Coney Island Diner

10 Railroad Ave, Middletown
(845) 343-3714

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Patricia Mendoza

I did a DoorDash order for 2 eggs and their house made corned beef hash. I’ve had it before and it was amazing. NOT today. It was straight from a can. It looks like dog food and tastes awful. My whole reason for ordering from here was because they made homemade corned beef hash. Do NOT false advertise. It’s a sure way to ruin your business. Very disappointing.

Exod Impact

I went there Friday morning to get some food for me and my family since we wanted to try something new, but while I was in my car trying to look at the menu and on the phone to see what they wanted a random guy comes and knocked on the window of my car and gives me a piece of paper for them basically threatening me to tow my car and the guy just said “idk the owner sent me” so that’s a great way to be greeted so I just left so if you plan on going walk or hang a huge sign on your car saying that you’ll be inside in a moment so yeah not returning

Service: 1

Vin Brady

This place is always good, great breakfast or lunch spot. If you are into hot dogs and chili then I absolutely recommend you try the coney dogs, Im addicted, really tasty.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julian Miranda

Nice little spot for a quick bite to eat they cleaned the tables nice before I ate and were very friendly id definitely come again and looking forward to it

Chorvas

Food was great

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kevin Hill

no more homemade corned beef hash! can't make an over easy egg to save their lives. Garbage!!!!! I will never eat breakfast here again!!!! SUCKS!!!!

Bonita Morgan

I only been there twice. Each time, I got the turkey and cheese on a roll. The turkey is seasoned well. The chips are amazing. The price was reasonable. Stop by this restaurant. You won't be disappointed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Angelina

Thank you Rish for your courteous service. Living in Westchester, it is always fun to visit restaurants with Long Island names in upstate NY. This is a nice traditional diner, service was great, breakfast specials were properly priced and portions were perfect. My favorite item? The bacon was great!!! The parking, restaurant and bathrooms were handicapped friendly. We plan to make this our breakfast nook for attending Orange County Fairgrounds.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Raf El (raffleticket)

We enjoyed our delicious breakfast and great customer service!

Vegetarian options: I had a delicious vege omelette!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Omelette and Home Fries

Anusha Tomar

No-nonsense spot with friendly staff and good portion sizes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

T J- Mann

Ordered pick-up before opening time. Unfortunately the homemade cornbeef hash definitely set in a fridge uncovered ( tasted sour) over medium eggs were over done. While the price when ordering through clover is much cheaper then ordering pickup through DD. If You are an early eater this is not the place. Homefries lacked seasoning more of a simple boil potato ?.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Joshua Sanchez

Good food burger was well done

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Dip

Richard McMickle

1st time going there and it will be my last. Food was edible, but nothing I would go out of my way for. Fries were very bland. Customer service was not very good either. Funny thing is they have coke signs on the wall but they serve Pepsi. Overall an experience I would not do again.

guymard

Been coming here for decades!Still, great people friendly staff, good eats!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Marilyn

Couldn't even put not one star. I ordered breakfast. It was eggs and pancakes the eggs. I said over medium they came overheard. Look like egg salad. The pancakes were ice cold the next day I order soup. They give me 9 salts, not even a pepper. I go over there. The boss is refusing to do anything about it. Tell me all I'm gonna watch the cameras and see how many salt and pepper they gave you. And then he never came out the back. Never gave me my money back. This place has gone downhill. We need a new restaurant in Middletown downtown. Beware of the new owners rude beware food disgusting. Beware, they don't know how to cook.

Loading...