Bakery Plus

383 NY-211, Middletown
(845) 344-2529

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Strawberry Shortcake

Raspberry Cheesecake

Birthday Cake

Sheet Cake

Photos

+41 photos

+40 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Grubhub

Doordash

Recent Reviews

If your looking for a THE BEST TASTING MOST DELICIOUS, Freshest, Quality, Cakes or Pastries this is the place to go!!! We have been buying Our Sons Birthday Cakes here for the past 17 years!!! Along with pastries for special occasions and Holidays and we've never been disappointed. And everyone always, always asks us where we got it from. Every single time. So if your looking to make a lasting impression and have to bring a Desert to a party or just having a party yourself...

December 2025

We have been buying Our Sons Birthday Cakes here for the past 17 years!!! They are Hands Down the BEST CAKES you will ever get or find anywhere around here!!! For the past 17 years every year without fail we have somone or multiple people ask where we got the cake from because they Absolutely love it that much and the rest of the people including my sons look forward to it every single year. They will not eat any other cake!!!! The Owner is Absolutely Amazing and I fully admire...

February 2025

Best Bakery hands down!!
Cakes are stellar and delicious. The pastries are fresh and absolutely yummy 😋 There's so many options of baked goods. Some of our favorite are the Boston cream cake slice, the sugar cookies and the cinnamon chip coffee cake.
The staff are always welcoming helpful and knowledgeable. We always get our personalized birthday ice cream cakes here as well.

February 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Middletown, NY

Bakery Plus

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Bakery Plus