Restaurants near Shelter Island Heights

“We visited on Saturday evening during the Thanksgiving holiday weekend. From the moment we entered through the front door, we were welcomed by big smiles, big smells of delicious food, and what felt like a warm hug from a good friend. Classic and palette awakening cocktails. Try the brandade fritters and the best Caesar salad I have ever enjoyed. Sea bass was fresh out of the waters that surround the east end. The burger and the roasted chicken. For sides we ordered the onion gratin, romanesco and French fries. Surprise banana split for dessert. Delicious! See you again soon. Happy Holidays!”

“Great meal last night wit PAWPAW at the Lin Beach House. The intimate setting and stellar service can’t be beat. The food never ceases to surprise me. I always try something new, that I never thought I would eat, and end up loving. Last night the Eel hush puppies blew me away! Can’t wait to come back again!”

“little Fish has the best fish and chips. we found this gem on our Tour of Ireland. excellent staff and excellent food!!”

“Great place. Really enjoyed the food the atmosphere and our waiter Sean was great. Good experience.”

“Best restaurant in the North Fork. Nookies delights year round with imaginative yet unpretentious fare in a cozy former diner on the grounds of the Silver Sands Motel. The chefs lean into the region's stellar local produce right down to the sweet and grassy snap pea martini. You can't go wrong with the seasonal veggie starters, pristine crudo and oysters, house made focaccia and tender pork cheeks or a bronzed roast chicken. Or sit at the counter to preview their menu choices being prepared in a convivial open kitchen.”

“Went to Maroni for the first time today....we split the chicken parm, the chicken milanese, and the penne ala vodka. All of it was amazing!! I can't even choose which I liked best, as all three were so great. Had the meatballs as well, and they were also perfect. One of the best meals I've had in a while, and I have nothing but good things to say.”

“So glad I found this place while visiting Greenport, coffee was excellent, breakfast delicious, selection great, and staff friendly and helpful! Definitely check this place out for breakfast!”

“Wonderful first time dining here!”

“the absolute best vineyard on the north fork x100. we have been here every year for the last 4 years and look forward to it every autumn. great dry rosé and a delicious provençal basket”

“Tastefully decorated and delish. The BLT & Espresso w/ Sweet Creme was yummy. We didn’t have reservations but the Host squeezed us in for a delightful meal. The wait staff was equally accommodating…can’t wait to return….🌻”

“Finally stopped in after meaning to for over a year and we are so glad we did!! Cute inside space with light atmosphere. The bartender was very friendly and knowledgeable about the beer choices. We tried two flights and liked 7 of the 8 we tried. Will definitely be back to try more. They also have an outdoor seating area but it was too cold the day we went.”

“Great Place Friendly service warm welcome”

“the best coffee very good”

“Excellent service and the food was delicious Can’t want to go there again!”

“Food and service was wonderful!”

“Perfect experience. My wife and I loved our selections. The owner, Tom, stopped by to say hi, which was a really nice touch and what a great guy. Cheers.”

“Hot, cold, iced latte and the food are all amazing!”

“Cute little spot- perf for drinks before or after dinner. Small bar section but has additional room for larger parties. Went with couple of friends and able to enjoy room with music and games. Good quality drinks and good service”

“Totally worth the trip! Best pizza ever. So great to see Frankie and his team”

“Good food 🥘 nice ambience”

“Lovely backyard with tables or Adirondack chairs for sipping wine and enjoying appetizers. Friendly staff. Great wines, especially whites and rosés.”

“This is a charming little neighborhood store/restaurant with such a lovely atmosphere. When me and my husband walked in, Barbara greeted us with a warm and friendly smile. We weren’t sure what to order, so I asked for her recommendation, and she suggested the chicken cutlet sandwich.

Following her advice turned out to be the perfect choice. In the kitchen, Tracy—who was just as kind and sweet—chatted with me like an old friend while quickly preparing a huge and delicious sandwich.

Man, the sandwich was enormous, and it tasted amazing. I honestly wondered if it was even possible to get such a generous and flavorful sandwich at such an affordable price.

Tracy is clearly a talented cook, and the adorable lobster dolls handmade by Barbara are absolutely delightful. The two of them seem like humble, gifted people who truly represent the warmth of the East End of Long Island.

The shop itself has a cozy atmosphere, and I especially appreciated how clean and well organized everything was. Me and my husbands are so happy with our experience that we already plan to come back again.

If you ever have the chance, stop by and try their food. You won’t regret it!”

“Best sandwich I’ve ever had, and even better service. Five stars.”

“Excellent! Wonderful tasting, the chardonnay was amazing, the curated top picks tasting is a great starting point. Paired with the cheese board and was a great decision.”

“Everything is delicious at this restaurant and you get generous portions too.”

“It is one of the best and most upscale wineries on Long Island. The wine selection is very large with some great roses, whites and reds. They also have a very delicious sake cider. The service was also great and the view was beautiful. We are red wine lovers and loved their Cabernet and Franc. Their signature rose is also delicious.”

“Really great tasting fish! I got the fish and chips and both were fired perfectly. Tartar sauce was good but ask for an extra one as one is not enough. Be careful on weekend lunch hour as it gets packed and also the food seems to be rushed and doesn't come out as great which would give the rating of 4.5. But overall lovely food and I always come here every summer.”

“Black Sheep is the best bagel shop on The North Fork!!! The food is amazing and the staff is great. Julian, Bobby, Hugo and Jonas are my favorites! They are fast and get your food made quickly. There is always something new to try. Definitely a black sheep girl for life!”

“We had an incredible Valentine's Day dinner at La Costanera in Half Moon Bay. The fixed menu was thoughtfully curated, and every dish was delicious — the oxtail entrée was absolutely amazing and a standout of the evening. The atmosphere was romantic and elegant, making it the perfect setting for a special night. Our dining consultant, Veronica, truly made the experience exceptional. When we noticed that each table had been given a rose but ours was missing, she kindly explained that the hostess should have provided one and personally went downstairs to get one for us. Her attentiveness, warmth, and professionalism made us feel genuinely cared for. Veronica is easily one of the best servers we've had in a long time. We can't wait to return!”