Athens Diner
837 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island
(631) 775-9888
Customers' Favorites
Hot Open Roast Beef with Brown Gravy
Pancakes or French Toast Deluxe
Quesadilla with Fries
Corned Beef Hash
Grilled Chicken
Steak and Eggs
Corn Beef Hash
French Fries
Greek Salad
Pancakes
Menu
Photos
+17 photos
+16 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Tatiana was incredible! She is outstanding. The food was amazing. I had a gyro with French fries. The gyro was delicious, the fries were fresh and hot. My friend had the Greek salad with gyro meat and he loved it too. The white sauce is excellent. Just the right amount of garlic, the pita bread was warm and tasty. I'm definitely going back. Great food and fantastic experience! Thank you Tatiana!
By far my favorite diner around i have 5 or 6 that are closer to my house and I will drive the extra 10-15 minutes to go here no questions. I would recommend the eggs Benedict and the Irish eggs Benedict is off the charts
Great unexpected find! We stopped by Athens Diner on our way back from Wildwood State Park and it was great. We brought our toddler and we all enjoyed a good Greek diner meal with kind staff. The Moussaka was specifically delicious.
You May Also Like
Shah’s Halal Food - 884 Middle Country Rd
![]()
Halal, Greek, Burgers, Mediterranean
Uncle Ray's Kitchen - 888 Middle Country Rd
![]()
Chinese, Fast Food