Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe
$$ • Seafood, Barbeque
Hours:
41 Smith St, Shelter Island
(631) 749-1851
About Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe
Customers' Favorites
Fried Shrimp
Recent Reviews
Ratings
Menu
Add a Menu
Hours
| Monday | 10AM - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 10AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 10AM - 8PM |
People in Shelter Island Also Viewed
Kyle's
Bakery, Family, Vegetarian
The Islander
Family, Burgers, Pet Friendly
Crabby Jerry's
Seafood, American, Pet Friendly
Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe, located on Shelter Island, is a well-known seafood spot that offers a variety of delicious options. The restaurant, run by owners Jimmy Hayward and his daughter Amanda, is famous for its fried chicken, smoked fish, and a wide assortment of other seafood. The prepared food from their fridge, such as potato salad, cole slaw, and ribs, is also highly recommended. The smoked bluefish and ribs are particularly popular among customers. While parking can be challenging during peak times, the outcome is worth the wait. Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe is a family-run restaurant that provides a personal touch, making it a must-visit for anyone vacationing on the island.