service, and, most importantly, the food make it a must-visit. I'll be back for sure, and I highly recommend it to anyone in search of a memorable Italian dining experience!“
“I can’t believe I drove past this place for years. Finally stopped in for dinner with my husband and we loved it so much we came back a week later. It feels local and yet classy. The staff is great, and the food comes out quick, even with a full dining room. Nepolean style pizza is delicious, pasta and gelato from scratch are a must. We are definitely adding this to our rotation of regular spots. Great food for reasonable prices is hard to find out here and they nailed it.“
“This is a great place in the Hamptons. Very real and unpretentious. Service was wonderful and attentive. Basic food is excellent: burgers, salads, sandwiches, etc. And the ambience is really pleasant, mixing the virtues of a good restaurant, a sports bar and friendly pub. Highly recommended!“
“Excellent, high quality, New Haven inspired bar pizza. Well worth the drive out East. The service was incredible. We made the trip out East just for this pizza. When our waiter heard, he told us drinks were on the house. The cocktails were great and the pizza equally as good. If you can, sit downstairs. It's dinky lit and a little more private if you go around lunch time. If made for a very cool experience. I can say with certainty that this is one of the best pizza spots on LI and a must stop at if you're in the area...or if you're a real pizza enthusiast, take the drive.“
“We celebrated my birthday today! Brett was amazing! The whole restaurant sang for me. The food was delicious. I didn’t even care the food took a little time because I was having too much fun. I definitely recommend this gem! Amazing!! Will come “
“First time dining at aMano and I was back 5 days later. The food was excellent and the staff couldn't have been nicer. This is a very welcoming establishment from the moment you walk in. Last night we ate at the bar and again had An outstanding meal and great service. Looking forward to trying more of the menu.“
“I order pizza here pretty regularly but last night I placed an order. They forgot a slice- which they refunded when I called. And I should have checked. However I got the baked pasta trio and the ricotta cheese in the stuffed shells and manicotti and lasagna was sour. It must have gone bad. So that $20 dish was thrown in the garbage. The marina very bland. I admit I was surprised. I chalk it up to life but hope someone checks that cheese because I wasn’t the only one that tasted it. Didn’t feel like calling again to complain after calling during dinner to say I never got a slice. Service is always friendly and prompted. Sometimes it’s busy and some of the reviews here show that they have never worked in a restaurant, especially after 2020- it stresses me out going anywhere. I can’t imagine how it is dealing with these fragile attitudes day in and day out. The ladies up front definitely work hard.“
“Had the pleasure of my wife and I returning to one of our Islands restaurants, Isola last night and was really pleased. It’s nice to begin thinking of enjoying local restaurants after a summer of visitors, guests and other obligations. Really enjoyed the Cioppino with pasta. Sauce was wonderful, rich but not heavy and overbearing. It was filled with seafood, including shrimp, octopus, squid and shellfish. Totally enjoyable nice portion, so that I had enough to take home for lunch the next day. My wife thoroughly enjoyed the swordfish special served over various vegetables. It was prepared to perfection and the caper sauce complemented the entire dish. Really nice place to enjoy that is “affordable”.“
“We first visited Sophie's about 10 years ago-we were not impressed. Mostly fried food served in styrofoam plates and uncomfortable high-top tables. This past fall, we visited Sophie's again (first time in 10 years). WOW-what an improvement! Delicious marinated steak, fantastic clams-on real plates! Beautifully decorated, comfortable dining table and chairs, friendly staff-great food and drinks. We have returned several times since-always satisfied with our dining experience!! My one complaint-don't serve appys with plastic plates.“