Restaurants near Mayville

Pueblo Real 43 S Erie St, Mayville Mexican • $
43 S Erie St, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Street Tacos
Chicken Fajitas

“Hubby and I stopped in for lunch yesterday. The restaurant was humming with many guests and servers buzzing around. We were promptly seated and viewed the impressive menu. We were pleasantly surprised to be given salsa and warm, delicious chips. Very yummy. Our orders were placed and in about 10 minutes, we were served our meals. Lovely presentation for both lunches which were very tasty. Service was excellent. We were both very pleased. We will be back and recommend giving them a try.”

4.8 Superb146 Reviews
Tulip's Brunch House 186 S Erie St, Mayville Pet Friendly • $
186 S Erie St, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

French Toast
Gravy and Eggs
The Benedict

“We have eaten here a couple of times and every time everyone is so friendly and the food is delicious! For both breakfast and lunch you can't go wrong! They also always have some great speciality coffee and tea options!”

4.8 Superb140 Reviews
Boxcar Barney's 13 West Lake Road, Mayville Ice Cream Shop • $
13 West Lake Road, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Moose Tracks on a Waffle Cone
Brownie Batter Ice Cream
Salty Caramel Truffle
Vegan Cookies N Cream
Cappucino Crunchgf
Cappuccino Crunch
Ice Cream Flight
Brownie Batter
Salted Caramel
Cookie Dough

“bring back baby cones, don't charge if a customer request for a bowl with a cone on top bc kids get messy”

4.7 Superb187 Reviews
Olde Corner Deli 6344 County Touring Rte 54, Mayville Sandwich Shop • $
6344 County Touring Rte 54, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Sandwich
Famous Italian Sub
Beef on Weck

“The best subs anywhere. Remarkable staff. Always immaculately clean. Fast service.”

4.7 Superb122 Reviews
Big Inlet Brewing 6169 Elm Flat Road, Mayville Brewery • $$
6169 Elm Flat Road, Mayville

“Great live music! Impressive selection of craft brews! This time of year (early fall) watch out for the falling apples from the trees! 😂🍎🍎🍎Really enjoy coming here!”

4.9 Superb121 Reviews
Andriaccio's Restaurant 4837 West Lake Road, Mayville Italian • $$
4837 West Lake Road, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Caesar Salad
Calzone
Calamari
Garlic Bread
Tiramisu
Pizza Logs
Shrimp Portofino
Fried Dough
Deep Dish Pizza
Spaghetti and Meatballs

“The eggplant parmesan,lasagna,blueberry coco moijito,red sangria, and tiramisu Where all excellent. The servers,bartender where all very efficient and helped each other out.Highly recommend.”

4.4 Superb376 Reviews
Skylar and Sophia's Lemonade Stand 5985 Fishermans Ln, Mayville Family
5985 Fishermans Ln, Mayville

“Outstanding lemonade for a very reputable price. These little girls work so hard to make their homemade lemonade. Made with fresh spring water and real fruit. What a great thirst qencher on a hot summer day.”

5 Superb4 Reviews
Hartfield Bay Cafe 6040 East Lake Road, Mayville Cafe • $$
6040 East Lake Road, Mayville

“Just had ribs and chicken, YUM! Homemade baked beans were awesome. Big, meaty beef ribs were nice and tender, great prices, and I didn't have to cook! Life's good.”

4.4 Superb20 Reviews
Bellini Lounge 215 West Lake Road, Mayville Burgers • $
215 West Lake Road, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings

“The dining room is spartan and more akin to a hotel's flexible convention space than a dedicated, professional restaurant. Wait staff are attentive but lack the polish of seasoned servers. Food is very good.”

3.9 Good36 Reviews
Redline Drive-in (50's-themed restaurant ) 5117 West Lake Road, Mayville Hamburger • $
5117 West Lake Road, Mayville

“Very nice drive in restaurant varied menu main burgers hot dogs and brats with various toppings and fries straight and curly. Comfortable covered outdoor seating as well as stools at a counter inside. Perry's ice-cream floats and milkshakes.”

3.5 Good53 Reviews
Webb's Carryout + Cafe 115 W Lake Rd, Mayville Coffee Shops • $$
115 W Lake Rd, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Iced Caramel Macchiato

“Amazing staff, service, food and atmosphere, love this place…”

3.5 Good106 Reviews
12

Docks

Docks 7 Water Street, Mayville Seafood • $$
7 Water Street, Mayville

“My husband & I were visiting the Chautauqua area and every other restaurant we went to was closed on a Saturday no less. We stopped at Docks by chance. The decor is not fancy but our meal was excellent and the service was great! We would definitely go here again.”

3.2 Average74 Reviews
Full Strength Coffee Company 55 East Main Street, Westfield Coffee Shops • $
55 East Main Street, Westfield - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brunch Board
Avocado Toast
Full Strength Bowl Eggs Bacon B Spinach Roasted Veggies and Cheese
Chocolate Chip Pumkin Muffin and a Latte
Full Strength Bowl of Scrambled Eggs
Everything Bagel with Egg and Bacon
Caprese Salad with Balsamic
Avacado Toast with Bacon
Lavender and Lemon Scone
Lemon Lavender Scone

“We had our daughter’s baby shower here and the owner and staff were so accommodating and helpful in the planning stages. My numerous questions via email were promptly and happily answered. They were so helpful on the day of the event by providing enough time for set up and decorating; and the food and drinks made by Full Strength were all delicious! This venue was cozy and perfect for our moderate scale number (30+) of guests attending. I would definitely recommend Full Strength for a great place to meet for a coffee and a treat, or for a special event that you are planning!!”

4.8 Superb143 Reviews
Bemus Point Inn Restaurant 4958 Main Street, Bemus Point American • $
4958 Main Street, Bemus Point - 9.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich
Cinnamon Bun
Sausage
Waffles
Jumbo Cinnamon Roll
English Muffin
Steak & Eggs w Hash Brown Casserole & Toast
11 Eggs Bacon Home Fries Toast
French Fries
Creme Brulee

“Great people great food 😎”

4.9 Superb285 Reviews
Village Restaurant 5447 East Lake Road, Dewittville Breakfast • $
5447 East Lake Road, Dewittville - 3.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Roll Pancakes
Chocolate Chip Pancake Bacon Egg
Eggs & Homefries
Mashed Potatoes
Sausage Gravy
Chicken Wing
Toast

“Great food, great people, and great atmosphere! She makes everything homemade and everything’s delicious. Trust me if you haven’t been there you need to go.!”

4.9 Superb167 Reviews
The Parkview Restaurant 3 East Main Street, Westfield American • $
3 East Main Street, Westfield - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Pot Pie
Eggs Benedict
Gourmet Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Soup
Tomato Bisque and a Ruben
Fantastic Chicken Salad
The Parkview Cold Plate
Chicken Pesto Sandwich
Chicken Caesar Salad
Citrus Shrimp Salad
Neptune Benedict

“Chicken Caesar wrap was amazing! Haven’t had grits this good since being in the south. Highly recommended”

4.8 Superb241 Reviews
Red's Best Pancake House 2749 County Touring Rte 15, Sherman Breakfast • $
2749 County Touring Rte 15, Sherman - 10.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Great Pancake and Sausage Breakfast with Coffee and Orange Juice
Pancakes with Homemade Sausage Pure Maple Syrup
Pancakes with Homemade Sausage Patties
Extra Sausage

“Looking to support locals, then head to Red's. The best pancakes you will get anywhere and the syrup is to die for good. Oh and smiling faces greet and serve you in a cozy lodge with the fireplace crackling. Get them while you can!!”

4.9 Superb129 Reviews
The Cornerstone - family restaurant and bakery 104 E Main St, Sherman American • $
104 E Main St, Sherman - 8.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich
Salad
Cherry Cobbler with Vanilla Ice Cream
Rodeo Burger and Fries
Breakfast Pizza
Homemade Bread
Western Burger
Mashed Potatoes
Sausage Gravy
Fish Fry

“Cute establishment and friendly people, they even remember your crazy haystack salad requirements ;)”

4.9 Superb94 Reviews
Lake Life Café 22 Main Street, Bemus Point Coffee Shops • $
22 Main Street, Bemus Point - 8.73 miles

Customers` Favorites

Avocado Toast
Croissant
Wrap
Frozen French Toast Latte
Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Sourdough Toast
English Muffin
Italian Panini
Basil Chicken
Greek Salad

“Fantastic spot for hosting events! Had my bridal and baby shower at Lake Life Cafe. Helpful, kind management and staff willing to accommodate essentially any needs/wants, great food, great beverages, and great atmosphere. Highly recommended for your next event!”

4.7 Superb168 Reviews
Portage Pie 42 North Portage Street, Westfield Bakery • $
42 North Portage Street, Westfield - 6.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Concord Grape and Peach Pie
Peach Blueberry Pie
Strawberry Rhubarb
Red Raspberry
Key Lime Pie
Apple Crumb
Blackberry

“Coworkers ordered a coconut cream pie & cherry pie, they are so delicious! I live in Erie PA and will travel just to order mine for the holidays!”

4.8 Superb168 Reviews
Brazill's on Main 7 East Main Street, Westfield American • $$
7 East Main Street, Westfield - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pan Seared Sea Scallops
Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Seafood Cake
Squash Ravioli
Apple Walnut Salad
Stuffed Mushrooms
With Banana Peppers
Bruschetta Crostini
Pan Seared Scallops with Asparagus and Risotto
5 \u0026 20 Beer Braised Short Ribs

“ABSOLUTELY amazing tonight .Tyler and another gentleman ran the entire house flawlessly. and tables were pretty steady.. a couple beside us was passing through from Toronto to Cleveland and their young children sat beside us . every plate of food that came out looked delicious!! they had chicken Alfredo on special Their calamari is on point! We had the strip steak and the scallops with risotto. lobster bisque. was rhe soup. you get a great dinner starting from $25-$40. includes soup or salad and bread with house made dipping oil. AMAZING This new chef is off the charts !!! The restaurant is so very clean as well. price point in my opinion is under priced for portuon sizs and dining experience. This is a gem. get to Westfield”

4.7 Superb114 Reviews
Annex 25 25 East Main Street, Westfield Bar • $$
25 East Main Street, Westfield - 6.04 miles

“Stepping into Annex 25 is like being transported worlds away to a utopia of friends, music, fine wine, and so much more! Julie and Jenna and all the staff have curated an atmosphere that is fun, beautiful, comfortable, and family friendly! It’s something you MUST experience to understand! Check out the schedule for the remainder of this season and head to Westfield to discover this local treasure!”

5 Superb30 Reviews
Tap Room & Grill 43 East Main Street Suite 1303, Westfield Bar • $
43 East Main Street Suite 1303, Westfield - 6.04 miles

“my grandfather used to own it the people there are still as great as they always were and they still have rat cheese”

4.7 Superb67 Reviews
Jacks Barcelona Drive In 8249 1st Street, Westfield Italian • $
8249 1st Street, Westfield - 7.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Perch Sandwich
Taco Salad
Coffe
Shrimp Burger
Cheeseburger
Chicken Parm
Coleslaw
Italian Sausage Hoagie and Curly Fries
Fish Fry and Onion Rings
French Toast Platter

“Fantastic stop on a journey! The food was stellar, the staff was wonderful, and the atmosphere was supreme!”

4.6 Superb202 Reviews
Quagliana's Bark Grill 14 East Pearl Street, Westfield American • $$
14 East Pearl Street, Westfield - 6.37 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lasagna
Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Parmigiana
Veal Parmigiana
Select a Pasta
Select a Sauce
Fish and Chips
Dinner Salad

“Found this gem last night by accident and I was blown away by how great the food was. Love the old building and classic atmosphere. The history of the building and the staff was fantastic. We will most definitely be back”

4.6 Superb208 Reviews
Buttercream Babe 33 East Main Street, Westfield Bakery • $
33 East Main Street, Westfield - 6.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie and Brownie
Blackberry Lime Cupcake

“Oh my goodness Buttercream Babe is YUMMY! Their chocolate chip cookie was truly exceptional…and I have a lot of cookie eating experience!!! Cupcakes too…what a GREAT spot!!! 😊😊😊”

4.7 Superb51 Reviews
CJ's Pizza & Subs 77 East Main Street Suite 1305, Westfield Pizza • $$
77 East Main Street Suite 1305, Westfield - 6.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Leone Calzone
Party 1-Topping Pizza & Bucket of Boneless Wings Combo
Homemade Chips
Steak Sub
Great Pizza
Curly Fries
BBQ Chicken
Meatball Sub
Supreme Pizza
Fried Picke Spears

“Best bbq chicken wing pizza around!! Stuffed crust too!!!”

4.6 Superb131 Reviews
Larry's Cantina Restaurant 11-13 North Portage Street, Westfield Bar & Grill • $
11-13 North Portage Street, Westfield - 6.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Fries
Clam Strip Basket
Bernies Wings
Pickle

“The shrimp basket is my faveeee.”

4.6 Superb121 Reviews
The Green Door Tavern 4739 NY-430, Bemus Point Bar • $
4739 NY-430, Bemus Point - 6.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Complimentary Popcorn
Peanut Butter Pie
Jumbo Buffalo Wings - Single 10
Jumbo Buffalo Wings - Double 20
Turkey Bacon Cheddar Wrap
Half Order Chicken Wings
Medium Chicken Wings
Mac Salad - Large
Hot Ham & Cheese
Combo Platter

“As a lifelong Buffalo,NY fella, I have to say the crispy/drenched in hot Buffalo Wing sauce wings I had at the Green Door are the equal of the best I’ve had in my home town. My partners burger was great as well. Great time at the Green Door!”

4.6 Superb189 Reviews
Green Arch Restaurant 41 W Main St, Brocton Diner • $
41 W Main St, Brocton - 9.79 miles

“Stopped in for a Mother’s Day celebration for lunch a day early because everywhere is a mad house on Mother’s Day. Jen was our server and she was wonderful beyond words. The food came out quick and hot. It was delicious! Their menu was awesome- we will definitely be back because there’s so much more to try!”

5 Superb49 Reviews