Island Empanada of Merrick

2142 Merrick Ave, Merrick
(516) 608-2663

Recent Reviews

Noah M.

Hey the food is good! I just had the lunch special and it was very good worth the price and the tostones are beautiful nice and fresh. Thanks again! Will come back. The place is very clean so that's a plus.

Soul Imagens

Everybody there is super nice with a destak to the Brazilian girl that is so lovely and patient . It's a shame that I don't remember her name now. Food is great price is right

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ronnie Ettedgui

Has to be by far one of my most disappointing meals. For $4 an empanada I was totally let down. They are so tiny and filled with mostly air. I really don’t think I’ll be going back there. Not really sure how they have stayed in business there. Especially considering the merrick standards. I’m sure they won’t be there for much longer. Better meal would have been a carvel Sunday ……. Less $ and more filling

Otniel Jorge

Excellent great price and awesome service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Beef and Cheese Empanada, Tostones

Nelisa zuluaga

Was served a partially frozen sofrito ball (potato ball) . When sent back the guy exclaimed "oh it was in the cooking a while well put it in the frier a bit longer" empanadas sit in baskets like bagels in a bakery. Wasn't thrilled, even the sofrito ball was under flavored, I could make this at home and so much

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Jacqueline Santos

Love the empanadas ! I ordered the tostones and they were rock hard. I would only recommend ordering

Food: 4

William Tirino

I came in with my daughter, one person ahead of me and the girl at the register was overwhelmed. Very sad to see. After seeing menu with the specials and not being informed of them we sat down...an empty restaurant and my daughter ruined her sweatshirt from grease on a table that was never cleaned... not sure if I would ever come back.

Service: 1

Choco K.

The empanadas were just ok in my opinion. The plus side of them was that they were less greasy than in other places. Service was not the greatest because after we ordered we realized there was a deal that the person at the register didn't offer. Prices for empanadas were not the best and it's definitely a comparison to Colombian spots I've been to. I made this comparison due to the fact that this cuisine is questionable. Puerto Rican cuisine doesn't include the items offered at this restaurant. While the decor shows Puerto Rico as its basis for the cuisine, I have to question the validity of the place. Churros is not a Puerto Rican, and the sofrito wasn't potent in the food. I'd say the food needs some work. For a quick bite sure, but if you're looking for the real deal this isn't it.

dave

I don't know what dumb fools gave this place less than 5 stars. There's no reason to go anywhere else nearby. You can even have them premake a empanada for you additionally, you could go home and bake it or air fry it.

Judith Landaverde

Maybe bad timing but the staff was a group of young guys goofing off talking about things that definitely are not appropriate for the work place. Ordered chicken fingers and fries. . $14 for BURNT BURNT chicken fingers. Legit took a bite and it hurt my tooth. Tasted like old

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kevin H.

First they got the order TOTALLY WRONG!! No sauce like I ordered, left out one shrimp empanada & plantains were BURNT TO A CRISP !! Never Ever spend good money here !!!

Angie H.

Nothing at all special here.Small sample of issues: PLACE >>>>ONLY works for Lactose Safe & Spicy Foods Safe eaters; place is very dull; &, boring; mostly all teen staff, who make lots of errors, very small, TINY, CRAMPED, store space, outdoor bench was removed!!!, -->>heavy priority on to-go orders!!!!!; slow moving, rigid staff; NOT a private: "public bathroom"; very, tiny, cramped, limited waiting space; crowded waiters flood the store; lines always back up onto indoor eaters; no fresh drinks, machine dispensers, no changes in staff service processes ever work out; register transaction process is always rigid and always difficult; shop opens late; &, closes early; far too many loud, wild, crazy, boisterous customers; crowded, lines always inside; &, outside the store; store insides clean, but, -->>always messy; &, -->>never neat; tabletops rarely cleaned; store insides always LOUD; &, NOISY; W/: WAY -->>too much chaotic commotion overall; place is a stress, tension, arguments, fights, anxiety, trouble magnet; atmosphere highly similar to a bar; &, too much constant action at door going in and out; NO food; &, drink products diversity & variety; extremely limited selection; items ONLY taste worthwhile when -->>immediately "fresh"; menu --->>>NEVER changes; ONLY cold drinks available; &, ONLY SUGARY, HIGHLY SWEETENED SODAS; &, DESSERTS AVAILABLE; &, all items ->obscenely ->overpriced; &, ALWAYS RISING; VERY FEW: napkins & utensils ALWAYS, THEY ARE: -->>highly limited; order packing severly deficient; prone to spills, leaks, rips, tears, easy drops, accidents, oily, greasy, staining, smelly spots; drips, breaks, gashes, holes, and, money & food loss; if problems encountered there are NO refunds, NO problem solving, NO owner is EVER on site; NO numbers to call; most customers are dangerous or -->>troublemakers; NO issues ever get resolved; tons of potential explosions between staff & customers are always brewing, this is a Hispanic/Latino version of: "Fast-Food Hell"!;...ETC.Place was a huge hit for convenience; NOT for any quality; which is average to mediocre.A. - [Up-Dated: Tu.-09/12/23.].Vegetarian options: Only a few.Dietary restrictions: Not good for folks with restrictions: everything is fried, cheesed, spiced, pre-packaged, canned, pre-made, wholesaler ordered, limited menu selections, NO variations, NO substitutions, NO alterations, NO modifications are even possible, all-ethnic menu, little to no menu diversity; NO menu changes are ever accepted; made, even the prices stay high and get higher; Nothing but overly sweet desserts, sodas, and, very greasy, oily, heavy, fatty, spicy, cheesy; &, hugely overpriced foods!Parking: Shopping mall lot.Kid-friendliness: Much.Wheelchair accessibility: None.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Rice and Beans, Pork Pernil, Potato Balls, Potatoes Stuffed

James G

good empanadas but way too expensive. I couldn't believe 4 of them came out to like $16. Go to any hood and they're a dollar or two

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

dwight ocasio

Delicious food and good service. The price not cheap but definitely worth it. They have reasonable deals and I get try another excellent tasting empanada with each visit .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mags Ng

Aside from the deliciousness, we loved the variety offered! You have your classics like beef and chicken, and traditional like pastelon and beef and cheese. Can’t wait to try others like chorizo and potato, Pernil and Cuban! Great option to add to our food choice rotation. Bonus, the staff is super sweet!!

Load More