Coney Island Cafe

10 Railroad Ave, Middletown
(845) 343-3714

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Raf El (raffleticket)

We enjoyed our delicious breakfast and great customer service!

Vegetarian options: I had a delicious vege omelette!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Omelette and Home Fries

Anusha Tomar

No-nonsense spot with friendly staff and good portion sizes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

T J- Mann

Ordered pick-up before opening time. Unfortunately the homemade cornbeef hash definitely set in a fridge uncovered ( tasted sour) over medium eggs were over done. While the price when ordering through clover is much cheaper then ordering pickup through DD. If You are an early eater this is not the place. Homefries lacked seasoning more of a simple boil potato ?.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Joshua Sanchez

Good food burger was well done

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Dip

Richard McMickle

1st time going there and it will be my last. Food was edible, but nothing I would go out of my way for. Fries were very bland. Customer service was not very good either. Funny thing is they have coke signs on the wall but they serve Pepsi. Overall an experience I would not do again.

guymard

Been coming here for decades!Still, great people friendly staff, good eats!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Marilyn

Couldn't even put not one star. I ordered breakfast. It was eggs and pancakes the eggs. I said over medium they came overheard. Look like egg salad. The pancakes were ice cold the next day I order soup. They give me 9 salts, not even a pepper. I go over there. The boss is refusing to do anything about it. Tell me all I'm gonna watch the cameras and see how many salt and pepper they gave you. And then he never came out the back. Never gave me my money back. This place has gone downhill. We need a new restaurant in Middletown downtown. Beware of the new owners rude beware food disgusting. Beware, they don't know how to cook.

Dominick Fernandez

Parking: Good

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Loaded Hot Dog with Fries

CHRISSY BROWN

Homefries taste like chemicals. Pancakes weren’t cooked all the way and they want to charge $14. Ridiculous stay away from there.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Angel

Good place for breakfast and lunch

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Egg Scramble Bowl

Jayden Rheel

Undercooked eggs and soggy toast, the food wasn't cooked properly and tastes off. They're not that hard to cook correctly so I don't understand what the issue is.

Bhr HgZ

First of all service is amazing, Gustavo was very nice and helpful. Food is really good, my kids loved it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Victor Ocampo

I’ve been getting the same sandwich over the past 2 years, $ 8.00 dollars for a grilled croissant with 2 slices of Turkey and 2 slices of cheese, after new ownership same sandwich today i pay $13.75 this is ridiculous, no wonder why the restaurant looks so empty now, this people needs to relax with this prices, taking a vantage of the customers that take the bus and on the go customers, not fair

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Amanda Rodriguez

My first time going to Coney Island after hearing it had new owners and it’ll be my last time. While I was underwhelmed by my food being bland it was their customer service that is losing my business. I first hand witnessed the woman behind the counter be racist towards another customer. The woman came in and upon listening to her try to order a coffee I could tell she was not English speaking. She asked for a medium to which she was told they no longer did that size. The lady clearly did not understand and to which the the woman behind the counter became ruder in saying “we don’t do medium, do you understand?” Then proceeded to get a Spanish speaking employee from the kitchen and told him to talk to “Mexican lady” She got her coffee then went to sit and wanted to order food, again with the same woman from behind the counter. Most likely unable to read English the customer pointed to a picture of food and said “like this” to which the woman said “What you just want the steak? I don’t understand” then walked off and got the Spanish speaking employee again and said to him “go get order from Mexican lady” I had never seen such terrible and racist customer service come from Coney which I’ve been frequenting for 15+ years throughout all their ownerships. It is rude to assume what someone is and terrible to treat them as less due to lack of communication. The area is highly diverse and highly trafficked due to the location and bus station, if you do not have the patience for the constant diverse language of clientele then don’t serve.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kim Holewienko

Food was absolutely cold and disgusting bathrooms were disgusting

Loading...