Went in to get a freshly made brown bonnet and was told they can’t make them - I would have to wait a few hours for one!!!! Went to give me a frozen one and I said no thanks and left!!!
Andrew Anker
Always the best soft ice cream. Friendly staff. Nice and clean
hurricanesteve65
Need to give the only person behind the counter on a friday night a huge raise
C L
Loved the Lemon Berry soft serve
ROYAL GAMING SQUAD
Horrible way to do business there. I got an ice cream there I was talking to the guy I wanted a large ice cream Cause I wanted to see how big it was. So I got the cone of cone, looked exactly like a small he charged me for a large. He told me that all the same, but the prices are different. And he wouldn’t lower the price to the small. I told him that’s not how you do business that’s not right to rip people off. I’m not happy you guys do this all the time I’m done up charging people. Carvel always has good ice cream But not the service
Eddy Gonzalez
Line out the door. Waited 20 mins to place my order. Poor girl working by her self.
Claire Moran
The team at Carvel did an amazing job creating a golf theme 30th birthday custom cake. The design was exactly what I asked for and better! Thank you so much! I highly recommend ordering a custom cake for any of your party needs.
steven heyman
Did not have the taste it was know for. Very plain tasting
Pat Hoolan
I have been going to the Middle Island Carvel for many years. The store is always clean, staff friendly and professional. Last week I ordered my son’s birthday cake. It was perfect! Not only did it look great, it was delicious. The ice cream was fresh, the “crunchies” were crunchy. The fudge topping was awesome. Don’t buy Carvel in a supermarket. There is no comparison.
This review is based off of a purchase I made about 2 years ago, however, through a local community page other people have experienced the same thing and i think it is EXTREMELY important to put this somewhere I know the owner will see.
So, again about 2 years ago I bought an ice cream cake for a friends birthday. I walked in, i was helped immediately, i asked the guy (young late high school/college looking dude) if the cake i was holding was the regular standard chocolate/vanilla ice cream cake. He said yes. When it was time to eat the cake every single person confirmed there is peanut butter in this cake. I felt terrible and thanked whatever higher power there is that no one was allergic.
I debated many times going in and asking for a refund bc the flavor of peanut butter is so strong it basically punches you in the face. But i decided not to because no one got hurt at the end of the day, and mistakes happen.
However since being made aware that another person experienced this RECENTLY. I’m deciding to make this problem known.
I’m not sure if this carvel is maybe using the wrong flavors OR worse they aren’t properly cleaning their work stations or equipment. Again, I’m not sure, and don’t want to make assumptions as I have never worked in the food industry.
But this isn’t just a “oh the ice cream is made around peanuts” the flavor is so strong! And i have had ice cream from carvel since 1993 never gave i been able to taste the peanuts until i bought that cake…so there must be something weird going on.
Owner, if you read this please do your best to investigate, what’s going to happen eventually is a child going into anaphylactic shock.
Went in to get a freshly made brown bonnet and was told they can’t make them - I would have to wait a few hours for one!!!! Went to give me a frozen one and I said no thanks and left!!!
Always the best soft ice cream. Friendly staff. Nice and clean
Need to give the only person behind the counter on a friday night a huge raise
Loved the Lemon Berry soft serve
Horrible way to do business there. I got an ice cream there I was talking to the guy I wanted a large ice cream Cause I wanted to see how big it was. So I got the cone of cone, looked exactly like a small he charged me for a large. He told me that all the same, but the prices are different. And he wouldn’t lower the price to the small. I told him that’s not how you do business that’s not right to rip people off. I’m not happy you guys do this all the time I’m done up charging people. Carvel always has good ice cream But not the service
Line out the door. Waited 20 mins to place my order. Poor girl working by her self.
The team at Carvel did an amazing job creating a golf theme 30th birthday custom cake. The design was exactly what I asked for and better! Thank you so much! I highly recommend ordering a custom cake for any of your party needs.
Did not have the taste it was know for. Very plain tasting
I have been going to the Middle Island Carvel for many years. The store is always clean, staff friendly and professional.
Last week I ordered my son’s birthday cake. It was perfect! Not only did it look great, it was delicious. The ice cream was fresh, the “crunchies” were crunchy. The fudge topping was awesome.
Don’t buy Carvel in a supermarket. There is no comparison.
Very friendly young attendants
Restaurantji Recommends
Middle Island Carvel did a Great job on making my wife's Birthday cake 🎂, it was Exactly what she wanted and was Delicious 😋.
Thank you so much.
Our cake was perfect. It definitely exceeding our expectations and was delicious. Thank you
Thank You guys again so much for making a beautiful cake for my Bestfriend she loves it and I will definitely come again for future cakes.
I love ice cream, great ice cream. Oh and the Spanish conquistador!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oreo Cookie Sundae Dasher, Carvelanche
This review is based off of a purchase I made about 2 years ago, however, through a local community page other people have experienced the same thing and i think it is EXTREMELY important to put this somewhere I know the owner will see.
So, again about 2 years ago I bought an ice cream cake for a friends birthday. I walked in, i was helped immediately, i asked the guy (young late high school/college looking dude) if the cake i was holding was the regular standard chocolate/vanilla ice cream cake. He said yes. When it was time to eat the cake every single person confirmed there is peanut butter in this cake. I felt terrible and thanked whatever higher power there is that no one was allergic.
I debated many times going in and asking for a refund bc the flavor of peanut butter is so strong it basically punches you in the face. But i decided not to because no one got hurt at the end of the day, and mistakes happen.
However since being made aware that another person experienced this RECENTLY. I’m deciding to make this problem known.
I’m not sure if this carvel is maybe using the wrong flavors OR worse they aren’t properly cleaning their work stations or equipment. Again, I’m not sure, and don’t want to make assumptions as I have never worked in the food industry.
But this isn’t just a “oh the ice cream is made around peanuts” the flavor is so strong! And i have had ice cream from carvel since 1993 never gave i been able to taste the peanuts until i bought that cake…so there must be something weird going on.
Owner, if you read this please do your best to investigate, what’s going to happen eventually is a child going into anaphylactic shock.
Loading...