Smith Street Deli

1736 Smith St, Merrick
(516) 546-8925

Recent Reviews

Nicole Espinal

I only come here for breakfast but I love their bacon, egg, and cheese sandwiches! The staff are usually so kind to me and helpful.I also LOVE their blueberry muffins. I’m moving soon and wonder how likely they’d be to share their recipe if I asked nicely LOL

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich

Mike Behman

I’ll take one crumb muffin hold the attitude This deli usually rocks! They offer a wide variety of salads, sandwiches, wraps, cakes, and muffins. The staff is generally very helpful and efficient even during busy times. However, today was an exception.I had a tough time placing a simple order for a crumb muffin with the Asian gentleman at the counter due to language barriers. It seemed like he would be better suited working behind the scenes rather than facing English-speaking customers directly.Despite my repeated attempts to clarify my order for the crumb muffin, there was confusion over whether I wanted "crumb" or "corn." Eventually, after some back-and-forth pointing between different types of muffins and minor misunderstandings about cutting it into four pieces as requested earlier on another item - which he mistakenly took - I received my order with visible frustration from him.It's disappointing that one negative experience can overshadow what is typically considered a four or five-star establishment in terms of quality food and service. Today's encounter felt like an unnecessary battle over something as simple as ordering a muffin

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

t Vega

The food sucks and is overpriced. They burn bagels and rolls like it's nobody's business. I don't bother to go there anymore.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Allen & Zoe Garcia

Delicious food !!!! Very good service!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich

BARTLETT TODD

A little slow when it's busy, it is expensive but the food is good and fresh.

Food: 5

Service: 5

j mac

Great food and friendly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Max Reantinescu

Couldn’t even make some eggs bc it was 30 mins past breakfast no other deli in merrick does this go to the bellmore deli very friendly staff. Also dirty rugs on the seats yuck!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Anita M.

Best deli in Merrick. Lots of staff which helps with getting customers out the door quickly. My go to deli.

Rob Rothman

Nice place, not so great of a sandwich. May as well go to Burger King. Sandwich was cold and small.

George Manasakis

These people make you wait 30 minutes on a text in order and I come 35 minutes after confirmation and order is still not ready which was one chicken cutlet sandwich that the chicken looked raw

Kristen G.

Great spot if you're heading to the beach! The sandwiches are all great (seriously, I haven't gone wrong with a single sandwich choice). They also have fruit bowls and plenty of drink options for your beach coolers! Pasta salads are good but way overpriced for what they are IMO.

Danny N.

This place is a must visit while in Merrick. Great quality food and service. Always better to call in your order, or enjoy Yourself and sit in.

crazy tomato

Terrible bacon egg and cheese sandwich, other food is ok at best

Regina P.

I went in on 8/27 with my daughter who is 8 months pregnant. We ordered 3 wraps and 2 of them were on a gluten wrap and the other needed a certain cheese. The woman who took our order seemed confused. We tried to explain as she wrote on her paper the information. This is not the first time my daughter has gone in there with special dietary request and never had an issue, so this was off to a bad start. The woman dissapeared to the back. After 35 minutes we are asking for our order and noone knew anything. The woman never reappeared and the coworkers just covering up for her. When we realized this was a disaster we left. Customer Service was awful and my poor daughter was in tears. The owner needs to speak to their staff about customer services.

Rob (RobsJots)

Not impressed. Salads are premade with 90% lettuce. Got added grilled chicken. Was shaved, not sliced and cold. Just not what I was expecting. Hero was OK, nothing special

Load More