Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe
$$ • Seafood, BarbequeAbout Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe
Customers' Favorites
Fried Shrimp
Recent Reviews
147 ratings
Share your opinion about Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe
This little hole-in-the-wall spot really blew me away! The crab cakes were a little on the mushy side, but the Shrimp Scampi was absolutely phenomenal—quite possibly the best I’ve ever had! It was packed with flavor and the shrimp were cooked perfectly. I’d honestly come back just to have that dish all over again! And even though this is a seafood spot, the fried chicken was another surprise—juicy, flavorful, and definitely worth trying. Can’t wait...read full review
The freshest cleanest seafood. Adian is a master in the kitchen and I always look forward to his specials. It is an institution
What a find … cash only. So fresh and so fresh. Had flounder and shrimps today … might go back for more shrimps … and drooling over that 1/2 lbs pull pork sandwich … need to bring friends lol
Hours
| Monday | 10AM - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 10AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 10AM - 8PM |
Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe, a well-known seafood spot on Shelter Island, offers a variety of delicious options. The restaurant is famous for its fried chicken, smoked fish, and a wide assortment of other seafood. The prepared food from their fridge, such as potato salad, coleslaw, and ribs, is also highly recommended. The smoked bluefish and ribs are particularly popular among customers.
Customers praise the restaurant's food, which is enriched with culture and soul. The fried oysters, baked clams, shrimp cocktail, mac-n-cheese, and cheesecake are particularly popular. The atmosphere and staff are amazing, with the owner, Commander Cody, being a warm and great host. The restaurant is cash-only but well-priced, and the parking is available down the driveway. Customers appreciate the restaurant's black-owned status and the personal touch it provides.
The fish is fresh and perfectly cooked, and the pistachio/ricotta cake is incredible. The prices are reasonable, and the chef and the owner are both very sweet. Whether buying fresh fish or getting a prepared meal, it's always excellent, including the ribs and fried chicken.