Michael Anthony's

1383 Jerusalem Ave #1342, Merrick
(516) 414-4541

Recent Reviews

Rob Schneider

Reliably delicious choices for take out too!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alisha Fenner

Disgusting employees, for starters a pizza place that’s not Italian is the first mistake. A delivery driver delivered my food elsewhere then picked it back up and bought it to me cold and my soda and garlic knots weren’t included. I had to wait til the next morning to call and they are just so nasty ! A Hispanic man w a heavy accent said “the boss don’t wanna refund I’ll bring you more pizza in 1 hour bye” and hung up. 3 hours later I went up there and asked for my refund and got some girl w some attitude talking about “we called you last night” only the cashier speaks English and I wasn’t leaving until I got my money. They kept tryna refer me to my bank when they the one who messed up! When I asked for the boss myself the boss gave up because she didn’t wanna talk and said give me my money back ! This is disgusting service and they need to be shut down.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sonny H.

In the past, food from this restaurant has been very good, although Sunday nites weather was extremely bad, the football was on and we were looking for some pizza. I called the restaurant and a dizzy person answered the phone, I placed my order, when I got to the restaurant the person I talked to was looking at me very strange. I asked if she was alright, and she immediately asked if I was alright. My order came out it was not what I wanted she continued to act like shit. Long story short, the place must have changed hands again, Pizza was shit.

Jackie Ramkison

Food was

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

andrie clemmons

Pizza was delicious. Freshly made. Warm welcoming service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tiombe Richardson

Atmosphere - none really. JNot really meant to dine

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

Sookdeo Ramkissoon

Well, order a pie and I got a secilia.. it has a bitter taste to it.. don't ordered anything online from here.. save your

Food: 1

Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pie

Paul Bacalan

0.5 went in to check the place out ordered two plane pizzas. The pizza was horrendous paper thin. The cheese was poor quality and just was hanging onto the pizza for dear life. Now moving onto the sauce, horrible texture left a metallic taste in my mouth as if it were out of a can. Overall horrible pizza and pice point was also high for such a sad slice I usually love pizza but today it’s a pass.

Audrey L.

Have been ordering from here for over 10 years. I always get the #2 special, cheese pie, penne a la vodka, garlic knots, salad and a free bottle of soda. I order this every week. Was very disappointed to see that the pasta dish was 1/4 filled. Called to complain and was told that this is how they'd be serving the "special orders" now. Mind you, I ordered the week before and received a order filled to the top of the container! The attitude of the person I spoke to had a "I don't care attitude." I won't be ordering from them again and neither will my school district for catering orders.

Dennis Cortez

Absolutely horrible service. would not recommend it. ordered some food. was told it out be about 30 minutes. this place is only 5 minutes away from my house. long story short, i received my order 2 hrs later, cold. only reason we accepted the delivery is because my wife was starving. had to heat the pizza in our oven.

Patricia C.

Ordered pizza from here many times. But this time I should have known it was going to be bad because it came too fast, wasn't cooked properly. Sausage wasn't done. Really surprised. Usually pretty good.

Divya A.

Good for takeout, this place is pretty busy but services fast. Definitely try to order online for fast service. I got eggplant parm and it was at a good price and tasted delicious. I wish there was more sauce for the pasta, the bottom of my dish was just plain pasta so that was upsetting. But the amount of food you get for price is great! The cheese calzone was also great. Wouldn't mind ordering from here again with more sauce

Robert Goldkranz

Their pizza is ok but their baked ziti was terrible.Sauce and cheese both tasted spoiled.Calzone was another disaster,undercooked,mostly putrid ricotta cheese.

Jordan P.

if I could give this place ZERO stars I would. I would never in my life think about stepping foot in this establishment but my friends got pizza to go from there and I actually have food poisoning been vomiting all night. This place is gross inside too. don't go here it's horrible food

Linda W.

The aunt who owns the pizza place is sooo nasty! She participates in too good to go, but when you come to get your food, she's nasty & she doesn't speak a word of English. It's left over food that's been sitting out all day & she doesn't want to part with it even though she's getting paid. Once I was leaving & the staff was talking about me to a customer & of course I heard & let them know! I went a few times & it keeps getting worse. I'm done! Let them throw their left over pizza in the garbage where it belongs!

Load More