Webb's Carryout + Cafe
115 W Lake Rd, Mayville
(716) 753-3960
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
This business is closed and still accepting payments for gift certificates online. They cashed my $50 payment in May 2024 and my parents were informed when they went to use the gift certificate that the restaurant closed in October 2023. DO NOT GET SCAMMED BY THIS BUSINESS!!
Inaccurate listing of hours…not open during the winter
Love the coffee and smoothies. Wonderful staff!
Parking: Large paved lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Iced Caramel Macchiato
Our waitress, Reese was fantastic! So attentive and accommodating. Some of the best service we have ever had!
The food was good overall. I had the chicken piccata and it wasn't what I expected. Just wanted to try something different. Should have gotten the prime rib since it is delicious. Service was great and the restaurant is beautiful inside and out.
We got hot cappuccino's the first day we stopped by they were good, but the real rockstar is their ice caramel macchiato which we tried today. I don't know what they do to it, but it was the best one I've ever had and I drink an obscene amount of coffee. Highly recommend stopping by and trying one!
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 4
We had a wonderful time. The food was very special and the chef was willing to prepare it without the olives that I don't care for — delicious. The atmosphere is good — not special but good. Overall the experience was the best kind of old fashioned dining. And we could hear one another — so both the service - and more importantly , the chance to have a special meal with my husband was very rewarding.
The Mediterranean Chicken I selected as my entree was to die for. Truly incredible. I had never had a sauce like it before. Tastes vary, so take that into account My wife had the Saturday prime rib special, a teal.value.
Walleye was a big disappointment. Having enjoyed it for years, I won't order it again. Too "bready", rice pilaf not tasty, etc. $35 (3 of us ordered) too much for a bad meal.
Not being a meat eater I was hesitant to dine here. Limited appetizer and salad choices led me to the mahi-mahi dinner. Firm fish, tasty rice pilaf, tender grilled corn on the cob with complementary delectable dinner rolls and butter. Thoroughly enjoyed my meal and you can't beat the view!  Service was consistent without being annoying. Staff is well trained in Customer Service. Will return but would like to see a few more seafood and vegetarian options.
Restaurantji Recommends
Very disappointing meal. It was a simple fish and chips that arrived with a very strange version of coke slaw. The fish was soggy, the French fries honestly resembled burned sticks with taste to match. We felt sorry for the poor waiter tasked with delivering this mess. We have gone to Webb's for thirty years. Clearly they have lost their mojo. We were told one of the owners was cooking that night - suggest he try hiring a cook.
The food is always good. It has pleasant atmosphere. There is bar area where you can eat and and ask an upstairs deck. They have a large menu. They have specials on different days of the week.
This is a VERY average restaurant. The restaurant itself is not unattractive. The servers are friendly--but the service is extremely slow and uneven. The portions are ridiculously large, and the food is quite average. There seems to be no awareness of how slow the service is. Unfortunately, this is an area where there are very few dining options...
The walleye was mushy. The bacon-wrapped filets were barely cooked, and had to be sent back. This was after a discussion about what they considered to be medium. The grilled mushrooms didn't come until my steak was almost gone. Baked potatoes were cold. Had to ask for rolls/butter several times. One of our party requested sparkling water which came after three requests. Prices are on the high side. We had been looking forward to a great dinner, but were very disappointed.
While we do not go frequently (once or twice a year typically), we have been going there for decades. Always a pleasure. Always good food. Always good service. Always recommend Webb's to others. I've seen some negative reviews and have to wonder whether they were at some other place than Webb's. Or were they those "always impossible" types of customer.
Loading...