Restaurants near Middle Island

Lucia Middle Island 25 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Salvadoran • $
25 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Tacos
Pancake
French Toast
Banana Split
Breakfast Quesadilla
Lucia App
Grilled Chicken
Skirt Steak
Smash Burger
Coconut Chia

“Truly amazing food staff is more than accommodating and over the top friendly they make you feel like family try it one time You won't regret it and I'm sure you'll go back several more times and applying a review much like I am ... ENJOY!!!!”

4.9 Superb76 Reviews
Athens Diner 837 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Diner • $$
837 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Greek Salad
Chef
Hot Open Roast Beef with Brown Gravy
Quesadilla with Fries
Corned Beef Hash

“Food here is always wonderful you get very large portions of the service is always very friendly Zoe was great I recommend it to all great family place friendly ”

4.6 Superb58 Reviews
Shah’s Halal Food 884 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Halal
884 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Sauce
Falafel
Salad
Combo over Rice
Chicken Gyro
Cheeseburger
Lamb Gyro
Chicken and Lamb over Rice
Lamb over Rice Platter
Seasoned Fries

“Salam Alaikum! I ate here regularly before the new owners; I saw the new reviews and was scared to try. The portions are Only smaller because of having to order salad on the side; if you don’t put it down the portions are indeed smaller, I was also given enough sauce for two familys! Fast service; ordered online they had everything ready by the time I arrived.”

4.6 Superb49 Reviews
Rocky Point Road Deli 1519 Rocky Point Rd, Middle Island Deli • $
1519 Rocky Point Rd, Middle Island

“Newer to the area, and was recommended this deli. Have only been here once and food was good, no complaints there. This review though is for the customer service I received today. I called at 1:04pm (google said they closed at 2) and tried to place a pick up order.. the lovely woman on the phone said they had already closed at 1 (winter hrs) but if i can make it there in 15 min she would stay open for me. I was absolutely blown away by how sweet this woman was. I have NEVER had anyone say they would stay open for me after already closing. I did not want to keep them there any longer than needed but will 100% be coming back during regular hours next week. Thank you!”

5 Superb22 Reviews
Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant 1259 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Pizza • $
1259 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Sicilian
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Garlic Knots
Pasta with Tomato Sauce
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Broccoli Rabe
Grandma

“I tried the regular and pepperoni and I really like it. The pizza here is definitely better than the Middle Island Pizza restaurant. Glad ive found some good piza that is close to home.”

4.5 Superb33 Reviews
Mac's Countryside Deli & Catering 61 Half Mile Rd, Middle Island Deli • $
61 Half Mile Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Hero
Chicken Cutlet
Roast Beef
Chef
Egg Whites Avocado Turkey Bacon Whole Wheat w Dash of Hot Sauce
Chicken Marsala
Honey BBQ
Wrap

“The chicken cutlet hero i ordered was absolutely amazing!! Spoke with gentleman behind the counter for a little, very nice gentleman and very good service!!! A+ would recommend to everybody!! Plus i just found out, THEY DELIVER!!! Try this place out, definitely won’t regret ”

4.4 Superb33 Reviews
AYCE Mongolian Grill 848-2 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Mongolian
848-2 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Sauce Bar
Pork Cheese Lo Mein Noodles Green Peppers Onions
Pork Lo Mein Noodles Green Peppers Baby Corn
Spinach Artichoke Rangoons
Build Your Own Stir Fry
Mongolian Barbecue
Cheesecake - Plain
Mongolian Sampler
Beef Stir Fry
S'Mores Crepe

“This place is my new go to! Went to dine in with my family and their food was out of this world. Staff was super nice and explained everything to make a fun experience. 10/10!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian and vegan option. Gluten free option.Dietary restrictions: Has all of their allergies listed on board”

4.1 Good86 Reviews
T's Chicken and Fish Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Chicken Wings • $$
Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Basa Fish Sandwich
Flounder Sandwich

“OMG the fish sandwich I had was soooo good I can’t wait to go back again.Parking: The truck was parked right by the train station, so there was plenty of parking.Kid-friendliness: The staff was very friendly and respectful to all people that came up to buy food.”

4.8 Superb6 Reviews
Panda House 888 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Chinese • $
888 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

“Decided to come here after getting groceries, and some of the food is just amazing! The eggplant with garlic sauce, chicken wings, and orange chicken was very tasty, good price for good food, our family will be back!😁”

5 Superb4 Reviews
Hero lovers and more 291 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Deli • $
291 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Potato Salad
Italian Hero with the Works
Turkey Club Wrap
Macaroni Salad

“I ordered the All American. My husband got the Classic Steak. (It was eaten before I could snap a pic!) They were both delicious, fresh and packed with meat! The bread is sooooooo good. Great service, great value and a buy one get one half off coupon! We will definitely be back!”

3.9 Good30 Reviews
Middle Island Pizza 586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Pizza • $
586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Italian
Everything Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Chicken Cheesesteak Pizza
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
Garlic Knots 12
Fried Calamari
Chicken Wings
Grandma Pizza
Salad Pizza

“Vegetarian options: They have plenty of options for vegetarians, anything made with meat can be made without or substituted with eggplant. It's great and delicious ?Kid-friendliness: It is kid friendly, school parties, sports team parties, birthday parties, and other kid celebrations can be made with a reservation in the back room, kids also like the big pizza man in the front when you're at the counter. It's a great family owned and family friendly pizzeria restaurant!! ?Wheelchair accessibility: They have easy access for anyone in a wheelchair, walker, and or cane. It's so great!! ☺️”

3.5 Good52 Reviews
Lombardi's of middle island 175 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Italian • $$
175 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Vodka Sauce
Meatballs
Spaghetti Carbonara
Clams
Mixed Green Salad
Chicken Parmesan
Home Made Bread

“My husband and I have been trying to go out to dinner for the longest, and finally, we got the opportunity. We chose to go to Lombardi's because it was local and the menu was extensive.This is like a hidden gem in the middle of Long Island. When we got there, we could see other patrons were enjoying themselves. Thankfully it was an older crowd, and we fit right in. No loud drunks, no loud music - the music was perfect for the atmosphere - think Frank Sinatra and the like. This place has a cozy and upscale vibe, with friendly and helpful staff. I would call it a very traditional Italian Restaurant.Let's talk about the food!We were offered a selection of plain or garlic bread. We got the garlic bread and WHOAH. SO SO good I had to control myself because I didn't want to fill up on bread before the food came. I would go back just for that bread lol.The salads that come with dinner are generous and have a nice variety of greens in them. The dressing is chef's kiss! DELISH! They are not small portions either.For dinner my husband got a pasta dish that he devoured and barely spoke because he was so into his food. This is a rare thing my husband is picky about food. I did snag some broccoli rabe off of his plate and I can say now that I want to go back and order what he had next time!I ordered something that actually wasn't on the menu, and before I even finished asking if they could make it, the lovely waitress was like "he can do it" I was astonished because in many places the chef will be a jerk about special requests and some flat out refuse.IT WAS THE BEST CHICKEN PICCATA I HAVE EVER HAD, I was so happy. The portion was huge, the flavor knocked my socks off. This is my all-time favorite dish and I order it everywhere. Lombardi's definitely made it the best.Lastly they have AMAZING coffee lol. The kind of coffee that has a quality taste to it, I suspect it might have been a 100% arabica blend. I drank it black and it was smooth with no bitterness.My hubs had a cannoli that was the size of a house, but I skipped desert because I was too full.There is a 100% chance we will be going back there very often in the future considering we live locally.”

3.4 Good39 Reviews
McDonald's 1175 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Fast Food • $
1175 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Cheeseburger
French Fries
Happy Meal
Mcchicken
Big Mac
Bacon Egg & Cheese Mcgriddles
Mccafé Vanilla Shake
Fish Fillet Sandwich
Chicken Mcnuggets
Big Breakfast

“This McDonald's stands out as one of the better ones I've visited. The food is consistently fresh, hot, and served quickly. I've used the kiosk for ordering, which is a convenient touch. This location truly shines with its exceptional staff and food quality that meets, if not exceeds, the standard expectations.”

3.4 Good40 Reviews
Uncle Ray's Kitchen 888 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Chinese • $
888 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Boneless Spareribs with a Touch of a Bent Stapler
Wonton Egg Drop Mix
Pepper Steak
Egg Roll

“I needed to find a close-to-home chinese take out (Got tired of traveling 25 minutes round-trip) and I heard from neighbors that Uncle Ray won't disappoint. They were right! I had the steamed Gen Tso chicken with chicken lo mein. It was a bit more spicy than I'd like but it was delicious. Their cheese wontons are so crispy too! The teriyaki beef sticks were tender and just the right amount of teriyaki flavor.Parking: convenientWheelchair accessibility: convenient”

3.2 Average24 Reviews

15
Carvel

Carvel 1289 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Ice Cream Shop • $
1289 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

“I absolutely love this place. Not only is the hot fudge better on the cakes then any other competitor, but their ice cream is amazing. Im from Guam, born in Zimbabwe and this is the first ice cream i've had since I got off the boat. Its honestly outstanding service and astonishing food.”

3.4 Good74 Reviews

16
Subway

Subway 750 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Sandwich Shop • $
750 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

“Very polite workers and super hard working! Randall the boss is a great guy and a great boss he always has things under control, and if he’s not there his crew holds the fort down. When I went there one of the workers “Jay” took my order and he did an amazing job super hard working and nice and he is a handsome guy!”

2.2 Poor10 Reviews

17
Subway

Subway 1187 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Sandwich Shop • $
1187 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki
Meatball Marinara
Italian B M T
Rotisserie
B L T

“I like subway sandwiches, they are delicious, the products are fresh and the space is pleasant. I highly recommend it.Parking: No problem to parkBecause there is plenty of space”

2.8 Average20 Reviews
Pupusas City 833 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Fast Food • $
833 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Birria
Revuelta
Chicharrón
Pupusa De Ajo 2 Pieces
Pupusa Loca 5 People
Big Yammy Original
Frijol Con Queso

“Came after work craving some pupusas and it did not disappoint!! The chiccarron pupusas were flavorful but I wish I tasted more meat still cheesy heaven ?. Zucchini and cheese was light and sweet kinda and mixed perfectly with the tall horchata! Horchata tasted a lil watery but still had a creamy cinnamon boba texture the veggie pupusa sandwich was yummyyy!! Need the lights to be turned down or dimmed in the dining section cuz it was too bright. Overall l Def be back ?”

3.3 Good89 Reviews
Good Wok Restaurant 1209 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island Chinese • $
1209 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Tempura Roll
Boneless Spare Ribs
Pork Fried Rice
California Roll
Wonton Soup

“Just tried this place best place ever! If I could rate it 10 stars I would. Will definitely be going back. Amazing sushi great service and staff. Overall wonderful experience and amazing food.”

2.6 Average43 Reviews
The State Room 67 W Main St, Patchogue Gastropubs
67 W Main St, Patchogue - 8.98 miles

Customers` Favorites

Beef Tartare
Dessert
Gulf Shrimp
Bolognese
Cocktail Hour
Risotto

“From the moment we stepped in, the warm and intimate atmosphere set the tone for a fantastic evening. Our server was absolutely wonderful, attentive and added to the overall enjoyment of our meal. As we moved on to our apps and entrees, we were blown away by the interesting flavors and impeccable presentation. It's clear that the chefs at The State Room are truly passionate about their craft. Highly recommend the shrimp and the beef tartare as each was bursting with flavor. We couldn't leave without trying dessert, which was just as delicious as everything else we had. Overall, a wonderful experience!”

4.8 Superb72 Reviews
FLAME HALAL GYRO 499 Sunrise Hwy, Patchogue Fast Food • $
499 Sunrise Hwy, Patchogue - 8.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lamb over Rice
White Sauce
Baklava
Combo over Rice
Chicken Wings
Chicken and Lamb Combo with Salad
Comb over Rice w Lamb & Chicken
Tomato Chicken on Rice
Falafel on Salad
Chicken in Gyro

“This place is hands down the best Halal in Patchogue. The woman asked if it was my first time and then got me a sample of the chicken delicious over rice. Out of control good. Everything is Cooked fresh, and you couldn’t ask for a nicer staff. Do yourself a favor, get the Baklava and well. When I got home I put the extra white sauce on my body and pretended to be a Gyro.”

5 Superb104 Reviews
The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant 154 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point American • $$
154 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point - 9.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cucumber Cream Cheese
Pot of Tea
Afternoon Tea Tier
Mozzarella Sticks
Roast Beef With
Egg Salad
Tea Pot
Served on Enriched Bread
Tea Sandwich of the Day
Finger Sandwiches Scone

“The vibe and atmosphere of this lovely place is immaculate. Immediately, I felt like I was transported in a Victorian picture book.And the food and tea were positively delectable. The taste of that white chocolate scone with the cream and strawberry jam still lingers on mind.Delia has crafted a delightful little place here and I wholeheartedly recommend.”

4.9 Superb114 Reviews
TIESTOS RESTAURANT 411 W Main St, Patchogue Latin American
411 W Main St, Patchogue - 9.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Quesadillas
Salad
Fajitas
Nachos
Tacos
Brownie Bomb
Chaulafan
Bandeja Paisa
Ecuadorian Churrasco Churrasco Ecuatoriano
Eggs Benedict

“Friendly staff. Everyone said hello as you walk in. Food was amazing. Everything tasted fresh. Had the Arroz Con Pollo. Very tasty. Had the tres leches for dessert. Best tres leches I ever had. Very delicious. Look forward to eating from here again.”

4.7 Superb74 Reviews
Ruta Oaxaca Mexican Cuisine 30 E Main St, Patchogue Mexican • $$
30 E Main St, Patchogue - 8.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chips and Salsa
Tres Leches Cake
Fish Tacos
Shrimp Tacos
Coffee Flan
Beef Short Ribs
Ceviche
Fresh Guacamole
Quesadillas
Enchilada Mole

“I’ve been to Mexico & South America many times & nothing compares to how delicious this place is. Made with love & real ingredients unlike anything I’ve ever had. The drinks were to die for!!!”

4.7 Superb223 Reviews
Taco Island Mexican Cantina 5507 Nesconset Hwy Suite #16, Mt Sinai Tex-Mex • $$
5507 Nesconset Hwy Suite #16, Mt Sinai - 5.75 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fries
Chips
Empanadas
Buffalo Chicken
Guacamole
Salsa
Shrimp Tacos
Crunch Taco
Fish Tacos
Carnitas

“I ordered for the first time through DoorDash and they exceeded my expectations! The price is unbeatable, the portions are big and the food was delicious. I can’t wait to visit the restaurant. 10/10 food and I will definitely be recommending.”

4.8 Superb126 Reviews
TGI Fridays 2240 N Ocean Ave, Farmingville American • $$
2240 N Ocean Ave, Farmingville - 5.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Salad
Ribs
Mozzarella Sticks
Sliders
Chicken Wings
Spinach Dip
Fried Shrimp
Mashed Potatoes
Bacon Cheeseburger
Fridays Signature Whiskey-Glazed Burger

“Absolutely great service by Nikki so friendly our whole party of 8 commented what a pleasure it was to eat at TGIF, Nikki recommended which appetizers are really good n she was spot on, she also recommended a drink which was delicious! Be back soon ! Five stars”

4.6 Superb410 Reviews
Joey Z's Restaurant 217 Main St, Port Jefferson Italian • $$
217 Main St, Port Jefferson - 7.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lemon Potatoes
Chocolate Fondue
Stuffed Mushrooms
French Toast
Saganaki
Falafel
Hummus
Z-Pita's Signature Filet Mignon Quesadilla
119 Fried Calamari with Marinara Sauce
Strawberry and Cream Cheese Crepes

“Fantastic meal tonight. We had several food allergies including gluten and dairy. They were amazing at making sure that we had several options to meet all of our dietary needs. The owner came out and explained the menu to us. They were unbelievably helpful and the food was absolutely delicious! I highly recommend the gluten-free/dairy free pizza with dairy free/vegan cheese. Our server, Jenna was fantastic! Everything was wonderful.Dietary restrictions: Gluten-free and dairy free”

4.8 Superb105 Reviews
Hummus Mediterranean Holbrook 1066 Main St, Holbrook Mediterranean • $
1066 Main St, Holbrook - 8.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Salads
Rice Bowl
Salad Bowl
Tzatziki Chicken
Lamb Gyro
Chicken Gyro
Side of Falafel with Sauce
Side of Take Home Hummus
Chicken Kebab Platter
Tzatziki Sauce

“Quick fix for earing healthy and affordable quality. Food to fuel the elite athlete as well as the everyday human. Tastes amazing and nutrition at an all time high with consistency and more of a balanced lifestyle. Between delicious and fitness.... the buffin muffin,overnight oats and prepaid meals make it convenient and efficient for the demanding life of today. Multiple selections and tasty... changed my life. ?”

4.7 Superb157 Reviews
Espo’s Cheese Steak Factory 122 Montauk Hwy, Moriches Cheesesteaks • $
122 Montauk Hwy, Moriches - 8.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheesesteak
Waffle Fries
Cheesesteak with the Works
Buffalo or BBQ Chicken Cheesesteak
Cheese Steak with the Works
Meatballs Smashed
All Cheese Steaks

“Food was great, cheese steak was very good and the bread was on point for the style they make. Will be going again and referring friends. Great local spot and there consistent with the quality of food which is hard to find. Keep up the great work”

4.9 Superb75 Reviews

30
RHUM

RHUM 13 E Main St, Patchogue Caribbean • $$
13 E Main St, Patchogue - 8.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Coconut Shrimp
Duck Empanadas
Tuna Burger
Fish Tacos
Island Burger
Chicken Taco
Buffalo Soldier Taco
Taco Shrimp Tacos Rastaman Tacos
Jerk Chicken with Mashed Potato
Award-Winning Key Lime Pie

“I took my friend there for her birthday on a Sunday. The server recommended the Prickly Pear Margarita-delicious. She checked on us many times to make sure everything was okay or if we needed anything. We had the corn tamales, tacos and a veggie burger. The food was great, service on point. One of my favorite places to eat. Thanks for a great meal. Highly recommend.”

4.5 Superb92 Reviews
map Map