Bagels Your Way Cafe
2799 NY-112 # 8, Medford
(631) 758-6467
Customers' Favorites
Sausage Egg and Cheese on a Rainbow Bagel
Bacon Egg and Cheese with Hash Browns
Reese’S Stuffed Cookies
Featured items
EGG SANDWICH... Soon-To-Be; Almost World-Famous
FRESH MADE TO ORDER EGG SANDWICHES. ALWAYS MADE WITH FARM FRESH EGGS.
Bagel with Cream Cheese/Spread/Butter
Home Fries
Our Soon-To-Be Famous Home Fries "CRISPY POTATO CUBES"
Hungry Dude Sandwich [3 Eggs, Ham, Bacon, Sausage, Cheese]
3 eggs, Bacon, Ham, Sausage, Cheese.
Iced Coffee
DELI Sandwiches
Fresh Sliced, made custom to order. :) let us know how you like it.
Hash Brown Patty
Omlettes
Choose any 3 ingredients! Customize as you like :)
Hot Coffee
EGGS + OMLETTES!
EGG SANDWICH... Soon-To-Be; Almost World-Famous
FRESH MADE TO ORDER EGG SANDWICHES. ALWAYS MADE WITH FARM FRESH EGGS.
Bagel with Cream Cheese/Spread/Butter
Omlettes
Choose any 3 ingredients! Customize as you like :)
Hungry Dude Sandwich [3 Eggs, Ham, Bacon, Sausage, Cheese]
3 eggs, Bacon, Ham, Sausage, Cheese.
Home Fries
Our Soon-To-Be Famous Home Fries "CRISPY POTATO CUBES"
French Toast (awesome!)
With syrup and butter. 6 WEDGES topped with powder sugar!
BLT
Hot Coffee
Hot Tea
Bagels & Spreads
Bagel with Cream Cheese/Spread/Butter
1 Dozen Assorted Bagels
Please let us know your favorites, otherwise we will assort them for you :)
Jelly & Cream Cheese
SLICED Nova Lox - Smoked
Smoked sliced nova lox
Salad Sandwiches
Chicken Salad Sandwich
BLT
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Veggie Tuna
Country/Waldof Chicken Salad
Egg Salad Sandwich
Whitefish Salad
DELI
DELI Sandwiches
Fresh Sliced, made custom to order. :) let us know how you like it.
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
Fresh Breaded white meat, cooked crispy & golden brown
***For HERO we recommend at least 2 cutlets***
Bagel with Cream Cheese/Spread/Butter
BLT
SLICED Nova Lox - Smoked
Smoked sliced nova lox
Hot+Fresh+Sides
Hash Brown Patty
Home Fries
Our Soon-To-Be Famous Home Fries "CRISPY POTATO CUBES"
Hot Cakes
With syrup and butter.
French Toast (awesome!)
With syrup and butter. 6 WEDGES topped with powder sugar!
SAUSAGE LINK - SIDE
Oatmeal
STEEL CUT OATMEAL. CHOOSE 3 ADD IN's
BACON - SIDE (2 slices)
Two Strips of our thick-sliced Fresh Farmhouse Bacon
French Fries
SAUSAGE PATTY - SIDE
TURKEY-BACON - SIDE (2 pcs)
2 Slices of Premium Turkey Bacon
HAM - Side (2 slices)
Served hot, two slices of ham.
PLANT BASED BACON - SIDE
"morning star" plant based Sausage
Bakery
Small Chocolate Chip Cookie
Fresh Baked Chocolate Chip Cookie
Black & White Cookie
traditional back & white cookie
Reeces Peanut Butter Cookie
Banana Chip Muffin
Apple Turnover
Corn Muffin
Blueberry Muffin
Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie LARGE
Chocolate Chip Muffin
Coffee Cake Muffin
Croissant
Double Chocolate Muffin
Blueberry Crumb Muffin
MINI rainbow sprinkle cookies (3pcs)
MINI Linzer Tart (2pcs)
Linzer Tart LARGE
MINI Milano cookies (3pcs)
GLUTEN FREE Blueberry Muffin (UDI's)
Half Dipped Cookie LARGE
MINI Shortbread Star cookie (2pcs)
MINI Fudge Tart (2pcs)
Milano Cookie LARGE
MINI chocolate sprinkle cookies (3pcs)
Choc Sprinkle Cookie LARGE
MINI Cherry Star cookies (4pcs)
Fudge Tart LARGE
Raisin Bran Muffin
Fresh & Fountain Beverages
Iced Coffee
Hot Coffee
Strawberry Lemonade
Sweet (Southern Style) Iced Tea
Raspberry Iced Tea
Peach Iced Tea
Blue Raspberry Lemonade
Unsweetened Iced Tea
Fresh Squeezed Lemonade
Pink Lemonade
Hot Tea
FRESH NY APPLE CIDER! LOCAL & FRESH
FRESH NY APPLE CIDER - LOCAL
Fruit Punch
DECAF Iced Coffee
Fresh brewed iced decaf coffee
Deli Iced Tea
Bottle Beverages
Tropicana OJ 12oz
PURE PREMIUM (SUBSTITUTION of similar will be made if out of stock)
Nesquick - Chocolate
Yoo Hoo -GLASS BOTTLE
Tropicana APPLE Juice 12oz
PURE PREMIUM (SUBSTITUTION of similar will be made if out of stock)
Tropicana OJ CLASSIC 14oz Carton
PURE PREMIUM (SUBSTITUTION of similar will be made if out of stock)
RED BULL 8.4oz
Coca-Cola®
Coca-Cola Soda
Nesquick - Strawberry
Snapple Lemon Iced Tea 16oz
Snapple Peach Iced Tea 16oz
Diet Coke®
Diet Cola
Gatorade 20oz BLUE
cool blue
Ginger Ale 20oz
Hal's Ginger Ale
DR. Pepper 20oz
Poland Spring Water
Sport Cap Water
Snapple Raspberry Iced Tea 16oz
Tropicana OJ+PINEAPPLE CLASSIC 14oz Carton
Tropicana OJ+CALCIUM CLASSIC 12oz
PURE PREMIUM (SUBSTITUTION of similar will be made if out of stock)
Pepsi 20oz
Tropicana OJ+STRAWBERRY+BANANA CLASSIC 14oz Carton
Nesquick - Vanilla
MONSTER ENERGY - GREEN
RED BULL (SUGAR FREE) 8.4oz
Tropicana GRAPE Juice 12oz
PURE PREMIUM (SUBSTITUTION of similar will be made if out of stock)
Diet Pepsi 20oz
MONSTER ENERGY - WHITE
Tropicana GRAPEFRUIT 10oz
PURE PREMIUM (SUBSTITUTION of similar will be made if out of stock)
Gatorade 20oz GREEN
Lemon -Lime Green
V8 100%25 Veggi Juice
12oz
Sprite®
Lemon Lime Soda
Tropicana PINEAPPLE + MANGO SPLASH 12oz
Celsius -MANGO
Tropicana OJ+SOME PULP CLASSIC 12oz
PURE PREMIUM (SUBSTITUTION of similar will be made if out of stock)
Cherry Pepsi 20oz
wild cherry pepsi
Nesquick - Double Chocolate
Simply OJ 12oz
12oz (SUBSTITUTION of similar will be made if out of stock)
Root Beer 20oz
Tropicana CRANBERRY 12oz
PURE PREMIUM (SUBSTITUTION of similar will be made if out of stock)
Gatorade 20oz RED
Simply RASPBERRY LEMONADE 12oz
(SUBSTITUTION of similar will be made if out of stock)
Simply FRUIT PUNCH 12oz
(SUBSTITUTION of similar will be made if out of stock)
Mountain Dew BLUE 20oz
BLUE
Gatorade 20oz ORANGE
orange
Cream Soda 20oz
PRIME - RED
PRIME - BLUE
PRIME - GREEN
Mountain Dew RED 20oz
mountain dew red
Seltzer/Club Soda 20oz
Hal's
Mountain Dew 20oz
Celsius - FANTASY VIBE
Celsius - WATERMELON
MONSTER ENERGY - ORANGE
Nesquick - Strawberry Banana
Orange Soda
Coca-Cola® Cherry
Cherry Flavored Coca-Cola
Celsius - PEACH VIBE
Celsius - ARCTIC VIBE
Celsius - ORANGE
Celsius - KIWI GUAVA
MONSTER ENERGY - PURPLE
# Salads, Fresh Made Daily
Egg Salad (Half Pound)( 1/2lb)
Made From Whole Fresh Eggs.
Chicken Salad (Half Pound)( 1/2lb)
Fresh All White Meat.
Country Chicken Salad (Half Pound)( 1/2lb)
Craisins, Raisins & Walnuts.
Veggi Tuna Salad (Half Pound)( 1/2lb)
Fresh All White Meat.
Tuna Salad (Half Pound)( 1/2lb)
Fresh All White Meat.
Whitefish Salad (Half Pound)( 1/2lb)
Fresh All White Meat.
GROUP DEALS & Catering
Dozen Bagels + 1/2 LB Cream Cheese
12 bagels of your choice & 1/2 LB of cream cheese
1 Dozen Assorted Bagels
Please let us know your favorites, otherwise we will assort them for you :)
Tray of Pancakes
18 Pancakes for a group. (3-4 Inch size) Includes syrup & butter (8x10 Party Tray)
Tray of Scrambled Eggs
Scrambled eggs for a group, (8x10 Party Tray)
1/2 GAL TROPICANA PURE PREMIUM OJ
Coffee 2 GO (includes Milk + Sugars)
Box-Of-Coffee serves 10-15 includes Milk, Stirrers & Sweeteners
Tray of Home Fries
Our soon-to-be-famous Home Fries! (8x10 Party Tray)
Tray of BACON
Real, Delicious, Thick sliced Farmhouse Bacon. (appx 25+ slices)
Tray of Sausage Links
Tray of Sausage Links. (12+ links)
Tray of French Toast
24 Wedges for a group, topped with powdered sugar. Includes Butter & Syrup (8 x10 Party Tray)
Tray of Sausage Pattys
Tray of Sausage Pattys (12+ pcs)
Assorted DELI Wraps Tray
Assorted Home-Made salads (chicken, tuna, egg etc..) & Cold cuts. Includes a pickle tray! Great Group Lunch!
Tray of assorted wraps (12 wraps)
A Delicious & Beautiful Assortment of Wraps Stuffed With Fresh Salads & Boars Head Cold Cuts. Includes Pickle Tray! Serves 12-14.
# Cream Cheese
1/2 Lb Plain Cream Cheese
43467
1/2 Lb Veggi Cream Cheese
1/2 lb.
1/2 Lb Scallion Cream Cheese
1/2 lb.
1/2 Lb Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese
1/2 lb.
1/2 Lb Strawberry Cream Cheese
1/2 lb.
1/2 Lb Jalapino Cream Cheese
1/2 lb.
1/2 Lb Tofutti (Non-dairy) Spread
1/2 lb. Non dairy.
1/2 Lb Tofutti Veggi (Non-dairy) Cream Cheese
1/2 lb. Non dairy.
1/2 Lb Olive Cream Cheese
1/2 lb.
Creamer
Half Gallon Whole Milk
Quart 1/2 and 1/2
Hazelnut Creamer
French Vanilla Creamer
Caramel Macchiato Creamer
Cin-O-Bun Creamer
Irish Cream Creamer
CHIPS N' CANDY
SOUR CREAM & ONION CHIPS
SALT & VINEGAR CHIPS
CHEETOS
JALAPENO CHIPS
BBQ CHIPS
SWEET ONION CHIPS
HONEY BBQ CHIPS
ORIGINAL SEA SALT CHIPS
SWEET CHILI CHIPS
BUFFALO RANCH CHIPS
SALT & PEPPER CHIPS
Photos
+61 photos
+60 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
They have a full vegan menu… one of the only breakfast places I have encountered on Long Island , vegan eggs, vegan cheeses, vegan meats. The prices are affordable too. Right next to the DMV so lots of parking
September 2025
here is a review for Bagels Your Way:
A Gem in Medford! I stopped by Bagels Your Way for a quick bite and was blown away by the experience. The service was super fast, and my order was hot and fresh, exactly what I was hoping for. It's the perfect spot when you need something quick and easy without sacrificing quality.
The owner, JR, and his crew are the real stars here. Their customer service is top-notch, and they made me feel incredibly welcome from the...
A Gem in Medford! I stopped by Bagels Your Way for a quick bite and was blown away by the experience. The service was super fast, and my order was hot and fresh, exactly what I was hoping for. It's the perfect spot when you need something quick and easy without sacrificing quality.
The owner, JR, and his crew are the real stars here. Their customer service is top-notch, and they made me feel incredibly welcome from the...
June 2025
In this tough economy, I like to support small business. I just ordered from here and my sandwich was exactly as I requested. I loveeee the fact that they didn't drown my ice coffee in creamer. They are smart enough to understand its not what people like. Will order again!
May 2025
You May Also Like
Cactus Cafe, Medford - 2799 NY-112
![]()
Tex-Mex, Barbeque
Starbucks - 2775 NY-112
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee