Bagel Cafe

187 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island
(631) 924-3403

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Hungry Man Special
Basket of Bagels
French Toast
Home Fries
Lox Spread
Fresh Lox

Menu

Picked for you
French Toast or Pancakes (3 pcs)
Butter syrup and powdered sugar. Add chocolate chips or blueberry banana.
Hungry Man Special
3 eggs, ham, bacon, sausage, and cheese on a hero.
Bagel Blast (13 pcs)
13 Assorted bagels with your choice of any 2 half-pound butter or cream cheese.
Platters with Home Fries & Bagel
2 eggs with ham, bacon, or sausage, home fries, and bagel.
Bagel Blast Jr. (6 pcs)
6 Assorted Bagels with your choice of 1 half-pound butter or cream cheese.

Breakfast
Eggs (2 pcs) on a Bagel
Includes small coffee or 4-ounce orange juice.
Hungry Man Special
3 eggs, ham, bacon, sausage, and cheese on a hero.
French Toast or Pancakes (3 pcs)
Butter syrup and powdered sugar. Add chocolate chips or blueberry banana.
Order of Home Fries
Platters with Home Fries & Bagel
2 eggs with ham, bacon, or sausage, home fries, and bagel.
Western Omelet (3 Eggs)
Mushroom, green pepper, onion, ham, and cheese with home fries or bagel.
Two Egg Whites on a Bagel
Fresh from the egg.
Healthy Man
3 egg whites, turkey, and Swiss on a hero.
Egg Whites, Spinach, Feta Wrap
3 egg whites, chopped spinach, and crumbled feta cheese on whole wheat or white flour wrap.
Bacon, Eggs Cheeseburger
2 extra-large eggs, 3 slices bacon, 2 slices cheese, and a fourth of a pound hamburger on a fresh bagel or roll.

Bakery Items
Assorted Bagel or Roll (1 pc)
Bagels
Freshly baked bagels.
Bagel Blast (13 pcs)
13 Assorted bagels with your choice of any 2 half-pound butter or cream cheese.
Bagel Blast Jr. (6 pcs)
6 Assorted Bagels with your choice of 1 half-pound butter or cream cheese.
Crumb Cake
Cookies (Large)
Muffin
Brownies
Muffin with Butter

Cream Cheese
Flavored Cream Cheese (1 lb.)
Plain Cream Cheese (1 lb.)
Fresh Lox (1 lb.)
Butter (1 lb.)
Lox Spread (1 lb.)

Homemade Salads
Tuna Salad (1 lb.)
Egg Salad (1 lb.)
Chicken Salad (1 lb.)
Macaroni Salad (1 lb.)
Chef Salad
Lettuce, tomato, carrots, onion, celery, olives, hard-boiled egg, ham, and turkey.
Garden Salad
Romaine lettuce with tomato, carrots and celery, green peppers, onions, and olives.
White Fish Salad (1 lb.)
Potato Salad (1 lb.)
Coleslaw (1 lb.)

Lunch Specials
Turkey BLT
Turkey with bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
Tuna Chicken and Egg Salad Sandwich
Homemade
Bacon Cheeseburger (1/2 lb.)
Lettuce and tomato included.
Philly Cheesesteak
Roast beef with peppers, onions, and Swiss cheese.
Ham or Turkey Sandwich
Our best carving turkey and hams.
Grilled Cheese
American cheese grilled on white or whole wheat.
Roast Beef Sandwich
On a roll or bagel. Lettuce and tomato included.

Coffee, Tea, Hot Chocolate
Coffee
Fresh ground.
Tea
Hot Chocolate

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+7 photos
Photo credit: google
+6 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Delicious! They're so kind too. Amazing bagel deals for an office party. Cost almost 1/3 less than everywhere else I looked. But the best part was the service. It was already later in the day and they didn't have everything we requested. They could've said look this so what we got and that's that. But they baked us a batch of fresh bagels just for our little office party! Heavenly. Don't miss this local gem!
December 2025
That’s definitely a amazing breakfast spot, they all are so loving and always go above and beyond for their customers and I witnessed it but today whoever lady was on register I guess related with owners or one of the Owner I’m not sure about it and I don’t want to because for one coffee and for a few cents, she became so rude and it was an embarrassment because other customers were standing over there. I went there like hundred times I never had such bad experience which...
April 2025
This is by far the best bagel place on Long Island. Great, friendly service - wonderful staff, and consistently superb breakfast foods. Worth the trip. Love them. Thank you for all that you do!
December 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Hero lovers and more - 291 Middle Country Rd
Deli, Wraps
Lucia Middle Island - 25 Middle Country Rd
Salvadoran
Spring Lake Catering Ent. - 30 E Bartlett Rd
Caterers, Golf, Golf Lessons

Bagel Cafe

187 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
(631) 924-3403