Long John Silver's

606 Broadhollow Rd, Melville
(631) 293-3496

Recent Reviews

John Kerekes

Every now and its worth the ride for KFC and Arthur Treachers

sherry capalbo

Nice service . good food

Debra Domino

Was very salty won't go back not like I remembered.

Dierdre Tinsley

Service was great very polite

Khuram M

Very good experience. Staff is very nice.

Fav Stevens

A bit salty but it was good

Andre Graham

The food was horrible.... An they forgot my ?....

danielle david

Was my first job 25 years ago and the food is still good. Brought my 95 year old grandfather this time.

Michael Chang

The staff was quite pleasant

Nathan D.

My boy Nolan took me here after a long car drive. The restaurant smelled like feces, and I think someone jizzed in the tartar sauce. Yuck. I didn't bother to complain, because he was yelling at a customer for something else. Awful Long John Silvers experience. I did not ring the bell when I left. Screw this place.

Steven V.

During a rainy day, in the middle of a Pandemic, Long John Silvers did great the entire meal! Going through the Drive-thru, the order was placed easily with customer service, shared humor, and attention to detail. The food (fish, shrimp, fries, & hush puppies) was delicious! Couldn't stop eating it! I've been here before and always had good food, & pleasant experiences, and this day was no different other than the Pandemic. If you're anywhere near the area, stop by for some good eats!

Sean Fromann

The fish seemed like it was in the fryer all day. On top of that, the menu simply says "fish." I couldn't really tell what I was eating and I ended up not finishing the meal.

Wendy Maini

Will NEVER go back to this restaurant. The pictures say it all. PLEASE take a look. Trash where the napkin dispenser is, the fish and chicken was cooked in old oil and the burnt pieces stuck to the meat. Catchup packs were stuck together, cobwebs on the lighting. The worst was, we waited to see just how long it would take to be served. 12 minutes. I timed it! Good luck there

Ge Na

Confusing as to whether you can order LJS at drive thru. Price for food was high compared to quality and amount. Hush puppies were awesome

Roby N.

OK, so my friend visiting from Norway is making me basically do a tour of fried chicken locales on Long Island, because he's obsessed. This was a much better experience. Very convenient location on a major thoroughfare. Easy to see from traffic. Well lit, with a clean and busy parking lot. We went in to the establishment this time. The employees are friendly and eager to help the customers. We had to wait for our food, so I found a table. A dirty, sticky table. Gross. After cleaning it myself, and waiting about five more minutes, my buddy came back with the food. The chicken tenders are great! Crispy on the outside, hot white meat chicken inside. A bit greasy, but this is a fish place, so I'm willing to overlook that. The fries tasted like the chicken, and even though that's wrong, I don't want to be right! Ultimate greasy spoon! The restroom was tidy, with plenty of toilet paper and a lovely fresh smelling soap. Way to go! I only took off one star, as I had to clean my own table ... reluctantly ... with my hand sanitizer. Otherwise, everything else was great. I would go back.

Load More