I think they had better re-evaluate thier portion sizes. When I order a 2 scoop cone I expect a reasonable 2 scoop cone. I think I received what was equivalent to 4 scoops...this cone was obnoxious. I had to request a bowl because the ice cream was dripping all over. Luckily we ate it there, outside and had extra napkins. I had a dark chocolate raspberry cone, nothing on them, just didn't care for it. I'm sure they have other flavors that would suit most. My other half had medium chocolate/vanilla twist ,well it was a large and then some. So if you have kids and go here, get the smallest size, cause it's likely to be more than enough. Thier prices were reasonable when you factor in the amount of ice cream you actually get. I was told by the worker larger portions are what they are known for. Me I just want a simple 2 scoop cone. If you have a huge appetite for ice cream, this is your place. Enjoy.
Daniel Greenberg
Sooooo big - get extra napkins good idea - I did not see a bathroom
John Rauber
Good ice cream but they lie on there menu small 1 scoop,medium 2 scoops, and large 3 scoops and that is a lie. The small is the size of 3 scoops the medium is 6 scoops and a large is as big as a football
Joe Miller
Visited Boxcar Barney's for the 1st time! Great Ice Cream! It was a nice way to cool down after a hot day on the lake
Sue Davis
Huge portions and very good! Highly recommend. My friend loved every bite!
Gregory Hoyt
Ice cream is delicious, portions are generous, staff are friendly and can usually handle a long line fairly quickly.
Robert White
Delicious ice cream. Lots of flavors and very generous portions!
Stephanie V.
So good and you get a LOT of ice cream for the price. Vegan options, too.
Peter Kinnally
Awesome ice cream. Great service! Sometimes there's a line but it's totally worth it for the large portions and great experience.
KeviN Martyn
They can serve a lot of people have benches, and even a small soft serve ice cream was a really good size.
A nostalgic must visit that has been updated, we love going to Barney's! Wish there was more shade and a couple more vegan flavors, but glad to see this Lake Chautauqua staple thriving!
Sky Sail
Great selection of hard and soft serve. Larger servings. Food options, but folks come for ice cream. Open till 9 but they stay open till the line is gone. Sometimes as late as 10
I think they had better re-evaluate thier portion sizes. When I order a 2 scoop cone I expect a reasonable 2 scoop cone. I think I received what was equivalent to 4 scoops...this cone was obnoxious. I had to request a bowl because the ice cream was dripping all over. Luckily we ate it there, outside and had extra napkins. I had a dark chocolate raspberry cone, nothing on them, just didn't care for it. I'm sure they have other flavors that would suit most. My other half had medium chocolate/vanilla twist ,well it was a large and then some. So if you have kids and go here, get the smallest size, cause it's likely to be more than enough. Thier prices were reasonable when you factor in the amount of ice cream you actually get. I was told by the worker larger portions are what they are known for. Me I just want a simple 2 scoop cone. If you have a huge appetite for ice cream, this is your place. Enjoy.
Sooooo big - get extra napkins good idea - I did not see a bathroom
Good ice cream but they lie on there menu small 1 scoop,medium 2 scoops, and large 3 scoops and that is a lie. The small is the size of 3 scoops the medium is 6 scoops and a large is as big as a football
Visited Boxcar Barney's for the 1st time! Great Ice Cream! It was a nice way to cool down after a hot day on the lake
Huge portions and very good! Highly recommend. My friend loved every bite!
Ice cream is delicious, portions are generous, staff are friendly and can usually handle a long line fairly quickly.
Delicious ice cream. Lots of flavors and very generous portions!
So good and you get a LOT of ice cream for the price. Vegan options, too.
Awesome ice cream. Great service! Sometimes there's a line but it's totally worth it for the large portions and great experience.
They can serve a lot of people have benches, and even a small soft serve ice cream was a really good size.
Restaurantji Recommends
Sugar cone was burned ,made the ice cream taste bad. When told about it all they did was say sorry and we had to throw it out.
We loved this place. Had the largest ice cream cones ever and it was delicious!! Must visit.
Excellent ice cream, huge serving size. Highly recommend.
A nostalgic must visit that has been updated, we love going to Barney's! Wish there was more shade and a couple more vegan flavors, but glad to see this Lake Chautauqua staple thriving!
Great selection of hard and soft serve. Larger servings. Food options, but folks come for ice cream. Open till 9 but they stay open till the line is gone. Sometimes as late as 10