Middle Island Pizza

Name: Middle Island Pizza
Address: 586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, New York, 11953, US
Telephone: (631) 924-0091
Price range: $
Rating: 3.5

$ • Pizza, Soup, Salad

Hours:
586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island
(631) 924-0091

Menu Order Online

Take-Out/Delivery Options

no-contact delivery

take-out

Customers' Favorites

Chicken Cheesesteak Pizza

Eggplant Parmigiana Hero

Everything Pizza

Garlic Knots 12

Sicilian Pizza

Fried Calamari

Chicken Wings

Grandma Pizza

Salad Pizza

Italian

Middle Island Pizza Reviews

3.5 (52)

Write a review

February 2024

Vegetarian options: They have plenty of options for vegetarians, anything made with meat can be made without or substituted with eggplant. It's great and delicious ?Kid-friendliness: It is kid friendly, school parties, sports team parties, birthday parties, and other kid celebrations can be made with a reservation in the back room, kids also like the big pizza man in the front when you're at the counter. It's a great family owned and family friendly pizzeria restaurant!!...read full review

February 2024

Sooo good. Everything there is just amazing. Either you want a regular slice or go crazy with a pasta slice. It doesn't matter they never disappoint. Best pizza place in the area hands down.

February 2024

Pizza is average. Not great average. Chicken caesar salad total trash. Payed 5 extra dollars for 5 2x1 inch strips of chicken. Weighed in at 2 oz of chicken. (yes i weighed the chicken). lettuce was brown. They covered up their brown colored salad with extra parmassean and gave you an extra dressing. Never again. Thanks for wasting my time.

More Reviews(188)