Amber's Sub Shop
125 W Main St, Middletown
(845) 342-4814
Customers' Favorites
Turkey and Roast Beef Sub
Grilled or Fried
Made Fresh Daily
Buffalo Chicken
Macaroni Salad
Chopped Cheese
Seafood Salad
Italian Combo
Honey Mustard
Chicken Salad
Menu
Photos
+23 photos
+22 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I have lived in Middletown since 2019, and have been looking for someplace to make this simple chicken cutlet sandwich. AMBER made it perfect! I felt like I was in heaven. PERFECT! She is my new GO TO SUB SHOP! She also made me feel like a SUPERSTAR while I was there, friendly great atmosphere! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!
Food is pretty nasty, breakfast sandwich taste like grill hasn't been cleaned.
But the biggest issue is the owner Amber herself, she recently bought garage next door, so I brought my car to get an oil change and my car then started stalling, I went back to talk to the mechanic that worked on it for more information and she interrupted her own employee speaking loudly almost screaming over the mechanic. She was giving me her diagnosis. Even though she's not a mechanic...
Sandwiches are amazing & a good price ! They definitely add more meat than any place around , The service is amazing as well, everyone always has a smile on their face and seems very happy to be there .
You May Also Like
Tapped - 22 Henry St Unit #2
![]()
Gastropubs, Cocktail Bar, American, Vegan, Vegetarian
Caputo's Pizza - 36 James St
![]()
Pizza, Wraps, Italian, Vegetarian